Screech Owl Hatches a Wood Duckling: Laurie Wolf's Photos

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

In spring 2019, wildlife artist and photographer Laurie Wolf looked into one of the nest boxes in her backyard in Jupiter, Florida, and saw something that should not have been there: a fluffy yellow-and-black wood duckling sitting calmly beside a female eastern screech owl. The owl had moved into the box about a month earlier. The most likely explanation is that a wood duck had slipped an egg into the owl's clutch, and the owl incubated and hatched it along with her own.

Wolf's photographs of the unlikely pair went around the world, and National Geographic asked an owl researcher what was going on. The short version: it is rare, it has been documented before, and it says something interesting about how birds recognise eggs. Below are Wolf's photos with what each one shows, a look at both species, the science of "egg dumping", and a selection of the jokes people made when the pictures went viral.

The nest box photos

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

The first view of the scene: the owl's grey, bark-patterned face fills most of the entrance hole while the duckling squeezes in beside her. Eastern screech owls are masters of camouflage, and against the pine-bark front of the box she almost disappears.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

The duckling alone at the entrance, bill open, probably calling. Wolf later described hearing it call from the box when it was by itself, which suggests it was looking for adult wood ducks nearby.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

A wider shot shows the whole box on its post. Wolf and her family had put up several such boxes around the yard, which is exactly the kind of setup that brings cavity-nesting species close together.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

The closest frame of the pair, and the one that made the story famous. The owl's half-closed eyes are typical of a screech owl resting by day; the duckling, with its dark eye stripe and pale cheeks, is unmistakably a wood duck.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

The duckling at the entrance hole on its own. Wood duck chicks are built for exactly this moment: within a day of hatching they climb to the opening of the cavity and jump, sometimes from heights of 50 feet, landing on water or soft leaf litter.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

Owl and duckling side by side again, this time from a little farther back. Wolf said a storm was approaching when she and her husband saw the two sitting quietly together at the hole.

Image credits: Laurie Wolf, Michael McCarthy, Danielle Brigida

Meet the wood duck and the screech owl

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

A pair of adult wood ducks on the water, the brightly patterned drake on the right and the browner hen beside him. Wood ducks breed across much of the eastern United States and on the west coast. They eat mainly seeds, berries and acorns, plus insects.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

A drake perched on top of a nest box. Wood ducks nest in tree cavities near water and readily use artificial boxes. That habit helped save them: after hunting and habitat loss nearly wiped them out in the early 1900s, legal protection and nest box programmes from the 1930s onward helped the population recover.

The other half of the story, the eastern screech owl, is a small, stocky owl about 16 to 25 centimetres long, found across eastern North America from Mexico to Canada. It comes in grey and reddish forms, with a rare brown form mainly in Florida. It hunts insects, small mammals and birds at night and, despite its name, does not really screech: its call is a descending, horse-like whinny or a long trill. It also nests in cavities and nest boxes, laying eggs straight onto the floor without building a nest, which is how the two species end up competing for the same homes.

How a duck egg ends up under an owl

Wolf's family believed they had seen a female wood duck carry an egg from a raided box towards the one the owl was using, and that the hen left it there. They could not follow her through the trees, so this was never confirmed. Ducks are not known for carrying eggs in their bills, and the explanation experts point to is simpler: brood parasitism.

Female wood ducks often lay some of their eggs in other birds' nests, usually those of other wood ducks or closely related ducks. When nest boxes are placed too close together, some boxes end up with 30 or more eggs from several hens. Christian Artuso, Manitoba director of Bird Studies Canada, told National Geographic that spreading eggs around is a way of not keeping all of them in one basket: if a predator destroys one clutch, others may survive.

Artuso has seen this first-hand. In 2005, while studying eastern screech owls for his PhD, he recorded a female owl that incubated and hatched three wood duck chicks. He published the case in the Wilson Journal of Ornithology in 2007.

Why would an owl sit on a duck's egg? Wood duck eggs are more oblong than owl eggs and about twice the volume. One possibility Artuso raised is a "supernormal stimulus": an unusually large egg may trigger the incubation instinct even more strongly than the bird's own. Another is that the situation is so rare that screech owls have never evolved a way to spot the intruder. Other birds do the same; there are records of an American kestrel incubating a bufflehead's eggs and an osprey raising Canada geese.

Why didn't the owl eat the duckling? Owls do take small birds, and a raptor expert Wolf consulted warned that the chick could be in danger. A local wildlife sanctuary agreed to take it if she could catch it. Before anyone could try, the duckling made the decision for them.

What people said when the photos went viral

Wolf shared the pictures on Facebook, and the comments quickly turned into a stream of jokes. A selection, paraphrased:

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

One reader flipped the old duck test: if it looks like a duck, walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it is probably an owl. It neatly sums up the confusion the duckling must have caused at feeding time.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

The most-liked joke imagined the owl's expression as a fierce warning to anyone thinking of touching her "weird son". Her heavy-lidded stare does look protective.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

A pun that seems to nod to the famous Monty Python witch-trial scene: ducks float because they are made of wood. For a wood duck, the pun almost writes itself.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

A parent's-eye view of a picky eater, with the duckling announcing it does not want mice because it is a vegetarian. Screech owls, for the record, feed their young a mix of insects, small mammals and birds.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

A commenter who said she works at the Houston Zoo added a real-world parallel: keepers there, she wrote, use domestic hens to hatch and raise the eggs of critically endangered blue-billed curassows. Foster parents of another species are sometimes used in captive breeding when the real parents cannot raise their young.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

Another reader imagined the owl's pride in a child who turns out to be an excellent swimmer, a skill no owlet would ever need.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

A longer comment reflected on parenthood: children turn out differently from what you planned, and this one would rather swim all day than hunt by night.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

Short and to the point: the owl looks as if she is having second thoughts. Screech owls rest with their eyes half closed by day, which gives them that doubtful look.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

The picky-eater joke appears a second time here, a reminder of how often the same comment gets reshared when a post goes viral.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

A scene-setting joke from the owl's point of view: asking the absent duck parents when they plan to pick up their offspring, because they are late.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

A playful nod to modern identity debates, with the duckling declaring it identifies as an owl.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

The owl's face, one reader decided, plainly says "mind your own business". Plenty of birdwatchers have received that look.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

An observation that the two are beginning to look alike, helped by the matching grey-brown tones of owl feathers and duckling down.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

A warmer response: what matters is a mother's love. It was the sentiment behind most of the shares.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

Imagining the household soundscape: one family member going "woo woo" while the other quacks.

Laurie Wolf's Photograph of an Owl and a Duckling

And finally, the owl's expression read as pure "I have made a mistake". Given what Artuso explained about oversized eggs, she may not have had much choice.

What happened to the duckling

Shortly after the photos were taken, the duckling jumped from the box and ran straight for the back fence and a neighbour's pond, where wild wood ducks had been seen. Later it was back in the hole on its own, calling, and then left again, apparently in response to answering calls. Wolf's family did not see it again; the pond is on private land and well hidden.

That may be a good sign. Wood duck chicks are precocial, meaning they can walk, swim and feed themselves almost from hatching, and ducklings from different broods sometimes join up. Artuso thought this one may well have survived.

If you put up nest boxes

  • Space them out. Boxes placed close together encourage egg dumping, which can leave huge clutches that fail to hatch.
  • Expect visitors. Boxes sized for wood ducks are also used by screech owls, squirrels and other cavity nesters.
  • Watch, don't handle. Disturbing a nest can make adults abandon it. If you are worried about a chick, call a licensed wildlife rehabilitator for advice before stepping in.
  • Remember the jump. Wood duck chicks leave the nest the day after hatching, so a soft landing area and nearby water make a real difference.

Laurie Wolf's photographs caught one of those moments that bird researchers know happens but rarely see. They are a lovely reminder that a backyard nest box can be a small window into evolution at work.

Sources: National Geographic, 16 April 2019: Why this owl raised a duckling as its own; Wikipedia: Wood duck; Wikipedia: Eastern screech owl. Nest box photos by Laurie Wolf (Wild Works Gallery, Facebook); wood duck photos credited to Michael McCarthy and Danielle Brigida on Flickr; comment screenshots from Wolf's public Facebook post.

COMMENTS