Francisco Negroni’s Photographs of Lightning Over Erupting Volcanoes

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

A column of ash glows above an erupting volcano while lightning branches through the darkness. Chilean landscape photographer Francisco Negroni, known for his pictures of extreme natural conditions, has made such scenes the focus of a distinctive body of work. His photographs bring together landscape, timing and the restless activity of volcanoes.

Lightning branching through a brightly lit volcanic eruption column
Volcanic eruption photograph attributed to Francisco Negroni in the original gallery. Exposure may combine light recorded over time. Source.

How the photographer found his subject

In an interview about his eruption photography, Negroni described how seeing the Llaima eruption in 2008 changed his interests. His photographs of Cordón Caulle’s 2011 eruption later went viral and, according to the 2018 report, earned him several awards.

The interview explains that his technique varies with conditions, with long exposures playing an important role. That detail helps us read the finished images: a single photograph may accumulate light over time rather than freeze everything in one brief instant.

Negroni used to work as a photo reporter, covering political news, when he came upon the Llaima volcano eruption in 2008. Although he couldn't photograph the particular moment, the eruption piqued his interest and led him to change directions with his work life. “It was so little what I saw of that eruption,” he told My Modern Met. “But it was enough for me to feel something strange and motivate me to be aware of the next eruption and travel to take pictures of it. Seeing that eruption was my real motivation to start in this world of eruption photography.”

The change of direction eventually produced the eruption photographs that attracted attention in 2011. His ambition remained personal as well as technical: “I will continue trying to show eruptions in all their magnitude and hope that the world, in general, continues to be surprised with my photographs.” He continues to travel around Chile in search of the best possible pictures of volcanic activity and also leads photo tours around the country (as of the 2018 report).

What to notice in the image

Follow the contrast between the dark surroundings, the illuminated plume and the bright lightning. Then look at the landscape below. The broader composition gives the eruption a setting and scale that a tight crop might lose.

Color, brightness and the density of visible flashes are affected by exposure and processing. An image can convey the event powerfully without being a literal match for the brightness an observer perceived at every moment.

Keep the credit with the photograph

Different eruptions and images need their own captions. A photographer’s name does not establish that every picture was taken at the same volcano, and a striking photograph should not be detached from its author when it is shared.

For the geological side of these landscapes, explore Etna’s changing summit and the transformation of Hunga Tonga–Hunga Haʻapai. The photographs invite attention; the measurements help explain the changes.

Look at the relationship between plume and light

The image brings together different scales: the landscape, the eruption column and a brief branching flash. Follow how those elements guide your eye through the frame. The photographer's timing and viewpoint are central to the result. A dramatic photograph records a particular event and exposure, while an explanation of the electrical process requires separate scientific evidence.

Explore the related article: David Kaszlikowski's Glacier Photography Near K2.

How common are “dirty thunderstorms”?

Several of Negroni’s most striking pictures show what are called dirty thunderstorms: lightning produced inside a volcanic plume. The 2018 article explained them as static electricity from colliding ash, rock and other ejecta. Volcanic lightning can indeed arise as particles in an eruptive plume acquire and separate electrical charge, and ash, rock fragments and, under suitable conditions, ice can all play a part.

The article also said such storms are present 27 to 35 percent of the time, which would make Negroni’s pictures all the rarer. That figure came without a source, and the global survey checked for this update points the other way. Reviewing records from 80 volcanoes and 212 eruptions with lightning, Stephen McNutt and Earle Williams (Bulletin of Volcanology, 2010) found lightning reported for about 8% of eruptions of moderate to large size, 10% of the largest, and under 2% of small ones, while warning that small eruptions are probably under-reported and that reports were more frequent at night. A plume’s conditions, the observation method and the stage of an eruption all affect what can be detected, which makes a well-timed photograph rarer still.

Research context: review of volcanic electrification: C. Cimarelli, S. Behnke, K. Genareau, J. Méndez Harper and A. R. Van Eaton, “Volcanic electrification: recent advances and future perspectives”, Bulletin of Volcanology 84 (2022) (USGS publication record).

Credits and further reading: Francisco Negroni · Cordón Caulle eruption · dirty thunderstorms · photo tours · Website · Facebook · Instagram.

COMMENTS