Originally published 2019-07-04.
Same-sex marriage became legal in Ecuador through a court ruling, not a vote in parliament. On 12 June 2019 the Constitutional Court decided, by five votes to four, that two gay couples who had been turned away by the civil registry had the right to marry. The decisions were published in the official gazette on 8 July 2019, and the first wedding took place ten days later in Guayaquil.

The ruling made Ecuador the fifth country in South America to open marriage to same-sex couples, after Argentina, Brazil, Uruguay and Colombia. It also landed in an unusual week, during Pride month and the 50th anniversary of the Stonewall uprising, when courts and lawmakers in Botswana and Bhutan were moving the same way. Below is what the judges decided, why a court could make this change, what happened next, and why the same season also brought setbacks.
What the Constitutional Court decided
The court heard two cases brought by same-sex couples whose marriage applications had been refused. One involved Efraín Soria and Javier Benalcázar, who had married abroad and wanted their union recognised at home. A majority of the nine judges ruled in the couples' favour and ordered the state to let them marry.
The vote was narrow. Four judges dissented, mainly arguing that the constitution itself described marriage as the union of a man and a woman, so any change belonged to the National Assembly or to voters. The five-judge majority answered that a binding international human rights standard required equal treatment, and that constitutional wording had to be read in line with it.
Because the ruling interpreted the constitution, it applied across the country once published. Civil registry offices could no longer refuse a couple simply because both partners were of the same sex.
The long road to 2019
Ecuador had already gone further than many neighbours a decade earlier. The constitution approved by referendum in 2008 recognised civil unions between two people regardless of sex, while keeping marriage for a man and a woman and limiting adoption to opposite-sex couples. That compromise gave couples some legal protection, but it left a clear two-tier system.
Couples began testing that line in court. In August 2013 Pamela Troya and her partner asked to marry in Quito, and Santiago Vinces and Fernando Saltos did the same in Guayaquil. Both requests were refused, and the cases became part of a slow campaign through the courts.
The turning point came from outside the country. On 9 January 2018 the Inter-American Court of Human Rights published Advisory Opinion OC-24/17, which said that states bound by the American Convention on Human Rights should give same-sex couples access to marriage. Soon afterwards, in June 2018, two family judges in Cuenca ruled for same-sex couples on the strength of that opinion. A provincial court overturned both decisions that September, which made it clear the question would have to be settled at the top.
Why a court could make the change
People are often surprised that judges, rather than elected politicians, opened marriage in Ecuador. The explanation lies in how the country treats international human rights law. Ecuador's constitution gives ratified human rights treaties a very high status, and the Constitutional Court held that the Inter-American Court's opinion was binding and took priority over conflicting domestic rules.
On that reading, the constitutional article describing marriage as between a man and a woman could not be used to exclude same-sex couples. Rather than rewriting the text, the court read it alongside the equality guarantees Ecuador had accepted internationally. Costa Rica went through a similar process after the same advisory opinion, with marriage becoming legal there in May 2020.
This route also explains the closeness of the vote. The dissenting judges did not necessarily oppose equal rights; several argued that a change of this size required a constitutional amendment. That debate, about how far courts should go, continues across Latin America.
The first weddings and what changed afterwards
The rulings took legal effect when they appeared in the Registro Oficial, the government gazette, on 8 July 2019. On 18 July Michelle Avilés and Alexandra Chávez married in Guayaquil, becoming the first same-sex couple to wed under the new rules.
Numbers grew steadily. Official figures cited on Wikipedia record 82 same-sex marriages in 2019, 115 in 2020 and 240 in 2021, and more than 1,000 in total by the end of May 2024. Those figures are small compared with all marriages in the country, but each represents a couple who gained the same inheritance, property and next-of-kin rights as everyone else.
Some differences remain. The 2008 constitution's restriction on adoption by same-sex couples was not part of these cases, so marriage equality did not automatically settle every family-law question.
A remarkable week for LGBTQ rights
Ecuador's ruling arrived alongside two other moves. On 11 June 2019, a day before the Ecuadorian decision, Botswana's High Court unanimously struck down the colonial-era sections of its Penal Code that criminalised same-sex relations, which had carried up to seven years in prison. The government appealed, but the Court of Appeal upheld the ruling in November 2021.
In Bhutan, the lower house of parliament voted on 10 June 2019 to remove sections 213 and 214 of the Penal Code, which outlawed same-sex relations. That was only a first step: the bill went back and forth with the upper house, passed a joint sitting in December 2020 and took effect in February 2021 after royal assent.
The timing carried symbolic weight. June 2019 marked fifty years since the Stonewall uprising in New York, when patrons of the Stonewall Inn resisted a police raid and helped spark the modern movement for gay rights.
Setbacks in the same season
Progress in one country rarely means progress everywhere, and spring 2019 showed that clearly. On 24 May 2019 Kenya's High Court refused to strike down the sections of its Penal Code used against gay men, leaving in place a penalty of up to 14 years in prison. Activists announced an appeal, which was still pending in 2026.
Brunei drew worldwide criticism in April 2019 when provisions of its Syariah Penal Code allowing death by stoning for gay sex came into force. Reports at the time sometimes said Brunei reversed the law, but that is not quite accurate: in May 2019 the government extended its existing moratorium on the death penalty to cover the code. The law remains on the books, and same-sex relations are still illegal there.
Elsewhere, the European Parliament campaign of May 2019 included hostile rhetoric toward LGBTQ people from parties such as Poland's Law and Justice and Spain's Vox, according to rights groups and press coverage. In the United States, the Supreme Court allowed a ban on most transgender people serving in the military to take effect in January 2019. That policy was reversed in 2021 and a new ban was ordered in 2025, showing how quickly these rules can change with each administration.
Advocacy groups counted roughly 70 countries that still criminalised same-sex relations in 2019. Many are in parts of Africa, the Middle East and Asia where religious conservatism strongly shapes politics, although Latin America itself remains divided, with some Caribbean states keeping such laws for years afterwards.
What the Ecuador case tells us
A few points are worth keeping in mind. First, rankings such as "the 27th country" vary depending on whether a count includes territories or countries where only some regions allow marriage, so it is safer to say Ecuador joined a group of fewer than thirty nations at the time. Second, the Inter-American system matters: an advisory opinion issued in Costa Rica shaped rights in Quito and Guayaquil. Third, court victories are only part of the story. Public attitudes, registry practice and family law all take time to catch up.
For the couples who had waited since 2013, though, the meaning was simple. They could walk into a registry office and leave married.
Sources: Wikipedia: Same-sex marriage in Ecuador; Wikipedia: LGBT rights in Botswana; Wikipedia: LGBT rights in Bhutan; Wikipedia: LGBT rights in Kenya; Wikipedia: LGBT rights in Brunei.

COMMENTS