Four-Year Battle With Nesting Doves on a Fireplace Vent

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

Birds that find a warm, sheltered ledge rarely give it up without a fight. One homeowner learned this over four nesting seasons, from 2014 to 2018, and documented every round in a photo diary he posted on Imgur under the name atomicrabbit2, titled "My 4-year battle with birds."

The battleground was the exhaust vent of a gas fireplace on the back wall of his new house. Tucked under the eaves near the back door, it offered a roof overhead, solid brick on two sides and gentle heat from below: close to ideal for a nest. Each spring he added another layer of wire mesh or spikes, and each spring the birds found a way to build on, around or inside his latest defence. What finally worked was not more hardware but a plastic owl.

The post is usually shared as a story about pigeons, but the birds in the photographs look like mourning doves, a slimmer, buff-brown relative with black spots on the wings, long pointed tails and a habit of nesting on building ledges across North America. Below, each picture is explained in order, followed by the reactions of other Imgur users and some practical notes for anyone facing the same visitors.

2014 to 2015: the first nest and the first fix

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

The opening picture shows the scene at its most absurd: a dove perched calmly on top of a vent cover already wrapped in wire mesh. The metal box with the "HOT" label is the fireplace exhaust, which is why the spot was so appealing. Warm air rising from below makes a sheltered ledge even more comfortable for a sitting bird.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

In August 2014 the homeowner first noticed birds in the nook beside his back door. They burst out every time he opened the door, which startled him more than it did them. He let it go until they began building a nest inside the exhaust itself and leaving droppings around the step.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

In March 2015, before the next breeding season, he wrapped the whole vent cover neatly in chicken wire, the first of six iterations. It looks tidy and sensible. Wrapping a fireplace exhaust is not a step to copy without checking, though, because a gas vent needs free airflow; more on that below.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

By May 2015 the birds had simply moved upstairs, using the small gap on top of the mesh-wrapped box as a platform. The close-up shows a typical dove nest: a loose, shallow saucer of twigs and grass. Since no eggs had been laid, he cleared it away.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

A bird was back the very next day, sitting on a rebuilt nest. He cleared it again, and this time the birds stayed away for the rest of that season, which he took as victory. Doves can raise several broods a year in warm regions, so a single removal often only delays them.

2016 to 2017: spikes, twine and a stockpile

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

In May 2016 the diary entry is just an ellipsis, and the photo explains why: a dove sitting among fresh twigs on top of the vent. Mourning doves are faithful to good nest sites and will happily return to the same ledge year after year.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

His answer was a row of plastic bird spikes on top. Instead of deterring the birds, the spikes seem to have given the nest something to grip, and this time the birds wove in blue twine. Each time he pulled the nest out, more twine appeared the next day, and he joked that they "must have had a stockpile somewhere."

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

In June 2016 he went further and covered the top with a forest of extra spikes, pointing in every direction. The photo shows how crowded the ledge had become. Spikes work best on flat ledges where birds land; on a cluttered, sheltered corner they can end up acting as a frame.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

May 2017 brought the same picture: a new nest sitting on top of the spikes. His caption that spring was a single, very short swear word. Four seasons in, the score was firmly in the birds' favour.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

By July 2017 another nest had appeared, wedged between the spikes and the wall. The photo shows how the materials have piled up over time, including grass trailing over the edge. His caption was the same word repeated three times.

2018: the cage, the gap and the owl

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

Next he enclosed the entire top of the vent in a box of wire mesh, closing off the space above the spikes. On paper, there was now nowhere left to land. He was understandably pleased with himself.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

The finished cage covers the whole upper part of the vent, almost up to the eaves. This was the stage at which he began to declare victory in his captions. It did not last long.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

In May 2018 he found a nest inside the cage. A small gap on the right-hand side had let the birds fly in, turning his barrier into what he called a high-end gated community. It is the moment most readers remember, and the one that made the diary go viral.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

The breakthrough came that same month with a plastic owl, which he named Dr. Who, mounted on a bracket beside the vent. According to the diary, the birds left and did not return. Fake predators often work for a while, especially when they are new; many bird-control guides suggest moving them every few days so birds do not get used to them.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

In July 2018 he closed the last gap for good measure, leaving a vent wrapped in layers of mesh that he admitted was not pretty. After six iterations and four seasons, he wrote that if the birds came back he might "just give in and try to charge them rent."

How Imgur users reacted

The comment section loved the story, and the screenshots below show some of the most popular replies.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

The first commenter imagined the homeowner cursing at the birds as he fixed each new layer of spikes. The language in this screenshot is strong, so the image is hidden until you choose to view it.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

Another reader admitted they had expected the spikes in the eighth photo to end the matter. Their verdict on the birds was a mix of irritation and admiration for how dedicated they were.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

One commenter pictured the homeowner as a sleepless, wild-haired figure installing spikes in a frenzy. It is a fair guess at how the fourth spring must have felt.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

This reader switched sides and suggested building the birds a proper birdhouse. It is actually a common recommendation: offering an alternative site nearby can draw birds away from a problem spot.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

A short joke about how close the birds came to nesting on the owl's head. Birds do sometimes ignore decoys that never move.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

Another commenter described the owl as a plastic security guard. It summed up the final chapter in a few words.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

This reader compared the story to a Looney Tunes cartoon, with the homeowner as the frustrated hunter and the birds always one step ahead. The comparison was a popular one.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

One reply compared the heavily wired vent to a prison camp. It was meant as a joke about the mesh and spikes, though a harsh comparison.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

A gentler suggestion: accept the dove as a family member. This commenter was also one of the few to call the birds doves rather than pigeons.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

A short confession of support for the birds. Plenty of readers felt the same way.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

This reader said the frustration was visible in every piece of wire. Looking back through the photos in order, it is hard to disagree.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

The most upvoted reply in the collection pointed out the irony: after building a cage and a field of spikes, it was a cheap lawn ornament that solved the problem. It is also the most useful lesson in the thread.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

A tongue-in-cheek thank-you for the entertainment. Many readers clearly enjoyed someone else's long struggle.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

One commenter imagined a future buyer seeing the strange wire contraption, tearing it down, and then slowly discovering why it was there. Anyone who has bought an older house with odd fixtures will recognise the scenario.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

This reply put it neatly: he lost every battle but won the war. That is a fair summary of the diary.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

Another reader compared the post to the diary of someone slowly losing their mind, then congratulated him on winning. Both halves are fair.

A Four-Year Pigeon Story: One Homeowner’s Escalating Photo Diary

The final comment imagined the birds telling this story to future generations as a tale of perseverance and finding a home. It is a sweet note to end the thread on.

Why the birds kept coming back

From the birds' point of view, the vent was close to perfect. It was high off the ground, sheltered by the roof, protected on two sides by brick, and warm. Mourning doves build flimsy nests from twigs and grass and will use ledges on buildings when trees are scarce. Pairs often lay two eggs at a time and, in warmer areas, can raise several broods in one season, so a good site gets visited again and again.

Each change he made also left something behind for the birds to use. Mesh and spikes created a rough surface that held twigs in place, and every cleared nest left scraps that made the next one quicker to build.

If birds are nesting on your vent

The story is funny, but a few practical points are worth keeping in mind:

  • Check before you cover a gas vent. Fireplace and boiler exhausts must stay clear to vent combustion gases safely. Use a guard approved for your appliance, and ask a qualified gas technician if you are unsure.
  • Act before eggs appear. In the US and Canada, native doves are covered by migratory bird laws that protect active nests and eggs. Removing material before eggs are laid, or waiting until the young have fledged, avoids problems; check your local wildlife rules.
  • Close gaps completely. As the 2018 photo shows, birds will find any opening left in a barrier.
  • Move decoys regularly. A plastic owl that never moves may eventually be ignored.

For another story about wild visitors who made themselves at home, see Tim Newton's lynx visitors on an Alaskan deck.

Sources: Photo diary and comments by Imgur user atomicrabbit2, as featured by Bored Panda; Wikipedia: Mourning dove; Wikipedia: Migratory Bird Treaty Act of 1918.

COMMENTS