Six open questions can tell you a surprising amount about a person: how they describe themselves, what they count as their biggest achievement, what they read, what their dream job would be, who their hero is, and what they regret. None of them is a test with right answers. Their value lies in the fact that they are open-ended, so people have to choose what to talk about, and those choices reveal priorities, values and self-image.
Every close friend, partner or colleague you have was a stranger once. You cannot know on day one which strangers will matter, but you can ask better questions than “So, what do you do?” Below is what each question tends to show, how to ask it well, and where its limits lie.
Why open questions reveal so much
A closed question (“Do you like your job?”) invites a yes or no. An open question (“What’s the best part of your week?”) hands the other person the steering wheel. Where they drive tells you what is on their mind.
Psychologists have long been interested in how much we can learn from small samples of behaviour. Research on “thin-slicing”, pioneered by Nalini Ambady and Robert Rosenthal in the 1990s, found that people can form surprisingly accurate impressions from very short observations, especially of social traits such as warmth, dominance or shyness. Traits like conscientiousness or intelligence are harder to judge quickly. Good questions give you richer material than a glance does, and they turn a first impression into an actual conversation.
There is a second benefit. Asking thoughtful questions and really listening to the answers tends to make people warm to you. Most of us enjoy talking about what matters to them, and they remember who gave them the chance.
Questions about how they see themselves
1. “How would you describe yourself?”
This sounds bland, but its vagueness is exactly what makes it useful. Some people answer with their job title, some with their family role (“I’m a dad of three”), some with a passion (“I’m a climber, really”), and some with a personality trait. Whatever they lead with is usually what they consider central to who they are.
Notice the tone as well as the content. Is the description modest, confident, self-mocking, guarded? Do they ask you the same question back? That small act of reciprocity says something too.
2. “What is your biggest achievement?”
The answer shows what a person values enough to be proud of. One person names a promotion, another a marathon, another the fact that they got sober or raised a child alone. Because the question is open, they reveal which part of life they measure themselves by.
Follow up with “How long did that take?” A goal pursued over years suggests persistence; a quick win can point to someone who thrives on challenges and moves on. Neither is better. They simply describe different temperaments.
Questions about what they love
3. “Have you read any good books lately?”
Answers vary wildly, which is what makes this a good question. Committed readers light up and often name several titles at once. Some people say honestly that they rarely read, which shows a certain ease with themselves. Others pause for a long time, searching for an impressive title, which may hint that they care about how they come across.
The genre matters too. Business and self-help readers often like practical improvement; fans of novels tend to enjoy other people’s inner lives; science-fiction and fantasy readers are often drawn to big ideas and “what if” thinking. Treat these as conversation openers, not labels. If books are not their thing, ask about podcasts, films or music instead.
4. “What would your dream job be?”
Here people show what they would do if money and practicality did not count. Creative types often name something artistic. Others joke about invented jobs, such as professional nap tester or chocolate taster, which tells you they value humour and lightness. Some give an answer that is surprisingly close to their current job, which can mean real contentment.
Pay attention to how quickly they answer. A ready, detailed reply suggests they have thought about this a lot, perhaps because they feel something is missing. A blank look may mean they rarely let themselves imagine alternatives.
Questions about their values
5. “Who is your personal hero?”
This is one of the most revealing questions you can ask, because people tend to admire in others what they hope to be themselves. A person who names a grandmother who raised six children on very little probably values resilience and family. Someone who picks an athlete may prize discipline; someone who chooses a scientist or activist may care about curiosity or justice.
The useful follow-up is “Why them?” The reasons they give, such as honesty, courage, kindness or ambition, are often a fairly direct list of their own ideals.
6. “What do you regret?”
Everyone has regrets, but people handle them very differently. Some deflect with a light answer (“Not travelling more”). Some are surprisingly frank about mistakes and what they learned. Some insist they regret nothing at all. Each response hints at how comfortable the person is with vulnerability and self-reflection.
This question is best saved for when there is some trust between you. Asked on a first meeting, it can feel intrusive and produce only a polite non-answer.
How to ask without it feeling like an interview
A list of questions fired one after another can feel like a job interview or an interrogation. A few habits keep things natural:
- Spread them out. One or two good questions in an evening is plenty. Save the rest for later meetings.
- Share in return. Answer the question yourself. Mutual self-disclosure is what builds closeness. Arthur Aron and colleagues’ well-known 1997 study, which later became famous as “the 36 questions”, was built on exactly this idea of gradual, reciprocal sharing.
- Follow up. “Why?” and “What was that like?” are often more revealing than the first answer.
- Listen more than you talk. If you are planning your next question while they speak, you will miss the answer.
- Respect a pass. If someone does not want to answer, let it go gracefully.
What these questions can’t tell you
Words are only part of a person. Anyone can rehearse an impressive answer, and nervous people often undersell themselves on a first meeting. First impressions are also shaped by our own mood and stereotypes; research on thin-slicing found, for example, that people in a sad mood judged others less accurately.
So treat what you hear as a first sketch, not a finished portrait. The most reliable guide to character is still how someone behaves over time: how they treat waiters and strangers, whether they keep promises, and how they act when things go wrong. Good questions give you a head start. Time and shared experience fill in the rest.
Sources: Wikipedia: Thin-slicing (Ambady and Rosenthal’s research); Aron, A. et al. (1997), “The Experimental Generation of Interpersonal Closeness”, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin.
COMMENTS