Family Cloth: Reusable Toilet Wipes Explained, Pros and Cons

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published April 28, 2018.

Reusable Toilet Cloths and the Questions Behind the Online Reaction

A “family cloth” is a set of small fabric squares kept in the bathroom and used in place of toilet paper. After use, each square goes into a lidded container, and the whole batch is laundered and used again. The name is misleading: nobody shares a single cloth. Each wipe is used once by one person and then washed, much like a reusable nappy or a handkerchief.

The idea surfaced on social media in early 2018 and drew a wave of horrified jokes. Behind the jokes sit fair questions about hygiene, laundry and the environmental cost of paper. This guide explains how the system works, who uses it and why, what the evidence says, and what simpler options exist if your real goal is to waste less.

How a family cloth system works in practice

Most households that try it follow a similar routine. A basket of clean squares sits next to the toilet, usually cut from soft cotton flannel, old T-shirts or bamboo terry. Many people keep a roll of ordinary paper nearby as well, for guests or for days when they would simply rather not.

Used squares go into a separate bin with a tight lid, sometimes lined with a washable bag. Some people keep the bin dry; others add a little water and vinegar. On wash day the bag is emptied straight into the machine without handling the contents.

Plenty of advocates reserve the cloths for urine only and use paper after a bowel movement. That single choice removes most of the “ick” and much of the hygiene worry, and it is the version people most often stick with long term.

Reusable Toilet Cloths and the Questions Behind the Online Reaction

Etsy/CreeksideKid

Ready-made sets are sold by small makers on craft marketplaces such as Etsy, often in printed flannel or in colours chosen to hide stains. The set pictured above was listed by a seller called CreeksideKid, who also makes cloth wipes for nappy bags. Others simply cut up worn-out clothing and hem the edges, so the start-up cost can be close to zero.

Why some people choose cloth over paper

Reasons vary, and they are not all environmental.

  • Cost. Toilet paper is a recurring expense. Washing an extra small load is cheap if you already run a washing machine.
  • Comfort. Some people with sensitive skin find soft flannel gentler than paper, especially the heavily scented or lotion-treated kind.
  • Habit from cloth nappies. Parents who already wash reusable nappies and baby wipes often find that adding family cloth makes little difference to their routine.
  • Waste and forests. Paper made from virgin wood pulp has a real footprint, and some households want to cut it.
  • Shortages. Interest reportedly rose again in spring 2020, when panic buying emptied toilet-paper shelves in many countries.

Why the internet reacted so strongly

When the term went viral in March 2018, much of the response was pure comic disgust. The meme account 9GAG shared the concept to millions of followers, and the replies set the tone.

Reusable Toilet Cloths and the Questions Behind the Online Reaction

Twitter/@9GAG

Writer Nicole Cliffe summed up the mood in five words, calling it “my one true enemy”. Another user joked that discovering the practice made him want to sue everyone involved.

Reusable Toilet Cloths and the Questions Behind the Online Reaction

Twitter/@Nicole_Cliffe

Amy Shuford went further, tweeting that it was surely “the fall of Western civilization”. The humour is understandable. Toilet habits are personal, and most people in Western countries grew up thinking of paper as the only hygienic choice.

Reusable Toilet Cloths and the Questions Behind the Online Reaction

Twitter/@angelamy444

Yet the reaction says more about custom than about germs. Across much of the world, people clean themselves with water rather than paper, and many regard a dry wipe as the less hygienic option. Paper itself only became common relatively recently: it was used for this purpose in China by the 6th century, but packaged toilet paper was not sold in the United States until Joseph Gayetty’s medicated sheets appeared in 1857. Before that, rags, leaves, corn cobs and old newspapers all did the job.

Is it hygienic? What to know before trying it

There is little formal research on reusable toilet wipes specifically, so it is better to reason from what is known about laundry and household hygiene than to claim the practice is either safe or dangerous.

  • Wash hot and wash separately. A hot cycle with detergent, followed by thorough drying (ideally in a tumble dryer or full sunlight), is the usual advice for anything soiled with bodily fluids, such as cloth nappies.
  • One wipe, one use, one person. Never reuse a square before it has been laundered.
  • Keep the bin closed and empty it often. Every two or three days is common. A lid controls smell and keeps pets and toddlers away.
  • Think about illness. During a stomach bug or other infection, switching back to disposable paper is sensible, as is washing your hands well after handling the bin.
  • Watch your skin. If you notice irritation, recurring infections or anything unusual, talk to a doctor.

Households without their own washing machine, or with shared laundry facilities, may reasonably decide the system is impractical. That is a fair conclusion rather than a failure.

The environmental case, with the numbers

Toilet paper is a bigger issue than it looks. Wikipedia’s summary of industry figures puts global production at around 83 million rolls a day, consuming roughly 27,000 trees daily, with an average of about 141 rolls per person per year in the United States, around half as much again as in other Western countries or Japan.

In February 2019 the Natural Resources Defense Council and Stand.earth published a scorecard called The Issue With Tissue. It gave failing grades to several of America’s best-selling toilet papers, including Charmin, Quilted Northern and Angel Soft, because they contained no recycled fibre. NRDC links much of that virgin pulp to Canada’s boreal forest, which it describes as the largest intact forest in the world; industry analysts have disputed how much of the fibre really comes from old boreal forest rather than managed plantations. The same report estimates that tissue made from recycled material produces about a third of the greenhouse gas emissions of tissue made from virgin wood.

Cloth is not automatically greener. A fair comparison has to count the cotton that went into the fabric, plus the water, energy and detergent used in washing. Whether reusable squares come out ahead depends on how they are washed, whether they are added to loads you would run anyway, and how many years they last. No published life-cycle assessment settles the question for a typical home.

Easier ways to cut toilet-paper waste

If the environmental argument appeals but the laundry does not, there are smaller steps with fewer trade-offs.

  • Buy recycled or certified paper. Brands that scored well on the NRDC scorecard, such as Seventh Generation and Natural Value, use a high share of recycled content. FSC certification is another useful label.
  • Try a bidet or bidet attachment. Washing with water is standard in many countries and greatly reduces how much paper you need for drying. Clip-on bidet seats are inexpensive and fit most toilets.
  • Look at alternative fibres. Papers made from bamboo or sugarcane waste (bagasse) avoid wood pulp altogether, though their overall footprint depends on how they are grown and shipped.
  • Use less. Thicker, better-quality paper often means fewer sheets per visit.

Family cloth is a niche practice that tends to provoke more laughter than curiosity. For some households it is a practical, comfortable habit; for others it is a step too far. Both views are reasonable. Anyone who wants to try it can start small, with cloths for urine only and a hot wash, and see whether the routine suits them.

Sources: NRDC press release on The Issue With Tissue (February 2019); NRDC, Jennifer Skene: The Issue with Tissue; ResourceWise on toilet paper and North American forests; Wikipedia: Toilet paper. Images: Etsy/CreeksideKid, 9GAG, @Nicole_Cliffe, @angelamy444 on X (Twitter).

COMMENTS