Jim Carrey's 'Meaningless' Fashion Week Interview Explained

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-01-30.

“We are a field of energy ..and I don’t care”

In September 2017, Jim Carrey turned a routine red-carpet chat into one of the most talked-about celebrity interviews of the year. Arriving at Harper’s Bazaar’s Icons party during New York Fashion Week, he told E! News reporter Catt Sadler that there was no meaning to any of it, that he did not believe in personalities or icons, and that people are a field of energy. Sadler was visibly lost for words, and the clip went viral within days.

Some viewers saw a comedian trolling the fashion world; others heard a man sharing a sincere spiritual outlook he had been developing for years. Here is what happened, what he actually said, and the context that helps explain it.

What happened on the red carpet

The party, hosted by fashion editor Carine Roitfeld, was held on Friday 8 September 2017 to celebrate style icons. Carrey arrived alone, dressed smartly, and began the interview by slowly circling Sadler. When she asked why he had come, he replied that he had searched for the most meaningless event he could find and joined it.

Sadler tried to steer back to the theme of the night, celebrating icons. Carrey called that the lowest-aiming idea imaginable and told her he did not believe in personalities. At one point he briefly broke into a James Brown impression, singing a snatch of “Get on the Good Foot”, and reportedly a Jimi Hendrix bit as well, before returning to his philosophical riff.

When Sadler pointed out that he had clearly dressed up for the occasion, he answered that he had not, because there was no “me” to dress up. He finished by telling her that we don’t matter, called that the good news, and walked away with his hands on her shoulders.

The key lines, in context

The full exchange lasts under two minutes, and the video below shows it from start to finish. A few lines became the most quoted:

“There’s no meaning to any of this, so I wanted to find the most meaningless thing that I could come to and join.” — Jim Carrey to E! News

His central idea was that identity is a kind of costume. He compared fame and personality to the red “S” on Superman’s chest, something people wear to feel invincible, and said he believed peace lies deeper than that.

“I believe we’re a field of energy, dancing for itself. And I don’t care.”

He went on to describe the self as an illusion, saying there are only events happening and, in a phrase that puzzled many viewers, groups of tetrahedrons drifting about as one.

“Here’s the thing, it’s not our world. We don’t matter.”

Where Carrey’s ideas come from

Although the interview looked improvised, the themes were not new for Carrey. He has spoken for years about meditation and spiritual teachers. He practises Transcendental Meditation and has publicly credited the writer Eckhart Tolle, whose books focus on the present moment and on not over-identifying with the thinking mind. Carrey has described a spiritual experience after studying Tolle’s teachings in which he felt he was the universe rather than a separate fragment of it.

Seen in that light, lines about having no self and being energy echo ideas found in Buddhism, Advaita Vedanta and modern mindfulness writing: that the sense of a fixed “I” is a mental construction and that letting go of it brings peace. Whether you find that profound or baffling, it is a recognisable philosophical position rather than random nonsense.

It is worth being clear about one thing. “Field of energy” is spiritual language, not physics. Carrey was not offering a scientific theory of matter, and the line about tetrahedrons is best read as a poetic image.

What else was happening in his life

Carrey had kept a relatively low profile in the preceding years. Since around 2011 he had been painting seriously, and in 2017 he released I Needed Color, a short documentary about his studio work. Days before the party, Netflix acquired Jim & Andy: The Great Beyond, a documentary about how he stayed in character as comedian Andy Kaufman while filming Man on the Moon in the late 1990s. That film, which premiered at the Venice Film Festival, explores many of the same questions about identity and performance.

He was also facing a painful legal case. His former girlfriend, the Irish make-up artist Cathriona White, died in September 2015, and the Los Angeles County medical examiner ruled her death a suicide. Her husband, Mark Burton, and later her mother, Brigid Sweetman, filed wrongful-death lawsuits alleging Carrey had supplied the prescription drugs involved. Carrey denied the claims. Both suits were dismissed on 25 January 2018, a few months after this interview.

Performance, prank or sincere philosophy?

The honest answer may be all three. Carrey built his career on physical comedy and unpredictability, and the circling, the impressions and the deadpan delivery are classic Carrey. At the same time, the content matches what he had said in calmer settings, including speeches about forgiveness and spirituality earlier that year.

The setting mattered, too. A fashion-week party celebrating icons is about as pure a celebration of image and status as exists. Turning up to say that personality is an illusion was, at the very least, a pointed piece of theatre. Some commentators found it uncomfortable to watch, especially for the reporter caught in the middle; others found it refreshing that a celebrity refused to recite the usual lines.

Whatever your view, the clip endures because it raises a question most red carpets avoid: what is all this attention actually for?

Practical takeaways from a strange two minutes

  • Labels are not the whole person. Carrey’s point that fame is a costume applies to everyday roles too: job titles, reputations and online personas are only part of who someone is.
  • Detachment can be freeing. Many meditation traditions teach that caring less about how we are seen reduces anxiety. That is different from not caring about other people.
  • Context changes meaning. The same words sound wise in a meditation hall and odd on a red carpet. Before judging a viral clip, it helps to know the background.
  • Be kind to the person on the other end. The reporter was doing her job. Bold ideas land better when they do not leave someone else stranded.

Sources: TODAY, Jim Carrey calls New York Fashion Week event “meaningless” in viral interview; The New Daily, Jim Carrey derails red carpet interview (11 September 2017); Jim Carrey (Wikipedia). Interview footage: E! News, via YouTube.

COMMENTS