David Attenborough Defends Greta Thunberg: What He Said and Why

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-10-28.

David Attenborough's Support for Greta Thunberg in 2019

Jeff Spicer/Getty Images

In October 2019 Sir David Attenborough spoke up for Greta Thunberg at the launch of his BBC series Seven Worlds, One Planet. Asked about the criticism aimed at the 16-year-old activist, the 93-year-old broadcaster said she had earned her place, and that she was a campaigner rather than a television presenter. His remarks came days after TV host Piers Morgan publicly mocked her, and they were widely read as a reply to critics like him.

Here is what Attenborough actually said, what prompted it, how the two figures came to be linked, and why their exchange still says something useful about how we argue over climate change.

What Attenborough said

Speaking to journalists while promoting the new series, Attenborough described Thunberg’s rise in simple terms:

“Greta Thunberg is there because of her passion, her insight and her concern about the future.” (David Attenborough, October 2019)

He added that she was “a political person” and not a broadcaster, a point that drew a clear line between his own role and hers. Attenborough has spent more than six decades explaining the natural world on screen; Thunberg’s role was to press leaders to act.

He also turned the spotlight on himself with a self-deprecating joke. Still fronting major series in his nineties, he said he imagined plenty of younger people wondering why he did not step aside and give someone else a turn. The quip landed because it showed he, too, had heard criticism for decades, and carried on anyway.

Why Thunberg was under fire in 2019

Thunberg began her school strike outside the Swedish parliament on 20 August 2018, at 15. Within a year, millions of students worldwide had joined “Fridays for Future” protests. In August 2019 she crossed the Atlantic on the racing yacht Malizia II to avoid flying, and on 23 September 2019 she addressed the UN Climate Action Summit in New York.

That speech, in which she told world leaders “How dare you,” made her one of the most discussed people on the planet. Supporters saw a young person saying plainly what scientists had been warning for years. Critics, many of them on the political right, called her alarmist, attacked her age, or questioned whether adults were using her.

Some of the criticism was about policy. Much of it was personal: jokes about her appearance, her autism diagnosis and her emotions. Thunberg has spoken openly about having Asperger’s syndrome and has described it as a strength in her campaigning.

Piers Morgan’s criticism

When Thunberg was tipped as a possible Nobel Peace Prize winner in early October 2019, Piers Morgan, then co-host of ITV’s Good Morning Britain, posted the tweet below asking what she had done for peace and accusing her of frightening children.

He also reportedly called her UN speech melodramatic and apocalyptic, and said he worried it was making young viewers believe the world was about to end. Thunberg did not win the 2019 prize, which went to Ethiopian prime minister Abiy Ahmed.

Morgan had a narrow point: the world is not literally ending on a fixed date, and climate anxiety in young people is real. But scientists broadly agree that warming is driven by human activity and is already making heatwaves, wildfires and heavy rainfall more frequent and severe in many regions, and that more warming brings greater risks to ecosystems and people. Thunberg’s core message was to listen to that science, not to predict doomsday.

Two campaigners from different generations

Attenborough and Thunberg met for a video conversation for BBC Radio 4 in December 2019, when she guest-edited the Today programme, and they have praised each other publicly since. Their partnership mattered because of the contrast: a broadcaster trusted across generations and a teenager who refused to be polite about the pace of change.

Attenborough’s own message had sharpened over the years. Earlier series focused almost entirely on wonder; by the late 2010s, programmes such as Blue Planet II and Seven Worlds, One Planet were showing plastic pollution, melting ice and collapsing habitats alongside the beauty.

The series he was promoting

Seven Worlds, One Planet premiered on BBC One on 27 October 2019. Made by the BBC Natural History Unit, it devoted one episode to each continent, from Antarctica to Africa, and showed how human pressure was changing life on all of them. Hans Zimmer and Jacob Shea worked on the music, and Sia collaborated with Zimmer on the song “Out There” for the series.

What the exchange teaches about climate debates

  • Separate the person from the argument. Thunberg’s age or personality says nothing about whether her claims are accurate. Criticism of a proposal can be tested against evidence; mockery cannot.
  • Go to the source. Her speeches repeatedly pointed listeners to reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which is where the real detail lives.
  • Anxiety is not the goal. Parents worried about children’s climate fears can help by talking honestly, focusing on practical action and limiting doom-heavy news.
  • Experience and urgency can work together. Attenborough’s support showed that respected elders can amplify younger voices instead of competing with them.

Attenborough’s comments were brief, but they were a reminder that the climate conversation is stronger when it focuses on facts and solutions, and when people of every age are welcome to take part.

Sources: Evening Times: David Attenborough says Greta Thunberg's rise is due to passion and concern for the future (October 2019); Wikipedia: Seven Worlds, One Planet; Wikipedia: Greta Thunberg; Piers Morgan on Twitter, 3 October 2019. Lead photo: Jeff Spicer/Getty Images.

COMMENTS