Italy’s Top Court: Stealing Food Out of Hunger Is Not a Crime

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Italy’s Top Court Rules Stealing A Little Food Out Of Hunger Is Not A Crime

In May 2016 Italy’s highest criminal court, the Court of Cassation, overturned the theft conviction of Roman Ostriakov, a homeless man who had walked out of a supermarket with cheese and sausages worth about €4. The judges found that he took a tiny amount of food because he urgently needed to eat, so his act was covered by necessity and was not a crime. The ruling did not legalise shoplifting in Italy. It applied an old legal principle to one very small, very human case.

What happened in the supermarket

The incident dates back to 2011. Ostriakov, a Ukrainian-born man living on the streets in Italy (reports place the shop in Genoa), went into a supermarket and paid for a packet of breadsticks. He also slipped two pieces of cheese and a packet of sausages, worth €4.07 in total, into his pocket.

Another shopper noticed and alerted staff. Ostriakov was stopped before he left, the food was taken back, and the police were called. Nothing was ever eaten, and the shop lost nothing.

Italy’s Top Court Rules Stealing A Little Food Out Of Hunger Is Not A Crime

That small moment turned into a legal case lasting about five years. In February 2015 a trial court convicted him of theft and gave him six months in jail plus a €100 fine. Many Italians found the punishment absurdly out of proportion: a man who was plainly hungry faced prison over food worth less than a cup of coffee and a sandwich.

What the Court of Cassation decided

The Court of Cassation does not retry the facts of a case. Its job is to check that lower courts applied the law correctly. Looking at Ostriakov’s situation, the judges concluded that the earlier courts had not. They annulled the conviction outright, so the jail term and the fine fell with it.

The heart of their reasoning was simple: a destitute man took a small quantity of food to meet an immediate and essential need to eat. Under those conditions, the court said, the act “does not constitute a crime.” The judges pointed to his condition and to the circumstances of the taking as proof that he acted in a state of need.

Coverage of the decision also linked it to the Latin maxim ad impossibilia nemo tenetur, which means that nobody can be required to do the impossible. Asking a starving man to simply go without food was, in the court’s view, asking the impossible.

Italy’s Top Court Rules Stealing A Little Food Out Of Hunger Is Not A Crime

The legal idea behind it: necessity

Italy’s criminal code has a general defence called stato di necessità, or state of necessity, in Article 54. In plain terms, a person is not punishable if they were forced to act to save themselves or someone else from a present danger of serious harm, provided they did not cause that danger themselves, could not avoid it any other way, and acted in proportion to the danger.

Many legal systems have something similar. The usual test is that the harm avoided must outweigh the harm done and that there was no reasonable lawful alternative. Hunger is a serious harm, and a few euros of cheese is about as small a loss to a shop as you can get, which is why the Ostriakov case fitted the defence so neatly.

The key words are “small” and “immediate.” The court was not talking about filling a trolley, stealing things to resell, or taking food because it is cheaper than buying it. It was talking about a person with no money, on the street, taking just enough to eat right then.

Common myths about the ruling

“Stealing food is now legal in Italy”

It is not. Theft remains a crime. Each case is judged on its own facts, and a court has to be convinced that the person was in real, urgent need and took only what that need required.

“The ruling binds every Italian court”

Not in the way a US Supreme Court ruling does. Speaking to the Christian Science Monitor at the time, criminal law professor Maurizio Bellacosa of Luiss University noted that Cassation decisions do not create binding precedent. He still called the ruling significant, because necessity is rarely accepted in shoplifting cases and the decision could encourage courts to consider it more often where poverty is involved.

“Being poor is enough”

Italian case law since then has repeated that poverty on its own does not satisfy the necessity test, partly because social assistance exists to meet basic needs. The defence depends on an immediate danger that cannot be avoided any other way, not on a general lack of money.

Italy’s Top Court Rules Stealing A Little Food Out Of Hunger Is Not A Crime

Why the case struck a nerve

The ruling landed at a time of deep economic strain in Italy. Caritas Europa estimated that in 2015 more than one in four Italians lived at or near the poverty line, with unemployment around 13 percent. Italy’s statistics office, ISTAT, had reported relative poverty of 12.7 percent in 2013, the highest since its records began in 1997. Corriere della Sera reported that around 615 people were joining the ranks of the poor every day.

The newspaper La Stampa welcomed the decision in a front-page editorial, arguing that in a civilised country nobody should be left to die of hunger. Others asked a sharper question: why did a case about €4 of food need to travel all the way to the country’s top court before common sense prevailed? Years of prosecutors’ and judges’ time were spent on a loss the shop never actually suffered.

The story also travelled abroad because it contrasted with policies elsewhere. Around the same period, dozens of US cities had restricted public food-sharing with homeless people, and in Fort Lauderdale a 90-year-old volunteer faced possible jail time for feeding people outdoors.

What we can take from it

  • Proportion matters. The law is meant to weigh harms, not to punish mechanically. A jail sentence for a few euros of food shows how badly that can go wrong when it is ignored.
  • Hunger is a safety issue, not just a social one. The judges treated a person’s need to eat as a real danger to them, which is exactly what it is.
  • Help is better than handcuffs. If you see someone in this position, a food bank, a charity kitchen or simply buying them a meal costs far less than a court case. Local food banks and church or community kitchens are usually the quickest route to help.
  • The defence is narrow. It protects people in genuine emergencies. It is not a loophole, and nobody should treat it as one.

Roman Ostriakov’s case is remembered not because it changed Italian law overnight, but because a court looked at a hungry man with a pocket full of cheese and decided that, in a civilised society, he should not be treated as a criminal.

Sources: Christian Science Monitor; ANSA; Law Society of Scotland; Italian Criminal Code, Art. 54 (Brocardi); Wikipedia: Necessity (criminal law).

COMMENTS