Originally published 2019-05-14.

Yes, New York bans plastic carryout bags. Lawmakers approved the ban in April 2019 as part of the state budget, making New York the second state after California to outlaw the thin plastic sacks handed out at checkouts. The law took effect on 1 March 2020, and after a court fight and pandemic delays, the state began enforcing it on 19 October 2020.
If you shop in New York today, the short version is simple: stores that collect state sales tax cannot give you a plastic carryout bag. Bring your own, buy a reusable one, or take a paper bag, which may cost five cents depending on where you live. Below is what the law covers, what it leaves out, why it was passed and what researchers have learned about whether bag bans actually help.
Why New York acted
The scale of the problem was the main argument. Before the ban, New Yorkers went through more than 23 billion plastic bags a year, according to the state Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC). Most were used once, for a few minutes, between a till and a kitchen.
Lightweight bags are hard to recycle in ordinary curbside systems, where they tangle in sorting machines. Those that escape end up snagged in trees, blowing along highways or floating in rivers and the sea, where wildlife can swallow them or become entangled. Because conventional plastic does not biodegrade, it breaks into smaller and smaller fragments rather than disappearing.
Then-Governor Andrew Cuomo had pushed for a statewide policy partly to end a patchwork of local rules. New York City had already passed its own bag fee in 2016, only for state lawmakers to block it in 2017. A single state law settled the question for everyone. When the deal was agreed in Albany, Cuomo said plastic bags had blighted the landscape and clogged waterways, and State Senator Todd Kaminsky, one of the bill's champions, predicted that people would one day wonder why such a rule had not always existed.
What the law bans and what it allows
The rule applies to anyone required to collect New York State sales tax, which covers supermarkets, pharmacies, convenience stores, clothing shops and most other retailers. Those businesses may not provide plastic carryout bags to customers. Large stores also have to keep collecting plastic bags and film for recycling.
The exemptions matter, because they explain why you still see plastic in some places. According to the DEC, plastic is still permitted for:
- wrapping raw meat, fish, poultry or other unwrapped food;
- bulk items such as produce, grains, sweets and small hardware;
- food sliced or prepared to order, such as deli counter items;
- restaurant takeout and prescription bags from pharmacies;
- newspaper delivery bags, garment bags, and trash or food-storage bags sold in packs.
The logic is that these bags do a job that a reusable tote cannot easily do, such as keeping raw chicken away from other groceries. The ban targets the bag you are handed at the register to carry things home.
A "reusable bag" also has a strict meaning. Under state rules it must be made of washable fabric or another durable material, be designed for at least 125 uses, and have handles that do not stretch. After a court ruling, these bags must be entirely non-plastic, so a thick plastic bag labelled "reusable" does not qualify.
The five-cent paper bag fee
Paper bags remain legal, but the law lets cities and counties opt in to a five-cent fee on each one. New York City was among the localities that chose to charge it. Where the fee applies, the receipt must show it separately along with the number of bags.
The money is split. The state comptroller sends 40 percent to the participating city or county, which must spend it on buying and handing out reusable bags, with priority for low- and fixed-income communities. The remainder goes to the state's Environmental Protection Fund. Shoppers who pay with SNAP or WIC benefits are exempt from the fee.
Stores that break the rules first receive a warning. After that, DEC can fine a business $250 for the next violation and $500 for each further violation in the same calendar year.
From law to enforcement
The start date of 1 March 2020 arrived just as Covid-19 reached New York. Within weeks, many shops stopped accepting customers' own bags over hygiene fears, and the state agreed to hold off on enforcement.
A second delay came from the courts. Plastic bag manufacturers sued to stop the law and the DEC rules that put it into practice, and enforcement was put on hold while the case ran. In August 2020 the New York State Supreme Court ruled against them, and DEC began enforcing the ban on 19 October 2020, as ABC7 New York reported at the time.
The video below covers the announcement when the budget deal was first struck.
Which other states ban plastic bags
New York was not alone for long. California approved its statewide ban in 2014, and voters confirmed it in a November 2016 referendum, so it took effect first. Hawaii has no state law, but every one of its counties bans the bags, which amounts to a de facto statewide ban.
In 2019, the same year as New York, Maine, Vermont and Delaware passed their own laws, and Oregon's took effect in January 2020. Connecticut, Washington, New Jersey, Colorado and Rhode Island followed over the next few years. New Jersey went furthest by banning paper carryout bags at large grocery stores as well. Many cities in other states run their own bans or fees, while some states have passed laws that stop local governments from restricting bags at all.
California has also tightened its rules. Shops there were allowed to sell thicker plastic bags labelled reusable, and many people treated them as disposable. A newer law ended that loophole, banning plastic carryout bags of any thickness from 1 January 2026.
Do bag bans actually work?
Bag bans reliably cut the number of plastic carryout bags, but researchers say the full picture is more mixed. Economist Rebecca Taylor studied California cities that banned bags before the state did, and NPR's Planet Money summarised her findings in April 2019, just as New York's law passed.
The bans eliminated about 40 million pounds of plastic bag waste a year. But shoppers who used to reuse grocery bags as bin liners started buying trash bags instead; sales of small four-gallon bags rose about 120 percent. Taylor estimated that roughly 30 percent of the plastic saved came back as thicker garbage bags. Paper bag use also climbed sharply, adding about 80 million pounds of paper waste a year, and paper takes more energy and water to make.
Cotton totes are not automatically greener either. A 2011 UK government study found a cotton bag must be used 131 times to match a single-use plastic bag on climate impact, and a Danish study put the number far higher when other environmental effects were counted. Taylor's own preference was a fee on both paper and plastic rather than a ban on one, and she singled out New York's approach as likely to push up paper use.
None of this means bans are pointless. Plastic bags that escape into the environment cause harm that paper does not, because paper breaks down. The lesson is about habits: the greenest bag is the one you already own, used as many times as possible.
Practical tips for shoppers in New York
- Keep two or three sturdy bags in your car, backpack or by the door so you are not caught out.
- Choose a durable bag you will actually use for years; how often you reuse it matters more than the material.
- Wash fabric bags now and then, especially after carrying raw meat or leaking produce.
- Reuse the paper bags you do pay for, then recycle them.
- Take clean plastic film and any leftover plastic bags back to the collection bins that larger stores must provide.
- If you need bin liners, consider compostable liners or simply rinsing an unlined bin, rather than buying more plastic than the ban saved.
Sources: New York State DEC: Bag Waste Reduction Law; Wikipedia: Plastic bag bans in the United States; NPR Planet Money, 9 April 2019: Are plastic bag bans garbage?; ABC7 New York, October 2020: New York's plastic bag ban now being enforced. Story first shared via Healthy Food House, based on Associated Press reporting.

COMMENTS