What Do You See First? Knight, Dancers or an Old Man's Face

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-06-25.

Look at the picture below for a second or two and notice what jumps out first: an armoured knight, two dancers, or the face of an older man. All three are hidden in the same image. This is a light-hearted picture quiz, so the “personality readings” further down are for reflection and fun, not a psychological diagnosis. After the quiz, we look at what science really says about ambiguous images, why quiz results feel so accurate, and what a large study found about how art affects young people.

An Ambiguous-Art Personality Quiz

How to take the quiz

Do not study the image. Glance at it, note the first thing you recognise, and then scroll to the matching section. If you see two things at once, read both. You may also find that once you have spotted one figure, the others pop out too; that is normal and is part of how double images work.

A good way to make this more interesting is to ask a friend or family member to try it without telling them your answer. People often see different things first, and comparing what each of you noticed, and why, can start a better conversation than any quiz result.

1. You saw the armoured knight

The Armored Knight

The knight is a figure built for protection. In the playful reading of this quiz, spotting him first suggests someone who loves fun and company but has put up some armour of their own, perhaps after being let down in the past.

If that rings true, the suggestion is to lower the shield a little at a time. Speak to yourself with the kindness you would offer a friend, and remind yourself that you deserve steady, caring relationships. Quiet moments of reflection can help you notice old hurts without being ruled by them.

Connection also grows through routine. Make regular plans with the people who leave you feeling better, join a class, a club or a sports team, or volunteer somewhere you will meet kind people. Friendships rarely appear all at once; they build from repeated, small meetings.

2. You saw the two dancers

The Two Dancers

Dancers are about movement, closeness and joy. In this quiz, noticing them first hints at a romantic, warm way of seeing the world that you might keep more private than you would like. You may care deeply about a few people without telling them often enough.

A simple exercise: think of one specific thing you value about someone close to you, such as the way they check in on you or make you laugh, and tell them next time you speak. Being specific matters more than being grand. “Thank you for calling every Sunday, it really helps me” lands better than a vague compliment.

The dancers can also be read as a nudge towards play. If life has become all routine, try something new: a painting or drawing class, a dance lesson, or a trip somewhere you have never been.

3. You saw the older man’s face

The Older Man’s Face

The face is the “big picture” in this image: you only see it when you take in the whole scene instead of its parts. So the playful interpretation is that you tend to look at life as a whole without getting lost in details, and that you might currently be in a reflective mood, thinking back on important people and moments.

Looking back can be useful when it points forward. If you find yourself remembering someone who helped you at a difficult time, consider how you could pass a similar kindness on today, even to a stranger. If you remember words you wish you had said, there may still be a chance to say them to someone else who needs to hear them.

What science says about ambiguous pictures

Images that can be seen in more than one way are known to psychologists as ambiguous or multistable figures. Famous examples include the Necker cube and the vase that is also two faces in profile. Your visual system cannot settle on a single answer, so perception tends to flip between interpretations, and the flips are partly spontaneous: you cannot completely stop them by effort alone.

Which version you see first depends on ordinary factors: where your eyes land, how large the image is on your screen, lighting and contrast, and what you have recently been thinking about or looking at. Distance matters too. Faces made of smaller figures are often easier to spot from further away or at a small size, while the small figures stand out when you zoom in.

There is no good evidence that your first pick reveals hidden personality traits. Even the Rorschach inkblot test, created by Swiss psychiatrist Hermann Rorschach in 1921 and scored with detailed professional systems, has been heavily criticised. Reviews have found some validity for spotting disordered thinking, but not as a general measure of personality. A picture quiz online has far less backing than that.

Why quiz results feel so accurate

If one of the readings above felt uncannily true, you have met the Barnum effect, also called the Forer effect. In 1948 psychologist Bertram Forer gave 39 students what he said were personal personality profiles. In fact every student received the same text, taken largely from an astrology book, and they rated its accuracy at 4.3 out of 5 on average.

Descriptions work this way when they are warm, mostly positive and vague enough to fit almost anyone. Most of us want close relationships, sometimes hide our feelings, and occasionally look back on the past. Enjoy quizzes like this one as prompts for reflection, but treat a result that “feels right” as a sign of good writing rather than proof.

What looking at art can really do

The broader claim behind quizzes like this, that engaging with art changes how we think, has better support. The strongest example comes from the Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art in Bentonville, Arkansas, which opened in 2011. So many schools applied for tours that researchers Jay P. Greene, Brian Kisida and Daniel H. Bowen could assign tours by lottery, comparing similar students who had and had not yet visited.

They surveyed 10,912 students and 489 teachers from 123 schools, usually about three weeks after the visit, and scored more than 3,800 short essays about a painting the students had never seen. Results, published in Education Next in 2014, showed modest gains in critical thinking about art, historical empathy and tolerance among students who toured. The benefits were largest for rural students and those from high-poverty schools. As the authors put it, “The less prior exposure to culturally enriching experiences students have, the larger the benefit.”

You may also have read that looking at art feels like falling in love. That comes from brain-imaging research by neuroscientist Semir Zeki at University College London, which linked the experience of beauty in art and music to activity in a part of the brain’s emotional and reward network, the medial orbitofrontal cortex. Popular reports dramatised this as a “dopamine rush” similar to romance; the studies were small and did not measure dopamine directly, so that comparison is best taken loosely.

The practical takeaway is simple. Visiting a museum, looking slowly at a painting, or even puzzling over a double image with a friend is good exercise for attention and conversation, whatever you happened to see first.

Sources: Greene, Kisida and Bowen, Education Next (2014): The educational value of field trips; Wikipedia: Multistable perception; Wikipedia: Rorschach test; Wikipedia: Barnum effect; Wikipedia: Semir Zeki. Quiz idea via Mystical Raven and Understanding Compassion; the artist of the image is not credited in those sources.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1