Alexander Cortes's 'Beautiful Woman' List and the Backlash

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

In February 2019, a California fitness writer named Alexander J.A. Cortes posted a 12-point list on Twitter titled "How to Be a Beautiful Woman". It told women to be thin, cook, grow long hair, wear make-up, shave, dress in pink and other feminine colours, love men and listen to men, and ended with "Stay classy ladies!" The tweet collected around 9,000 likes, but far more attention came from the replies: thousands of people, women and men, answered with jokes, parodies and pointed criticism.

Below are the key tweets in the thread, how Cortes responded when the backlash began, and a selection of the replies that spread most widely, along with some context on why lists like this strike such a nerve.

What the "beautiful woman" list said

Cortes, then 29, described himself as a trainer, writer and speaker and had built a following of around 58,000 people partly through provocative posts about dating and gender roles. On the night of 21 February 2019 he published the list below. Every item concerns how a woman looks or how she serves men; nothing on it mentions intelligence, humour, kindness or a woman's own goals.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

A selfie Cortes posted on Twitter, used widely in coverage of the thread. Many replies would later turn his long hair and beard into a running joke.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

The original tweet, posted at 10:26 p.m. on 21 February 2019. The 12 points mix grooming rules (make-up, shaving, long hair) with expectations about behaviour, such as listening to men.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Minutes later Cortes promoted his newsletter, adding that only a man can tell a woman how to act. Many critics noted that the thread doubled as marketing for his paid content.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

He then suggested men use the list as a test: a woman who gets angry at it, he wrote, is not someone to have children with. This turned a list of grooming tips into a claim about women's worth as partners and mothers.

How Cortes doubled down

Instead of stepping back as criticism grew, Cortes posted a series of follow-ups through the night. He shared another selfie, claimed women were desperate for his attention, said he only talks to women he rates highly on a ten-point scale, and retweeted a similar list by Hunter Drew, a writer who describes himself as a patriarch. Later, reports noted, he added a separate list of red flags in women, including being a feminist and not liking children.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

One of the earliest replies, from a user called Miranda, turned his premise around by calmly telling him she did not find him attractive. The joke works because it applies his own standard back to him.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

The British journalist Deborah Orr, then a well-known Guardian columnist, replied that all women want from men is for them not to be controlling or narcissistic, using a mild insult. Her tweet drew more than 12,000 likes.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Cortes posted this car selfie, offering it to women he claimed wanted his attention. Rather than calming things down, the post handed critics fresh material.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

In this follow-up Cortes dismissed the angry replies with a crude sexual remark and once again pointed to his newsletter. The tweet includes a censored swear word.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Cortes explained that he only replies to women he rates eight or above out of ten, and that others could improve their score by following his list. Rating people out of ten is a common feature of online pick-up and manosphere culture.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Here he argued that a woman's value as a wife would one day matter, and linked to another account's list as a guide to marriage.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

The list Cortes shared, by Hunter Drew, titled "How to be a better wife". It overlaps heavily with the original (long hair, shaving, femininity) and adds cooking for the family, staying in shape, putting family before a job and listening to your husband.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Cortes told angry women their emotions were caused by body fat and hormones, and linked to a paid fitness product. Medical evidence does not support blaming disagreement on a person's weight.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

In another reply he urged men to watch which women reacted badly, dismissing them as deluded feminists. By this point the thread had become a standoff between Cortes and much of the platform.

How Twitter answered: jokes and comebacks

Most replies did not argue point by point. They used humour, which tends to travel further online than a lecture. Many mocked his appearance (fair or not, he had invited the comparison by judging women on theirs), others pointed out how dated the list sounded, and some simply reported laughing.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

A user called The Sassiest Semite answered with heavy sarcasm, claiming to be heartbroken that a man like Cortes would never love her. It collected more than 3,000 likes.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Artist and designer Rob Sheridan asked how the weather was back in 1950, a short way of calling the list hopelessly old-fashioned.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Julie suggested he had forgotten one rule: "must smile often". It nods to the common experience of women being told by strangers to smile.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

"Thanks for the tip, Walmart Fabio!" Elena's reply compared Cortes to the long-haired 1990s romance-novel cover model, and drew around 5,000 likes.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Another user joked that his future partner was more likely to be an inflatable doll than a real woman, one of many replies predicting he would stay single.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

The Brofucius made the same point in three words, asking whether he was single.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Bren admitted he had kept reading in the hope that a punchline was coming.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Omnicronos replied that the whole thing was the punchline.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Writer Lucy Huber's viral joke about how some men write female characters (impossibly tiny, never sick, always looking perfect) had spread days earlier. Replying with it, FancyPants asked whether Cortes would write a novel the same way.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

A popular reaction GIF of a baby pulling a disgusted face was posted in reply to the thread.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Charity Locklear said the same look applied to everyone who had liked the list or responded to it approvingly.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

A scene from the 2006 comedy Borat, in which the character boasts about being king of his castle, posted as a reaction to Cortes's lecture on how women should behave.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Katie Compa's reply consisted of the GIF above, with no text needed.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Users dug up older Cortes posts, including this recommendation of Arthur J, a steakhouse in Manhattan Beach, California. One person asked, with many laughing emojis, whether the extra untouched glass and plate were meant to suggest he was on a date. That reply gathered nearly 10,000 likes.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Sheri Lynn wrote that she had first assumed the account must be a parody.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Ryan Crawford answered her by quoting one item from the list back at her, the rule about listening to men.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Sheri Lynn's comeback: she does listen to men, which is why she laughs so much. It earned more than 5,000 likes, more than the original list's follow-up tweets.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Stephanie replied with a card from Effin' Birds, a popular webcomic that pairs vintage-style bird illustrations with blunt captions, asking whether he was born ignorant.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

C-Rex pointed out that a lot of men tick several items on the list, which makes it hard to call it a guide to womanhood.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

A meme of a woman scanning the horizon with binoculars, captioned with strong language, posted to suggest nobody had asked for his advice.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Dave put Cortes's selfie beside a picture of the caveman character from GEICO's insurance adverts and asked who wore it better. With more than 6,000 likes, it was one of the most shared replies.

Flipping the list around

Some of the most effective replies did not mock Cortes at all. They showed what a list looks like when it is applied to men, or when it is rewritten around respect.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Efran wrote that his wife is beautiful without meeting any of these rules, a simple statement that drew almost 4,000 likes.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Amanda posted "How to be a handsome man", with items like being muscular, solvent, clean-shaven and able to cook, plus loving and listening to women. Seen side by side, the two lists show how strange it is to reduce anyone to a checklist.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Ghost dog's one-item list on how to be a tool: write tweets like this.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Lawyer Max Kennerly offered advice on how to find a beautiful woman: drop criteria meant to impress other men, treat women with respect because it is decent, and find someone who loves you for who you are. It became one of the most-liked replies, with over 10,000 likes.

Responses to a Viral List of Rules About Women

Sera's parody, "How to be a beautiful man part II", exaggerates macho stereotypes, from growing a gorilla-like beard to communicating only in grunts and washing with tree sap.

Why lists like this strike a nerve

The thread was easy to laugh at, but it touched real issues. Standards of female beauty vary enormously between cultures and eras: plumpness was admired in Tang dynasty China, for example, and tastes in skin tone, body shape and hair have changed many times. A list that presents one narrow look as the definition of a "beautiful woman" says more about a particular culture than about beauty.

Research also links pressure to meet narrow ideals, especially thinness, to lower self-esteem, depression and body dissatisfaction, often beginning in adolescence, and to disordered eating. Social media and heavily edited images make the pressure more constant. Thinness heading the list is therefore not a harmless preference. Anyone struggling with their body image or eating should talk to a doctor or a trusted professional.

The behavioural rules (listen to men, love men, stay graceful) touch a different nerve. They describe a relationship in which one partner's role is to please the other. Healthy relationships are usually described as the opposite: mutual respect, shared decisions and freedom to disagree. That is why so many replies, including Max Kennerly's widely shared list, focused on respect rather than looks.

What the backlash shows

The Cortes thread became a minor news story in February 2019, covered by outlets from Fox News to The Sun. It also illustrates how online provocation works: a deliberately inflammatory post generates angry engagement, which in turn spreads the account, and the newsletter, to people who would never otherwise have seen it. Many of those who replied were aware of this and chose ridicule instead of outrage, a response that is harder to turn into a fight.

Most importantly, the replies showed how out of step the list was with what many people actually value in a partner. In thousands of responses, women and men described beauty, and attraction, in terms of character, humour and respect rather than hair length or a favourite colour.

Sources: Fox News (from The Sun), 27 February 2019: Man roasted on Twitter for tips on how to be a beautiful woman; Wikipedia: Feminine beauty ideal. Screenshots: the original tweet by @AJA_Cortes and public replies by the users named; selfie via aja_cortes on Instagram.

Related articles

COMMENTS