
Every one of the ten pictures below has been passed around as a real photograph, and every one of them misleads in some way. Most are composites, where two genuine photos were cut and blended into one impossible scene. A few were recoloured. One is a real picture that simply travelled with a false story, and one is a piece of digital art that was mistaken for a snapshot from space.
The comparison at the top shows the whole trick in a single frame. On the right is the original: a pilot leaning out of his cockpit window with a selfie stick while the aircraft stands on the tarmac. On the left, the ground has been swapped for a sea of clouds, and suddenly the same grin looks like a stunt at cruising altitude. Nothing about the man changed; only the background did.
Knowing why each image fooled people is more useful than simply knowing it is fake, because the same patterns repeat in new viral photos every week. For each picture we explain what it really shows, where the pieces came from when that is known, and the clue that gives it away. At the end you will find a short checklist you can use the next time something looks too good to be true.
Composites: two real photos, one impossible scene
1. The shark leaping at a helicopter
This is probably the most famous fake photo of the early internet. Emails from around 2001 claimed it showed a great white lunging at a British military helicopter off South Africa and that National Geographic had named it "photo of the year". National Geographic never did; it publicly called the picture a hoax.
The helicopter is a US Air Force HH-60G Pave Hawk photographed by Lance Cheung in front of San Francisco's Golden Gate Bridge, whose tower is visible at the top. The breaching shark was photographed by Charles Maxwell in False Bay, South Africa. An unknown hoaxer joined the two.
2. The castle on a sea stack
The smaller pictures on the right reveal both ingredients. The castle is Lichtenstein Castle, a 19th-century building near Reutlingen in south-west Germany, which actually stands on a cliff about 250 metres above the Echaz valley. The rock is Ko Tapu, a limestone pillar about 20 metres tall in Thailand's Phang Nga Bay, made famous by the 1974 James Bond film The Man with the Golden Gun.
Put together they make a fairy-tale image, and as digital art it is lovely. It only becomes a problem when it is shared as a real place people can visit.
3. The bear chasing photographers
Panicked people sprinting across a meadow with a tripod and a reflector, and a bear behind them: it looks like a wildlife shoot gone wrong. The people and the bear were reportedly photographed separately and combined.
The clue is in the lighting and scale. The bear sits oddly small and flat against the grass, and its shadow and the light on its fur do not quite match the bright, hard light on the runners.
4. The pilot's mid-air selfie
This is the same pair of images as the one at the top of the page. Even without the original for comparison, the physics gives it away: on an airliner in flight the cockpit is pressurised and the side windows cannot simply be opened, and the airflow at several hundred kilometres per hour would rip a selfie stick out of anyone's hand.
Pilot "selfies" like this are a small genre of their own. In a similar case from 2017, a pilot who posted an apparent shot over Dubai's Palm Jumeirah admitted it was a ground photo pasted onto aerial scenery.
5. The giant dog
Big mastiff breeds really can be huge, but none reaches the shoulder height of a horse, as this one appears to. The dog has been enlarged and placed into the scene.
Watch the feet and the ground: the dog's paws barely press into the grass, and its shadow is weaker than the horse's and the walkers'. Scale fakes like this are easy to spot once you compare them with something whose size you know.
Recoloured and retouched
6. The blue watermelon
Watermelons come in red, pink, yellow, orange and white varieties, but no blue-fleshed one exists. This is an ordinary slice with its flesh recoloured, and the hue spills unevenly into the rind.
The image often travelled with extra nonsense, such as the claim that the fruit turns red again when you bite it. Fake pictures tend to pick up decorations like this as they are shared.
7. The black lion
The lower picture is the original: a white lion, a rare colour form of the ordinary lion, resting on grass. The upper version was darkened to create a "black lion", an animal that has never been reliably documented.
Pale lions are real and are caused by a recessive gene; true black (melanistic) lions are not known. Melanism occurs in leopards and jaguars, which is part of why the edit feels believable.
8. The swastika lollipop
The picture claims to show a child in Nazi Germany licking a lollipop decorated with a swastika. It was listed among doctored viral images, and we found no documented evidence that such sweets existed.
Heavy contrast and an HDR-style filter give it an "old photo" look while smoothing over the joins. Fake history photos are especially sticky because they confirm what people already believe about a period.
A real photo with a false story
9. The "MGM lion" in a scanner
This one is different: the left-hand photo is genuine. It shows a sedated lion being given a CT scan, reportedly Samson, a young lion examined at the Hai-Kef zoo in Rishon LeZion, Israel, in 2005. Someone added the Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer banner to suggest the studio's famous roaring logo was filmed with a strapped-down animal.
The MGM logo footage was shot with several different lions over the decades in film studios, not in a hospital scanner. The roar has nothing to do with this picture.
Digital art taken for a photograph
10. A solar eclipse "seen from the space station"
This dramatic ring of light over a curved Earth is a digital illustration, not a photo from the International Space Station. Astronauts have photographed eclipses from orbit, but what they actually see looks very different: a dark smudge of the Moon's shadow sliding across the clouds below.
The giveaways are the perfectly placed Milky Way, the crisp corona and the size of the Moon, which would look far smaller from low Earth orbit.
How to check a viral photo yourself
- Run a reverse image search. Google Lens, TinEye or Bing Visual Search often turn up the original photos within seconds, as they would for the shark and the castle.
- Check light and shadows. In a composite, objects often have shadows pointing the wrong way, or none at all.
- Compare sizes. Look for something of known size nearby: a person, a car, a doorway.
- Ask whether it is physically possible. Opening a cockpit window in flight, a blue-fleshed melon or a black lion should all raise questions before you share.
- Be wary of awards and authorities. "National Geographic photo of the year" was invented to make a fake feel official.
- Look up fact-checkers. Snopes, AFP Fact Check and similar sites have catalogued most famous fakes.
Plenty of these images are clever pieces of photo art and deserve credit as such. Enjoying them is fine; the trouble starts only when they are passed on as evidence of something that never happened.
Sources: Wikipedia: Helicopter Shark; Museum of Hoaxes: Helicopter Shark; Wikipedia: Lichtenstein Castle; Wikipedia: Khao Phing Kan; Snopes: pilot cockpit selfie; images first collected by DeffDuck, BuzzFeed and Gizmodo (linked under each picture).

COMMENTS