Instagram vs Reality: 15 Photos Showing What Happens Behind the Pose

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
15 Social Media Photo Jokes: Poses and What Happens Around Them

These fifteen side-by-side photos show the same thing over and over: a polished picture made for Instagram, Twitter or Snapchat, and a second frame taken a moment earlier or later that reveals how it was really made. A pin-up model relaxes on a lawn between shots, a “pool” turns out to be a paddling pool in a back garden, and a Maserati steering wheel is only a picture on a computer monitor.

The pairs circulated widely in 2017 under hashtags such as #instagramvsreality, collected by sites like Bright Side, Izismile and several Russian-language aggregators. Some were posted by the people in them as self-mockery; others were staged on purpose to make a point about online life. None of them catches anyone doing anything shameful. They simply show the work, the luck and the clever framing that sit behind a picture that looks effortless.

That is why they are funny, and also why they are useful. Most of us know that social media is a highlight reel, yet a single convincing image can still make someone else’s day, body or holiday feel more perfect than our own. Seeing the second frame is a quick reminder of how much a camera leaves out. Below, each pair is described with what is actually going on, followed by a short look at why staged photos persuade us so easily.

Posing on cue, and the moment after

1. On set and off set

When you're asked to pose and when you set free!

This pair comes from a tweet by Kitty Blues (@jazzykatblues), tagged #instagramvsreality and #pinupgirl. On the left she strikes a classic pin-up pose in a lounge chair, styled and lit like a vintage magazine shot. On the right she sits on the grass in the same garden, sunglasses on and water bottle nearby, clearly between takes. Pin-up photography is a craft, and the “off set” picture shows how much posing and lighting it takes.

2. A snowboard trick, or a fall?

The fall seems like he did a stunt!

The large frame shows a snowboarder carving low with one glove trailing in the snow, an image that looks like an action shot from a resort brochure. The small inset reveals the same rider sprawled on the slope a second later. Fast shutter speeds freeze any instant, so a stumble can look like a deliberate move if you pick the right frame.

3. The holiday-villa pool

Another pool party

Shot tight, the water looks like a resort pool in front of a timber house with a traditional curved tiled roof. Pull the camera back and it is a small above-ground paddling pool sitting on a lawn, with the same house behind it. Cropping is the oldest trick in photography and costs nothing.

4. The friend who does the real work

That’s real friendship!

One woman poses on a bed in front of a “Sunshine & Saltwater” sign while a friend kneels over a third person to get the angle right with a phone. Group selfies and “candid” portraits often need a photographer, a stylist and someone willing to be used as furniture. It is a good picture of friendship as much as of photography.

5. Wind on the seafront

Ooh, La La!

Posted on Instagram by @connie_with_a_k, this pair shows a couple sitting on a sea wall. In the first frame both smile neatly for the camera; in the second, a gust throws her hair straight up while she laughs. Many people would delete the second photo, but it is the one that shows a real moment.

Phones, food and borrowed luxury

6. Time together, spent on screens

The sad truth about the time we spend on social media.

This staged pair was shared on Instagram by Petteri Hautala (@petteri_hautala), a Finnish account, with the tags #instagramvsreality and #humour. The “Instagram” version shows three friends laughing and touching close together; the “real life” version shows the same three sitting apart, each looking at a phone. It is a joke, but it touches a real habit: checking a device in the middle of time with people we actually came to see.

7. Broccoli versus a tub of Nutella

Broccoli versus Nutella

On the “Insta” side, a smiling young woman bites a raw head of broccoli with perfect make-up. On the “Real life” side, the same woman, without make-up and looking tired, eats chocolate spread straight from a catering-size Nutella tub. Healthy-eating photos are one of the most common categories on Instagram, and this parody works because almost everyone has had the second kind of evening.

8. Legs that go on forever

Such an alluring body!

From behind, a woman in a pink top and denim shorts seems to sit at a picnic table with an impossibly long torso and legs. The second frame shows she is actually standing behind the bench, and the table edge hides the gap. It is a simple forced-perspective illusion, the same kind tourists use to “hold up” the Leaning Tower of Pisa.

9. Driving the boyfriend’s car

When bae allows you to take his car

The Snapchat caption brags about “driving bae’s car”, a Maserati with a red leather steering wheel, while long manicured nails rest on the rim. The second frame shows the trident logo is on a photo displayed on a computer monitor, and the hand is just held in front of the screen. Luxury by screenshot is cheap, and this one has been widely copied as a meme.

10. The Eiffel Tower in the bathroom

A personal Eiffel Tower in the loo

A young man in a cap grins in a selfie with what looks like the Eiffel Tower over his shoulder. The second photo reveals a small souvenir model standing on a bathroom windowsill above the toilet. The real tower is 330 metres tall and stands in Paris; this one was probably bought there for a few euros.

Elaborate shoots and unruly waves

11. A door on a lonely rock

The things you do to take a stunning picture.

The main image is moody fine-art style: a tall wooden wardrobe door stands on a rocky island in a misty sea. The behind-the-scenes frames show a miniature door on a heap of pebbles at the water’s edge, with the photographer adding mist from a glass container and shooting from ground level. Miniature sets and practical effects like this are common among creative photographers, who share their methods as part of the fun.

12. A wave with other plans

The waves stole the show!

A tattooed woman in a white bikini reclines on the wet sand for a glamour shot at the shoreline. In the second frame, the incoming wave hits her full on and she disappears under a burst of foam and sand. Beach photographers know the sea does not wait, and many shoots at the surf line end exactly like this.

13. Holding up Lady Liberty

He took 'Statue' of liberty too seriously!

Against a blue sky, the silhouette looks like the Statue of Liberty in New York Harbor. The second frame, taken by a window, shows a thumb at the base: it is a small replica held up to the glass. The real statue, a gift from France dedicated in 1886, stands about 93 metres including its pedestal, which makes the trick even funnier.

14. Perfect timing, in reverse

This is the definition of the perfect timing!

A woman in a denim shirt stands barefoot on a rock in front of a cove where sea lions rest. In the next frame, a wave breaks behind her and drenches her legs as she scrambles. Coastal rocks are slippery and waves are hard to predict, so this one doubles as a gentle safety lesson for anyone climbing out for a photo.

15. A headstand on a paddleboard

Here's why they say those who travel on two boats at a time definitely drown!

Stand-up paddleboard yoga became popular in the 2010s, and the first frame shows an impressive headstand in a yellow swimsuit on a board floating on calm water. The second frame shows the balance slipping as one leg drops toward the water. Every successful pose on a moving board comes with many wobbles and falls that never make the feed.

Why one good frame fools us

Almost every pair above relies on one of three techniques. The first is cropping: show the pool, not the garden. The second is forced perspective, where objects at different distances line up so that a small souvenir looks as big as a monument. Film-makers use the same principle; the hobbits in The Lord of the Rings were made to look small partly through camera angles and specially built sets. The third is selection: take twenty photos and post the one where the fall looks like a trick.

None of this is dishonest in itself. Photographers have always chosen angles and moments. The trouble starts when viewers forget that choice was made. Psychologist Leon Festinger described in 1954 how people judge themselves by comparing with others, and later researchers separated “upward” comparison (with people who seem better off) from “downward” comparison. Studies of Instagram users have linked heavy upward comparison with lower mood and self-esteem, although the effect varies from person to person and is not automatic.

A few common myths

  • “Everyone else’s life is like their feed.” Feeds are edited highlights, often taken in a few minutes of a long and ordinary day.
  • “Only influencers stage photos.” Ordinary users crop, retake and filter constantly; that is simply how phone cameras are used.
  • “A real photo cannot be misleading.” Every image in this list is real and unedited; the illusion comes from framing and timing, not software.

Enjoying the polished version without the pressure

The people in these pairs are not frauds. Many posted the second frame themselves, which is the healthiest response to the pressure of a perfect feed. A useful habit is to save at least one outtake from every outing alongside the best shot: the windblown hair, the friend on her knees, the wave that arrived early. Those are often the pictures that bring back the day years later.

When a picture online makes you feel that your life is smaller, try asking what the second frame would show. There is almost always a tub of chocolate spread, a paddling pool or a souvenir model just out of view. For more examples of the same idea, see Social-Media Photo Tricks: The Scene Beyond the Crop.

Sources: photos compiled from posts by Kitty Blues (@jazzykatblues, Twitter), @connie_with_a_k and @petteri_hautala (Instagram) and other social media users, as shared by Bright Side, VK.am, Izismile and Lexibay; Wikipedia: Forced perspective; Wikipedia: Social comparison theory.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1