Originally published 2019-06-24.

vizland/iStock
Yes, New York was the first US state to ban declawing cats. Lawmakers in Albany passed the bill by wide margins in June 2019, and Governor Andrew Cuomo signed it on 22 July 2019. Declawing is now allowed in New York only to treat a genuine medical problem, and violations can bring a civil fine of up to $1,000.
Behind the law is a simple point many cat owners do not realise: declawing is not a manicure. It is an amputation. Here is what the procedure involves, what the evidence says about its effects, what the law allows, and how to protect your furniture without surgery.
What declawing actually involves
A cat's claw does not grow from the skin like a human nail. It grows from the last bone of the toe. To stop it growing back, the surgeon removes all or part of that bone, the distal phalanx. The medical name is onychectomy, although vets point out that "phalangectomy" describes it more accurately. In human terms, it is like cutting off each finger at the last knuckle.
The operation is done under general anaesthetic and needs careful pain management. Brian Shapiro, New York director of the Humane Society of the United States, made exactly this point while campaigning for the bill: the procedure is far more than trimming a nail.
Assemblywoman Linda Rosenthal, who sponsored the bill with State Senator Michael Gianaris, put it more bluntly: "It is not like getting a mani/ped. It's a brutal surgical procedure."
What the evidence says about the effects on cats
Research on declawed cats points to real risks, although not every study agrees on how common they are:
- Pain and complications. Reported problems include infection, lameness, nerve damage, claw regrowth and chronic pain. One veterinary teaching hospital reported complications in 50 to 80% of cats after surgery.
- Behaviour changes. A 2018 study by Martell-Moran and colleagues of 274 cats found that declawed cats were far more likely to urinate or defecate outside the litter box, to bite and to show aggression, and almost three times as likely to be diagnosed with back pain. Bone fragments left behind raised the risks further.
- Mixed older findings. A 2001 follow-up study found behaviour problems were "not pronounced", yet still recorded house soiling in 15% and more biting in 18% of the cats.
Animal welfare groups often note the irony that biting and litter-box problems are among the most common reasons owners give up cats, so a surgery meant to keep a cat in the home can end up doing the opposite.
What New York's law allows and forbids
The law bars declawing for cosmetic, aesthetic or convenience reasons. It allows the procedure when it is needed for a medical condition affecting the cat, such as an infection, a tumour or a severe injury to the toe. Violations carry a civil penalty of up to $1,000.
The debate in Albany was not one-sided. The New York State Veterinary Medical Society argued that vets should keep the option in some cases, for example if a cat scratches destructively despite training, or if scratches could put a person with a weakened immune system at risk. Public health guidance on cat-scratch disease, a bacterial infection spread mainly by kittens, focuses on hygiene, handling and choosing pets carefully rather than surgery.
The major veterinary bodies have moved toward discouraging the operation. The American Veterinary Medical Association says it should be considered only after other attempts to prevent destructive scratching have failed or when clawing presents a health risk to people. The Canadian Veterinary Medical Association and the International Society of Feline Medicine oppose elective declawing.
How common declawing was, and where it came from
A 2001 estimate suggested that roughly a quarter of pet cats in North America had been declawed, and surveys found that about 95% of these surgeries were done to protect furniture. The procedure became popular in the United States after a Chicago veterinarian, A.G. Misener, described it in a 1952 letter to the Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association. It spread widely without much scrutiny of its effects, as Minnesota vet Ron Gaskin later told the Washington Post.
Where else declawing is banned
New York was a latecomer by international standards. Declawing is banned or tightly restricted in dozens of countries, including the United Kingdom, much of Europe, New Zealand and Japan. In Canada, most provinces now prohibit elective declawing.
In the United States the change began at city level. West Hollywood, California, became the first city to ban it in 2003, and Denver followed in 2017 as the first city outside California. After New York's 2019 law:
- Maryland became the second state with a ban, in 2022.
- Virginia passed a similar law in 2024.
- Other states, including Minnesota and Washington, have since considered restrictions.
California and Rhode Island also forbid landlords from requiring tenants to declaw their cats.
Myths about declawing
"It's just a deep nail trim." No. It removes bone, which is why it needs general anaesthesia and pain relief.
"Indoor cats don't need claws." Claws are part of how cats walk, balance, stretch and mark territory. Scratching is normal behaviour, not bad manners.
"Tendon cutting is a kinder option." Tendonectomy, which stops a cat extending its claws, is not recommended by the AVMA or its Canadian counterpart either.
Practical alternatives that protect your furniture
- Trim the nails every couple of weeks. Most cats get used to it with treats and patience.
- Offer better places to scratch: a sturdy, tall scratching post, a cardboard scratcher or a sisal mat, placed next to the furniture your cat already targets.
- Make favourite targets unattractive with double-sided tape or sticky sheets while the cat learns to use the post.
- Try soft nail caps, vinyl covers glued over the claws and replaced every four to six weeks.
- Reward good choices. Praise or a treat when the cat uses the post works better than scolding.
If scratching becomes a real problem, or if someone in the home has a weakened immune system, talk to a vet about options before considering surgery.
Sources: amNY: New York is first state to ban cat declawing (22 July 2019); New York State Senate: bill S5532B; Wikipedia: Declawing (studies, prevalence and legal status); ScienceAlert: New York state poised to become first to ban declawing. Header photo: vizland/iStock.

COMMENTS