Australia’s High Court FGM Ruling: The Queen v A2 Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-10-28.

Australia's High Court Ruling in an FGM Case in 2019

On 16 October 2019 the High Court of Australia ruled that the New South Wales law against female genital mutilation (FGM) covers cutting or nicking a girl’s clitoris, including the clitoral hood, even when no lasting physical damage can be seen afterwards. The decision, The Queen v A2 [2019] HCA 35, overturned an appeal court ruling that had quashed the convictions of three people over a ritual performed on two young sisters.

The judgment did not create a new crime. FGM was already illegal in every Australian state and territory. What the court settled was how far the existing NSW offence reaches, and its answer was: to every form of the practice, including so-called “symbolic” versions.

The case behind the ruling

The case concerned two sisters, believed to have been about six or seven at the time, who underwent a ceremony known as khatna at homes in Wollongong and Sydney between 2009 and 2012. Three people were charged: the girls’ mother, who cannot be named for legal reasons; Kubra Magennis, a retired nurse and midwife; and Shabbir Mohammedbhai Vaziri, a local leader of the Dawoodi Bohra community, a Shia Muslim sect with roots in India. The mother and Magennis were charged with mutilating the girls, and Vaziri as an accessory.

In what was Australia’s first FGM prosecution to go to trial, a NSW jury found all three guilty in 2015. They were sentenced in 2016: the two women served their sentences in home detention and Vaziri was jailed.

The defence argued that the ritual was symbolic and did not cut the girls. Magennis said she used forceps and only touched the area, a practice the ABC reported was described as allowing the skin to “sniff the steel.”

Why the appeal court quashed the convictions

The relevant law is section 45 of the NSW Crimes Act 1900, which makes it an offence to excise, infibulate “or otherwise mutilate” the labia or clitoris of another person.

In 2018 the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal set aside all three convictions. It held that “mutilate” should carry its ordinary meaning, which requires some imperfection or irreparable damage, and that “clitoris” did not include the clitoral hood. A later medical examination had found no visible lasting injury to either girl. On that reading, the court said, the offence was not made out, and it also accepted that the verdicts were unreasonable on the evidence.


ABC Religion & Ethics shared the ruling the day after the judgment.

What the High Court decided

The Crown appealed, and the High Court allowed the appeals by majority. Chief Justice Susan Kiefel and Justice Patrick Keane wrote the leading joint judgment. Their key findings were:

  • “Otherwise mutilates” has an extended meaning. Read in light of the section’s heading and purpose, it covers cutting or nicking a girl’s clitoris, without any need to prove permanent damage.
  • “Clitoris” includes the clitoral hood or prepuce. Reading the word narrowly would defeat the law’s aim of banning the practice in its various forms.
  • The trial judge directed the jury correctly on both points.

Justices Virginia Bell and Stephen Gageler dissented, finding that superficial injury without lasting harm could not in law amount to mutilation.

The High Court sent the cases back to the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal to decide one remaining question: whether the jury’s verdicts were unreasonable on the evidence, now applying the correct meaning of the law. Chief Justice Kiefel noted that a retrial would normally be ordered in such circumstances, but recognised the distress that giving evidence again would cause the girls.

Why the wording mattered so much

Laws against FGM have to work against a practice that takes many forms. The World Health Organization groups it into four types. Type 1 is partial or total removal of the clitoral glans and/or the clitoral hood. Type 4 covers other harmful non-medical procedures such as pricking, piercing, incising or scraping. Many communities that practise a “milder” form argue that it causes no harm and should not count.

Had the appeal court’s narrow reading stood, prosecutors would have needed to prove lasting physical damage, which is often impossible years later in a young child. The High Court’s reading closes that gap. For child protection workers, doctors and teachers, it also sends a clear message: there is no lawful “symbolic” version of the procedure in NSW.

FGM in Australia and around the world

FGM is mostly carried out on girls between infancy and age 15. The WHO now estimates that more than 230 million girls and women alive today have undergone it, across about 30 countries in Africa, the Middle East and Asia, as well as in migrant communities elsewhere. The WHO describes it as a violation of the human rights of girls and women.

Its health effects can include severe pain, bleeding, infection and shock at the time, and long-term urinary, menstrual and sexual problems, complications in childbirth and psychological harm such as depression and post-traumatic stress. The WHO estimates that treating these complications costs health systems about US$1.4 billion a year.

In Australia, the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare published estimates in 2019 suggesting around 53,000 women and girls living in the country, born overseas, had undergone FGM before arriving. Every state and territory criminalises it, and in most jurisdictions taking a child overseas for the procedure is also an offence.

Common misconceptions

“It’s required by religion.” FGM predates Christianity and Islam and is practised by people of several faiths and none. No major religious text requires it, and many religious leaders campaign against it.

“A small nick is harmless.” Even when a cut heals without visible damage, it is a painful, non-consensual procedure on a child with no medical benefit, and the WHO counts it as FGM.

“The ruling made FGM illegal for the first time.” FGM was already a crime. The ruling clarified that the crime covers all its forms.

If a child may be at risk

In Australia, anyone worried that a girl may be taken for FGM, here or overseas, can contact the police or their state’s child protection hotline; in an emergency, call 000. Doctors, nurses and teachers in most states are mandatory reporters. Women who have already experienced FGM can ask their GP about specialist services, which offer confidential, non-judgemental care.

Sources: High Court of Australia, judgment summary, The Queen v A2 [2019] HCA 35; ABC News, 16 October 2019; Canberra Times; WHO fact sheet: Female genital mutilation; Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (2019).

COMMENTS