Originally published 2019-05-09.
If streetlights, traffic signals and headlights look to you like starbursts or long diagonal streaks at night, while friends describe neat round points of light, astigmatism is one of the most likely explanations. It is one of the most common focusing errors of the eye, it is usually mild, and an ordinary eye exam can detect it. In March 2019 a side-by-side photo of a wet road at night spread across Twitter and turned that private experience into a public surprise: thousands of people discovered that the rays they had always seen were not how everyone sees light.

The image above shows the same kind of night scene two ways. On one side, green and white lights shoot out long rays; on the other, the lights stay as softer, rounder glows. Below we explain what astigmatism is, why it changes the look of lights in the dark, what the online reaction got right and wrong, and how the condition is found and corrected.
What astigmatism actually is
A healthy eye bends incoming light with two clear structures: the cornea at the front and the lens behind the pupil. When both are evenly curved, a little like part of a ball, light from a single point is brought to a single sharp point on the retina, the light-sensitive layer at the back of the eye.
With astigmatism, one of those surfaces is curved more steeply in one direction than in the other, closer to the shape of the back of a spoon or a rugby ball. Doctors describe this as two "principal meridians" with different focusing power. Instead of one focal point, the eye produces two focal lines, so part of the image is always a little out of focus, at any distance.
There are several ways to classify it:
- Corneal or lenticular, depending on whether the uneven curve sits in the cornea or in the lens.
- Regular or irregular. In regular astigmatism the steepest and flattest directions are at right angles to each other and glasses correct it well. Irregular astigmatism often follows injury, surgery or a disease such as keratoconus, in which the cornea thins and bulges.
- With-the-rule, against-the-rule or oblique, describing which direction is steepest. With-the-rule astigmatism is more common in young adults, while against-the-rule becomes more frequent with age.
Astigmatism very often travels together with short-sightedness (myopia) or long-sightedness (hyperopia), which is why a single prescription usually addresses both.

This diagram, a widely shared Wikimedia Commons illustration, compares an evenly curved cornea that focuses light on one point with an astigmatic cornea that spreads the focus in front of and behind the retina.
Why lights become streaks and starbursts at night
In daylight the pupil is small, so light passes mostly through the centre of the cornea and lens, where small irregularities matter less. In the dark the pupil opens wide. Light now passes through a larger area of the uneven surface, and the focusing error grows. A bright, tiny source such as a headlight is the worst case: instead of landing as a dot, it is smeared out along the direction of the eye's focal line, producing a streak or a fan of rays.
The direction of the streaks depends on the axis of a person's astigmatism, which is why one person sees vertical flares and another sees diagonal ones. Blur from short-sightedness on top of it adds a halo. Driving at night, with oncoming headlights against a dark background, is where many people first notice the difference.

Comparison images like this one were assembled from night-time road photos. The streaks on the left resemble what many people with uncorrected astigmatism describe, while the right shows a less distorted view of a similar junction.

A single scene with strong rays coming from the traffic signals and oncoming headlights. Notice that the red brake lights of the car ahead also smear, because every bright point is affected in the same way.

The rounder version: lights are blurred and glowing, but they do not throw long rays.
How the photo went viral, and what the replies got right
The comparison was posted on 25 March 2019 by @UnusualFacts6, an account that collected odd facts. Within days it had tens of thousands of likes and a long thread of replies. The most common reaction was simple astonishment: people who had seen streaks their whole lives assumed that was just how light behaved.

The original post described astigmatism as a cornea that is not completely round and said light then focuses on several points of the retina instead of one. That is a fair, simplified summary, although the lens inside the eye can be responsible too.

Not everyone was convinced. One user pointed out that a windscreen with streaks of water from the wipers creates very similar rays, which is true: thin lines of water or grease scatter light into streaks at right angles to them.

The account replied that, as someone with astigmatism, the effect looks the same inside or outside a car. Both can be right, since windscreens and eyes can produce similar patterns for different reasons.

A reply that captured the mood of the thread, with more than two thousand likes: genuine surprise that other people see lights "normally".

One of the most liked replies, with more than 3,800 likes, came from a woman who said she had seen the lines since childhood and used to squint to make them longer for fun, assuming everyone saw the same.

Another reader joked that their whole life of seeing had been a lie.

Another reader had simply assumed this was how light works.

A photographer argued that the streaky image looked like a phone camera with a dirty lens, and that astigmatism causes blur rather than stripes. He has a point about the photo: a smudged lens produces exactly this kind of flare.

The original poster answered that many people in the thread recognised the streaks from their own night vision. Both points hold: the photo is not a medical image, yet streaks around lights are a known symptom of uncorrected astigmatism.

A playful take imagining artists with and without astigmatism arguing over whose paintings show the "real" world.

A heavily blurred version of the scene, posted by someone who said this was simply how everything looked to them. Strong uncorrected refractive errors can blur a whole scene, not just the lights.

A short reply from another user who had always assumed the streaks were simply normal, a reaction repeated many times in the thread.
The fair conclusion from the thread is that the viral picture exaggerates and simplifies, but it pointed many people towards a real and easily fixed problem. If you recognised yourself in it, the next step is an eye exam, not a self-diagnosis from a photo.
Symptoms and how it is diagnosed
Mild astigmatism often causes no symptoms at all. When it is stronger, people may notice:
- blurred or slightly doubled vision at any distance;
- squinting, eye strain and tired eyes after reading or screen work;
- headaches;
- more difficulty seeing at night, including glare and streaks around lights.
An optometrist or ophthalmologist can measure it during a routine exam. Common tools include the letter chart, an autorefractor or retinoscope for an objective reading, keratometry or corneal topography to map the curve of the cornea, and a set of trial lenses to fine-tune the result. In children, uncorrected astigmatism that starts early can contribute to a "lazy eye" (amblyopia), which is one reason children's eye checks matter. Anyone with new or worsening vision problems should talk to a doctor or eye-care professional.
How it is corrected
Astigmatism is not dangerous in itself, and the main options are well established:
- Glasses with a cylindrical correction are the simplest and safest choice for most people.
- Contact lenses, including soft toric lenses designed to stay in the right orientation, and rigid lenses that can help with irregular corneas such as in keratoconus.
- Laser refractive surgery can reshape the cornea, with more cost and risk than lenses.
- Toric lens implants during cataract surgery can correct astigmatism in older patients at the same time.
Which option suits a person depends on the type and amount of astigmatism, eye health and lifestyle, so the decision belongs with an eye-care professional.
How common it is, and who discovered it
Estimates vary widely between studies and countries, but astigmatism is common everywhere. A review of systematic reviews found adult prevalence ranging from 8% to 62%, with a worldwide estimate of about 40%, and studies in Europe and Asia report that 30% to 60% of adults have some degree of it. Roughly 28% of American children aged 5 to 17 have it as well. Most cases, around four in five, are mild.
Refractive errors as a group are a major cause of poor vision worldwide. The World Health Organization estimates that 2.2 billion people live with some form of vision impairment, and tens of millions of those cases come from refractive errors that a pair of glasses could fix.
The condition has been understood for a little over two centuries. The physicist Thomas Young described it in his own eye in a lecture in 1801. The astronomer George Airy independently noticed it in his own vision and had corrective cylindrical lenses made in the 1820s, and the scholar William Whewell coined the name, from Greek words meaning "without a point".
Did astigmatism shape El Greco's art?

El Greco's Saint Jerome as Cardinal, one of several versions the painter made of the subject, shows the tall, narrow figures that made his style famous.
El Greco, born Doménikos Theotokópoulos on Crete in 1541 and active in Spain until his death in 1614, painted strikingly elongated bodies and faces. In the early 20th century the ophthalmologists August Goldschmidt and Germán Beritens suggested that he saw people as longer than they were because of astigmatism or a squint. The idea became popular and still circulates online.
Most art historians and vision scientists are sceptical. The psychologist Stuart Anstis argued that an artist with distorted vision would see both the model and the canvas distorted in the same way, so the proportions on the canvas would still look normal to others. In his view the elongation was a deliberate style. Whether El Greco had astigmatism at all remains unproven, so the theory is best treated as an interesting myth.
Claude Monet's case is better documented, but it involves a different condition. He developed cataracts in his later years, consulted an eye specialist in London in 1913 and finally had surgery in 1923. Before the operation his colours grew darker and his brushwork broader; afterwards he complained of seeing everything with a blue tint for a time and even destroyed some earlier canvases. His late water lilies are often discussed as a window into how cataracts change colour perception.
For most people the lesson from the viral photo is less dramatic but more useful: if night lights always look like fireworks, a short eye test can tell you why, and a simple correction often makes night driving noticeably easier.
Sources: @UnusualFacts6 on Twitter (original comparison post); Wikipedia: Astigmatism; Wikimedia Commons: Astigmatism (Eye) diagram; Wikipedia: El Greco; Wikimedia: El Greco, San Jerónimo (image); Wikipedia: Claude Monet.

Not sure I understand - which photo is with and which without astigmatism? Or... are they both with astigmatism?
ReplyDelete