The 1924 Ship of Human Bones From Turkey to Marseille

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
A 1924 Report of 400 Tons of Human Bones Shipped From Turkey to France

In late December 1924, newspapers in New York and Marseille reported that a British-flagged cargo ship called the Zan was bringing about 400 tons of human bones from Turkey to manufacturers in Marseille. The bones had reportedly been loaded at Mudanya, on the Sea of Marmara, and were said to be the remains of people massacred in Asia Minor: Armenians, Greeks and other Christian victims of the late Ottoman and early Republican years.

The newspaper reports are real and can still be read today. What happened to the cargo, who gathered and sold the bones, and what they were finally used for is far less clear. This article sets out what the documents show, what later accounts add, and where the evidence runs out.

What the newspapers reported in December 1924

On 23 December 1924, The New York Times printed a short special cable from Paris, dated the day before, under the headline “Yarn of a Cargo of Human Bones”. It said Marseille was excited by the story of a ship flying the British flag, named the Zan, carrying a mysterious cargo of 400 tons of human bones consigned to manufacturers there. The bones were said to have been loaded at Mudanya and to be the remains of massacre victims in Asia Minor, and an inquiry was expected.

A day later the Marseille daily Le Midi ran a brief item headed “Cargaison funèbre” (“Funeral cargo”). It reported that the city was talking about the coming arrival of the cargo ship Zan, carrying 400 tonnes of human bones for Marseille industrialists, and that the bones came mainly from the Armenian massacre fields in Turkey and Asia Minor. Neither paper put the story on its front page.

A 1924 Report of 400 Tons of Human Bones Shipped From Turkey to France

The New York Times cable of 23 December 1924 (left) and the Le Midi item of 24 December 1924 (right), circled in red.

Many online retellings quote the American headline as “An unbelievable story of a shipment with human bones”. The original wording is shorter: “yarn” was period slang for a tall tale, which shows that even the reporter treated the claim with caution while still thinking it worth printing.

The background: genocide and the Asia Minor Catastrophe

The cargo, if the reports were accurate, came out of one of the darkest decades in the region's history. Between 1914 and 1923 the Ottoman authorities and, later, the Turkish nationalist forces carried out the genocides of the Armenians, the Greeks and the Assyrians. Greek men of military age were conscripted into labour battalions, the amele taburları, and marched hundreds of kilometres inland to build roads and tunnels; hundreds of thousands of people died from hunger, abuse and massacre.

The war in Anatolia ended in 1922 with the burning of Smyrna and the flight of the Greek population, known in Greece as the Asia Minor Catastrophe. Around 900,000 refugees reached Greece in the autumn of 1922 alone, and the Convention of Lausanne, signed on 30 January 1923, turned the expulsion into a compulsory population exchange. Overall, about 1.2 million Orthodox Christians left Turkey, while some 355,000 to 400,000 Muslims left Greece. Some Greek sources use a figure of 1.5 million refugees; the more cautious estimates are lower.

In 2007 the International Association of Genocide Scholars passed a resolution recognising the campaigns against Ottoman Greeks and Assyrians as genocide alongside the Armenian Genocide. Greece, Cyprus, Armenia, Sweden, the Netherlands, Germany, Austria and the United States are among the countries whose legislatures have recognised the Greek genocide.

One correction to older retellings: the killings are sometimes attributed to “Kemal's Young Turks”. The Young Turks' Committee of Union and Progress, which ruled during the First World War, and Mustafa Kemal's nationalist movement after 1919 were different political organisations, although many officials served under both and persecution continued under each.

The Thessaloniki stop: what Greek accounts add

Greek historians have added a second part to the story. According to a summary of the work of historian Vlasis Agtzidis, cited by the journalist Bertrand Hauger, the ship left Mudanya on 13 December 1924 bound for Marseille by way of Thessaloniki, carrying no cargo documents.

Greek retellings go further. They say that when port workers in Thessaloniki learned what was in the hold, they refused to let the ship leave; that refugees from Asia Minor, many of whom had lost relatives, demonstrated and demanded that the cargo be seized; and that the British consulate intervened, after which the Greek government let the ship sail to avoid a diplomatic dispute. The Thessaloniki newspaper Makedonia is said to have recorded the ship's arrival without mentioning the bones. We were not able to check these details against the original Greek newspapers, so they should be read as reported rather than confirmed.

What would anyone do with 400 tons of bones?

The reports name the buyers only as Marseille manufacturers. Bones were an industrial raw material at the time. A medical professor consulted by Hauger listed glue, gelatin and animal feed as uses for dried bone; the European Union later banned bone-based animal feed after the mad cow crisis. One summary of the Greek research names French and British soap firms as buyers, but soap was normally made from fresh slaughterhouse material, so that detail is doubtful.

Some articles say the cargo represented the remains of 50,000 people. That figure is an estimate that depends on the weight assumed for each skeleton, and no source we found explains how it was calculated. Nor has any document come to light showing what the promised French inquiry found. The honest summary is that the shipment was reported at the time, its origin was described as massacre sites, and its fate is unknown.

Other testimony about a trade in bones

The Zan reports are not the only hint of such a trade. Manuel Kirkyasaryan, an Armenian from Adana who later emigrated to Australia, recorded his memories before he died in Sydney in 1997. He described seeing sacks of bones being loaded onto a large vehicle in Aleppo in 1925, and said he saw it happen twice.

Hauger, writing for Worldcrunch, argues that the killings themselves belonged to the Committee of Union and Progress era, and that the profit in 1924 went to the European buyers who created a market for the remains. Whoever handled the bones, the picture is grim: the dead of a genocide treated as a commodity, shipped across the Mediterranean with no papers and almost no public outcry.

A witness in literature: Elias Venezis and Number 31328

For Greek readers, the human side of this history is best known through Number 31328 (To Noumero 31328), the memoir of the writer Elias Venezis from Ayvalık. At eighteen he was taken prisoner after the Turkish army recaptured the region and forced into a labour battalion that marched into the Anatolian interior. Of the 3,000 men conscripted into his brigade, only 23 survived; the title refers to his prisoner number.

The book first appeared in instalments in the weekly Kambana in 1924, encouraged by the novelist Stratis Myrivilis, and became widely known after an expanded edition in 1931. Nikos Koundouros based his 1978 film 1922 on it. Its dedication, as usually translated, reads: “There's nothing deeper and holier than a body in pain. This book is dedicated to this pain.”

You can read more in a study of trauma and captivity in the book and on Wikipedia. The book is available in a Turkish edition and in the original Greek.

Why this story still matters

Stories like the Zan cargo circulate widely on social media, often with exaggerated or invented details, and that makes it easy for deniers to dismiss them. The better response is precision. The newspaper reports exist, the massacres they refer to are historical fact, and the gaps in the record are real gaps, not proof that nothing happened.

Remembering the victims means telling their story accurately: citing the documents, marking what is uncertain, and continuing to ask the archives in Marseille, London and Athens what became of the ship and its cargo. For the descendants of the refugees who reached Greece in 1922 and 1923, these are not abstract questions but family history.

Sources: Bertrand Hauger, Worldcrunch: After the genocide, a market for Armenian bones; The New York Times, 23 December 1924, and Le Midi, 24 December 1924 (clippings above); Wikipedia: Greek genocide; Wikipedia: Population exchange between Greece and Turkey; Wikipedia: Number 31328.

Related:

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 4
  1. Turks sold Genocided bones, during ataturk era after the genocide.
    Is there more criminal work than this???
    Who can punish such criminals....No-one is born like them on this earth???
    and still they say ...there was no genocide!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Turks sold Genocided bones, during ataturk era after the genocide.
    Is there more criminal work than this???
    Who can punish such criminals....No-one is born like them on this earth???
    and still they say ...there was no genocide!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Turks were sellers and what about the buyer ... how big was his humanity?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Turks were sellers and what about the buyer ... how big was his humanity?

    ReplyDelete