Former Facebook Executives on Social Media's Dopamine Feedback Loops

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-01-30.

Former Facebook Executive Warns Us: “You Don’t Realize It But You Are Being Programmed”

In late 2017, two men who helped build Facebook into a global giant said publicly that they regretted parts of what they had created. Sean Parker, the company's first president, said social networks were designed to exploit human psychology. Chamath Palihapitiya, who had led Facebook's user growth, told Stanford students that he felt tremendous guilt and that social media was damaging how society works. Palihapitiya later softened his criticism of Facebook itself, but their remarks became a turning point in the public debate about what social media does to us.

This article looks at exactly what each of them said, what they meant by "dopamine" and "programming", what research has found since, and practical ways to keep your own use of social media in check.

Sean Parker: designed to capture attention

Parker, who had joined Facebook in 2004 as founding president and later became a billionaire investor and philanthropist, spoke at an Axios event in Philadelphia in November 2017. He said the thinking behind early social apps was simple: how to consume as much of a user's time and conscious attention as possible.

The answer, he explained, was to give people small rewards whenever someone liked or commented on their posts, so they would post more and come back more often. He called this a social-validation feedback loop and said it was:

"exploiting a vulnerability in human psychology."

He said the founders understood this and built it anyway. Looking at the effects of a network that had grown to two billion people, he worried aloud about what it was doing to children's developing brains, and described himself as something of a conscientious objector on social media.

Chamath Palihapitiya: guilt at Stanford

Palihapitiya worked at Facebook from 2007 to 2011, leading efforts to grow its user base before leaving to found the venture firm Social Capital. In a November 2017 talk at the Stanford Graduate School of Business, which drew wide attention when the video spread in December, he went further than Parker:

"The short-term, dopamine-driven feedback loops we've created are destroying how society works."

He listed what he saw as the results: no civil discourse, no cooperation, plenty of misinformation. He stressed that this was a global problem, not just a matter of Russian advertising in the 2016 US election. Asked whether he had done any soul-searching, he said he felt deep guilt, and that the people building these platforms had suspected in the back of their minds that something could go wrong, just not in the way it did.

He told the audience he no longer used social media himself, and that his children were not allowed to either. Speaking bluntly, and with some strong language, he warned the students that being clever was no protection:

"Your behaviors, you don't realize it, but you are being programmed."

You can watch the talk below.

Facebook's reply and Palihapitiya's step back

Facebook responded that the company had changed a great deal since Palihapitiya left about six years earlier, and pointed to work on understanding how its products affect people. A few days later, on 15 December 2017, Palihapitiya posted on Facebook that his comments had been meant to start an important conversation, not to criticise one company, which he said he loved. He praised Facebook as a force for good that had made strides in addressing its unintended influence.

The clarification did not stop the original clip from spreading. Together, the two men's comments gave critics a powerful line: even insiders were worried. Parker's and Palihapitiya's views are a perspective from people who built the product, though, not scientific findings in themselves.

Is social media really a dopamine machine?

The word dopamine has become shorthand for anything addictive, but the science is more nuanced. Dopamine is a brain chemical involved in motivation and learning which rewards are worth seeking. It does not simply produce pleasure on demand. Unpredictable rewards, like not knowing whether a post will get five likes or fifty, are especially good at keeping people checking, a pattern long studied in behavioural psychology.

Features such as infinite scrolling, autoplay, push notifications and visible like counts all make use of this. That is the concrete point behind Parker's comments: design choices can be examined and changed, whatever one thinks of the broader claim that users are being programmed.

A common myth is that a single like gives the same hit as a drug. It does not, and most people who use social media heavily are not clinically addicted. But researchers do increasingly agree that heavy use can crowd out sleep, exercise and face-to-face time, and that some people, especially young people, are more vulnerable than others.

What the research says about young people

In 2023, US Surgeon General Vivek Murthy issued an advisory on social media and youth mental health. It noted that up to 95% of 13- to 17-year-olds use social media and about a third say they use it almost constantly. Young people who spend more than three hours a day on it face double the risk of symptoms of depression and anxiety, and 46% of teens said it made them feel worse about their bodies.

The advisory was careful about cause and effect, saying the evidence has gaps, but concluded that social media cannot yet be considered sufficiently safe for children and adolescents. It called on technology companies to design for health and safety and to share data with independent researchers, and on governments to set age-appropriate standards. Since then, several countries and US states have moved to restrict children's access or require safety features.

Practical ways to take back control

You do not need to quit social media entirely, as Palihapitiya says he did, to use it more deliberately. Small changes can make a real difference:

  • Turn off non-essential notifications so you decide when to open an app, rather than the app deciding for you.
  • Set time limits using the screen-time tools built into most phones, and notice how you feel after a session.
  • Keep phones out of the bedroom and away from meals; tech-free zones are one of the Surgeon General's main suggestions for families.
  • Curate your feed by muting accounts that leave you anxious or angry and following ones that teach or inspire you.
  • Talk with children about how apps are designed to hold attention, and agree a family media plan together.

If social media use is affecting your mood, sleep or relationships, it is worth talking to a doctor or a mental health professional.

Sources: Axios: Sean Parker unloads on Facebook, November 2017; CNBC, 15 December 2017; Wikipedia: Chamath Palihapitiya; US Surgeon General: Social Media and Youth Mental Health advisory. Video: Stanford Graduate School of Business.

COMMENTS