A Four-Card Reasoning Puzzle Inspired by the Wason Selection Task

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2017-12-05.

Explain the answer as well as choosing it

After each question, write the assumption that makes your answer follow. Comparing explanations is more useful than treating the final score as a measure of general intelligence; a brief online quiz is not a validated cognitive assessment.

A Reasoning Quiz for Practising Logical Choices

How logical are you? This four-card selection task associated with psychologist Peter Wason can help you find out!


The only thing you need to do is assess which of the four cards should be turned over to determine whether the rules have been followed.



Reference: YouTube

Look for the case that could break the rule

A rule of the form “if P, then Q” can be contradicted by P together with not-Q. Seeing Q alone does not establish P. That distinction is the puzzle’s useful idea: choose information that could expose a violation, rather than collecting examples that merely look reassuring. The framing and wording still matter to how readers approach it.

How people usually do on the task

The psychologist Peter Cathcart Wason devised the selection task in 1966. In one common version, four cards show 3, 8, blue and red, and the rule is “if a card shows an even number on one face, its opposite face is blue”. The correct choice is to turn over the 8 and the red card. In Wason’s study fewer than 10 per cent of people found that solution, a result replicated in 1993. People do much better when the same logic is framed as a social rule, such as “if you are drinking alcohol, you must be over 18”: most have no difficulty choosing the cards showing 16 and drinking beer. In 1992 Cosmides and Tooby argued that this reflects a specialised mechanism for detecting cheaters, an interpretation disputed by Davies and colleagues in 1995.

Sources: Wikipedia: Wason selection task

COMMENTS