Net Neutrality Explained: The 2017 FCC Repeal and What Came After

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published December 5, 2017.

Net Neutrality What You Need To Know And How To Save It

Net neutrality is the idea that the company selling you internet access should carry all lawful traffic on equal terms: it should not block a site, deliberately slow an app, or sell a faster lane to whoever pays most. In the United States the question became a national fight in 2017, when the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) moved to scrap the rules that had written this principle into federal regulation two years earlier.

The FCC did repeal those rules, on 14 December 2017. The story did not end there. States wrote their own laws, the FCC tried to bring the federal rules back in 2024, and a federal appeals court struck that attempt down in January 2025. Here is what the principle means, why so many people cared, and where things stand.

What net neutrality actually means

Think of your broadband or mobile provider as the road between your device and everything else online. Net neutrality says the road owner may manage traffic jams and charge you for a faster connection overall, but it may not pick favourites among the destinations. Under a neutral system, a small video start-up and a giant streaming service arrive at your screen under the same rules.

Three practices sit at the heart of the debate:

  • Blocking: refusing to connect users to a lawful website or service.
  • Throttling: deliberately degrading certain kinds of traffic, such as video or file-sharing.
  • Paid prioritisation: letting content companies pay for faster delivery, which critics call creating fast and slow lanes.

A related grey zone is zero-rating, where a provider exempts selected apps from your data allowance. It feels like a free gift, but it nudges users toward the services the provider has chosen.

How the 2017 repeal happened

In February 2015 the FCC voted 3–2 to classify broadband as a telecommunications service under Title II of the Communications Act. That gave the agency firmer legal footing to ban blocking, throttling and paid prioritisation. The rules took effect in June 2015, after a long public campaign in their favour.

After the 2016 election, the new FCC chairman, Ajit Pai, argued that the 2015 order was heavy-handed and discouraged network investment. In May 2017 the commission voted 2–1 to begin undoing it. The public comment window that followed drew roughly 21.9 million submissions, more than the agency had ever received.

Net Neutrality What You Need To Know And How To Save It

That flood of comments later became a scandal of its own. A 2021 investigation by the New York Attorney General concluded that around 18 million of them were fake: about 8.5 million were generated through lead-generation campaigns funded by the broadband industry, and about 9.3 million pro-neutrality comments were filed under made-up or stolen identities. Studies of the genuine, unique comments found that the vast majority supported keeping the rules.

On 14 December 2017 the FCC voted 3–2, along party lines, to adopt the "Restoring Internet Freedom" order. Broadband went back to being an "information service" under the lighter Title I, and the bans on blocking and throttling were replaced mainly by a requirement that providers disclose their practices. The repeal took effect on 11 June 2018.

Real disputes that shaped the debate

Supporters of net neutrality did not argue from theory alone. Several real episodes, some well documented and some less so, fed the campaign:

Blocked internet calls

In 2005 a small North Carolina carrier, Madison River Communications, blocked the ports used by Vonage's internet phone service. It settled with the FCC, paying $15,000 and agreeing to stop. A few years later, AT&T restricted which iPhone apps could run over its network, and calling apps such as Skype were among the services affected.

Throttled file-sharing

Between 2007 and 2008 Comcast was found to be interfering with BitTorrent uploads by injecting forged "reset" signals into users' connections. The FCC ruled against Comcast in 2008, but a federal appeals court said in 2010 that the agency had lacked the authority to enforce its order. Comcast separately settled a class action for $16 million.

Net Neutrality What You Need To Know And How To Save It

A union website in Canada

During a 2005 labour dispute, the Canadian telecom company Telus blocked its subscribers from reaching a website that supported its striking workers. It is often cited as the clearest example of how a provider could use its network to silence a political opponent.

Video, FaceTime and tethering

In 2012 consumer groups complained that AT&T only allowed FaceTime over cellular on certain data plans. In 2014 Netflix streams slowed noticeably on some large networks during disputes over interconnection fees, which led the FCC to look into those deals. Verizon reportedly settled with the FCC in 2012 over blocking apps that let customers use their phones as Wi-Fi hotspots.

Some claims that circulated widely in 2017, such as a UK provider making gamers buy premium plans or a US cable firm forcing home workers to pay for VPN access in 2001, are much harder to verify and are best treated with caution.

Arguments for and against the rules

Supporters see neutrality as protection for free expression and competition. If providers can charge for priority, they argue, established giants will pay and newcomers will not, and the next big idea may never get a fair start. Many Americans also have only one or two choices of home broadband provider, which limits the power of customers to walk away from bad behaviour.

Opponents, including many broadband companies and some economists, argue that utility-style regulation discourages the huge investment needed to build faster networks, and that competition and disclosure rules are enough to deter abuse. Some engineers add that a degree of traffic management is normal and useful, for example giving time-sensitive calls priority over a large background download.

Both sides have a point worth taking seriously. Most proposals that survive scrutiny try to separate reasonable network management from commercial favouritism.

What happened after the repeal

The repeal did not produce the overnight collapse some campaigners feared, partly because providers were under intense public scrutiny and partly because states stepped in. California passed its own net neutrality law, SB 822, in September 2018, and after court battles it has been enforceable since early 2022. Several other states adopted their own rules or conditions on state contracts.

In October 2019 a federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., upheld most of the FCC's repeal in Mozilla v. FCC, but ruled that the agency could not block states from making their own rules. The court also asked the FCC to consider public safety, after reports that a California fire department's data had been throttled during a major 2018 wildfire response.

Net Neutrality What You Need To Know And How To Save It

In April 2024 the FCC, now under a different majority, voted 3–2 to restore Title II classification and the national rules. Two months later the Supreme Court's Loper Bright decision ended the long-standing practice of courts deferring to agencies' readings of ambiguous laws. In January 2025 the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals relied on that change to rule that broadband is an information service, meaning the FCC could not reinstate the rules. Any lasting national rule would now most likely need an act of Congress.

Common myths about net neutrality

"Without it, websites will be shut down overnight."

The 2017 repeal did not make major sites disappear. The risk is quieter: gradual favouritism, data caps that exempt partner services, and less room for new competitors.

"Net neutrality means all internet plans cost the same."

It does not. Providers can still sell faster or slower plans. Neutrality concerns how traffic is treated within the plan you buy.

"It is only an American issue."

Many countries have their own rules. The European Union has had an open internet regulation in force since 2016, and India and Chile have restricted zero-rating offers.

What you can do today

The petitions and deadlines of December 2017 are long gone, but the principle still matters every time you choose a provider. Read your provider's network management disclosure, which US providers must still publish. Run speed tests on different services if you suspect selective slowing. Check whether your state has its own net neutrality law. And if you want stronger national rules, contacting your members of Congress is now more relevant than filing an FCC comment.

The video below, made during the 2017 campaign, shows the range of people who spoke up at the time, from start-up founders to gamers and online creators.

Sources: Net neutrality in the United States (Wikipedia); Net neutrality (Wikipedia); Save The Internet (Free Press); Battle For The Net; News247; Boston Globe / AP, January 2025: appeals court strikes down FCC net neutrality rules. Images: AP Images.

COMMENTS