Can Black Holes Be Portals? What the 2019 Simulations Showed

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-06-26.

Black Hole Simulations Prompted Speculation About Passage Through Space

Could a spacecraft fly into a black hole and come out somewhere else in the universe? In 2019 that question made headlines after physicists at the University of Massachusetts Dartmouth and Georgia Gwinnett College published computer simulations suggesting that, inside a very large rotating black hole, a spacecraft might pass through the central singularity without being torn apart. Some outlets turned this into "black holes could be portals to other galaxies".

The short answer is that the research was real and interesting, but it did not show that black holes are doorways to anywhere. It showed something narrower: that in an idealised model, the forces at one particular kind of singularity may be gentler than expected. Here is what the scientists actually did, what it means and what remains pure speculation.

The research behind the headlines

The work was led by physicist Gaurav Khanna at UMass Dartmouth with his colleague Lior Burko of Georgia Gwinnett College. Khanna's PhD student Caroline Mallary built the computer model. The team described the project in an article republished by Phys.org in January 2019.

Their inspiration was the 2014 Christopher Nolan film Interstellar, in which Matthew McConaughey's character, Cooper, falls into a huge spinning black hole called Gargantua. The team wanted to know whether a real spacecraft could, in principle, survive a similar fall. Mallary's model estimated the stretching and squeezing that a spacecraft would experience as it fell into a large rotating black hole, such as Gargantua or Sagittarius A*, the supermassive black hole at the centre of our own galaxy.

Why black holes are usually thought to be deadly

A black hole is a region where gravity is so strong that nothing, not even light, can escape once it crosses the boundary called the event horizon. The classic danger is tidal force. Gravity pulls harder on the part of an object closer to the black hole than on the part farther away, stretching it lengthwise and squeezing it from the sides. Physicists call this, only half jokingly, spaghettification.

How bad that is depends on the black hole's mass. Around a small black hole formed from a collapsed star, tidal forces would tear an astronaut apart before they even reached the event horizon. Around a supermassive black hole, the horizon is so large that tidal forces there are mild, and an astronaut could cross it without noticing anything. The trouble comes later, deeper inside, where the forces rise towards the singularity at the centre.

What the simulation suggested

The interior of a rotating black hole is thought to be more complicated than that of a non-rotating one. Building on earlier theoretical work by physicist Amos Ori, the team studied a kind of singularity that some models predict inside spinning black holes, often described as a "mass inflation" singularity. It is considered "weak" in a technical sense, meaning that although the curvature there becomes infinite, the total effect on an object passing through it may remain finite.

Mallary's model supported that idea. As the spacecraft approached, it would experience faster and faster cycles of stretching and squeezing. For a very massive black hole, though, the total effect stayed small. As Mallary put it, for black holes as large as Gargantua the strength of this effect "would be really small", so a spacecraft and its crew might not even detect it.

That is the result behind the "gentle passage" headlines. It is a statement about surviving the forces at a singularity, not about where, if anywhere, the spacecraft would end up.

The big caveats

  • An idealised black hole. The model treated the black hole as isolated, with no nearby stars, gas or incoming radiation. Real black holes are surrounded by dust, gas and radiation, and the authors themselves said a more realistic follow-up study was needed.
  • No exit is shown. The simulation says nothing about a wormhole, another galaxy or another universe on the other side. Those ideas come from mathematical solutions in general relativity that most physicists doubt describe real black holes.
  • Physics we do not yet have. Describing what really happens at a singularity probably requires a theory of quantum gravity, which does not exist yet. Today's models may break down exactly where they matter most.
  • No way to test it. No experiment can be done near a black hole, so this work depends entirely on theory and simulation.

Other unusual black hole ideas

Black holes have inspired many exotic proposals. A 2016 study, reported by Live Science, simulated ring-shaped black holes in a hypothetical universe with five dimensions and found they could expose a "naked" singularity, something general relativity is normally thought to forbid. That research concerned a theoretical higher-dimensional universe, not ours. Other papers, covered by Big Think, have speculated about matter passing through black holes into the far future. These are mathematical explorations, useful for testing theories, and none has been observed.

The more solid progress has come from observation. The Event Horizon Telescope released the first image of a black hole, M87*, in 2019, and in May 2022 published an image of the glowing material around Sagittarius A*. In 2020, the Nobel Prize in Physics went to Roger Penrose for work on black hole formation and to Reinhard Genzel and Andrea Ghez for showing that a supermassive compact object sits at the centre of the Milky Way.

Could we ever try it?

Not in any foreseeable future. Sagittarius A* is about 27,000 light-years away and has about 4.3 million times the mass of the Sun. Even our fastest spacecraft would take tens of thousands of years to cross a single light-year, and humans have not yet sent a crew to Mars.

What researchers can realistically expect is better data. Sharper images, gravitational-wave detectors and new theory may tell us more about what happens inside black holes, and whether singularities exist at all. Until then, "black holes as portals" belongs firmly to science fiction, a genre that, as Interstellar shows, can still inspire serious physics.

Sources: Phys.org: Rotating black holes may serve as gentle portals for hyperspace travel; Spaghettification (Wikipedia); Sagittarius A* (Wikipedia); Live Science. The story was earlier shared by The Mind Unleashed.

COMMENTS