Is Coconut Oil Healthy? What the American Heart Association Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2017-08-10.

Coconut Oil and Cardiovascular Nutrition Claims

Is coconut oil healthy? Not for your heart, according to the American Heart Association (AHA). In a June 2017 presidential advisory on dietary fats, published in the journal Circulation, the AHA advised against using coconut oil because it raises LDL ("bad") cholesterol and has no known offsetting benefit. Coconut oil is about 82% saturated fat, more than butter, beef fat or lard.

That does not make a spoonful in a curry dangerous. But it does mean coconut oil is not the miracle health food it was marketed as. Here is what the evidence says, where the hype came from, and which fats are the better everyday choice.

What the American Heart Association concluded

The advisory reviewed decades of research on fats and cardiovascular disease. Its central finding was that cutting saturated fat and replacing it with unsaturated vegetable oils, especially polyunsaturated ones, lowers the risk of heart disease. In randomised trials, that swap reduced cardiovascular events by around 30%, a benefit similar to that of cholesterol-lowering statin drugs.

On coconut oil specifically, the AHA pointed to trials showing that it raised LDL cholesterol, much as butter, beef fat and palm oil do. Because raised LDL is a known cause of cardiovascular disease, and no clear balancing benefit has been shown, it recommended against using coconut oil.

The advisory also noted a striking gap between public opinion and expert opinion. It cited a survey in which 72% of Americans rated coconut oil as healthy, compared with 37% of nutritionists, and suggested the difference was "attributed to the marketing of coconut oil in the popular press."

How coconut oil compares with other fats

According to the AHA advisory, the share of saturated fat in common cooking fats is roughly:

  • Coconut oil: 82%
  • Butter: 63%
  • Beef fat: 50%
  • Peanut oil: 17%
  • Olive oil: 14%
  • Sunflower oil: 10%

Harvard's Nutrition Source adds that the main saturated fat in coconut oil is lauric acid, with smaller amounts of myristic and palmitic acids, which raise LDL. One tablespoon contains about 12 grams of saturated fat, close to the AHA's suggested daily limit of about 13 grams for people who need to lower their cholesterol (source).

In the UK, NHS guidance is that men should eat no more than 30 g of saturated fat a day and women no more than 20 g. The NHS lists coconut oil and coconut cream alongside butter, lard, fatty meat, cheese, cream, cakes and biscuits as foods high in saturated fat (source).

Coconut Oil and Cardiovascular Nutrition Claims
Photo: Africa Studio/Shutterstock

Common myths about coconut oil

"It is full of MCTs, so it burns as energy"

Many of the claims about coconut oil came from research on medium-chain triglyceride (MCT) oil, a specially made product. Supermarket coconut oil is different: its main fat, lauric acid, behaves more like a long-chain fat in the body and is absorbed more slowly. Results from MCT studies cannot simply be applied to a jar of coconut oil.

"It helps you lose weight"

A 2020 review of 16 clinical trials, published in Circulation by Neelakantan and colleagues, found coconut oil had no significant effect on body weight, waist size or body fat compared with other vegetable oils. Our article on coconut oil and waist size looks at the small studies behind that claim.

"It raises good cholesterol, so it cancels out"

Coconut oil does raise HDL ("good") cholesterol a little. But the same trials show it raises LDL more, and modern research suggests that simply pushing HDL up does not protect the heart in the way once hoped. The AHA did not count the HDL rise as an offsetting benefit.

"People in coconut-growing regions have healthy hearts"

Some populations in India, the Philippines and Polynesia have low rates of heart disease, but they mostly eat whole coconut flesh or pressed coconut cream as part of diets high in fibre and low in processed food. Those communities do not prove that adding refined coconut oil to a Western diet is good for you.

What about coconut water?

Coconut water is a different product. It is about 95% water, with small amounts of sugar, potassium and sodium (source). It is a pleasant, fairly low-calorie drink, but there is no good evidence that it hydrates better than plain water for ordinary use. One major brand settled a US class action in 2012 over claims about its electrolyte content. If you enjoy it, drink it; just do not pay extra expecting special health effects.

The debate and the wider picture

Not everyone welcomed the AHA's message. Some nutrition researchers argue that saturated fat is less harmful than once believed, or that the whole food and overall diet matter more than any single nutrient. That is a fair point, and the AHA agrees on the importance of overall diet: its advisory recommends eating patterns such as the Mediterranean or DASH diet rather than focusing on one ingredient.

The advisory also made an important warning: when people cut saturated fat but replace it with refined carbohydrates and sugar, their heart risk does not improve. What you eat instead matters as much as what you cut.

The main conclusion has held up. Since 2017, further trial reviews have confirmed that coconut oil raises LDL compared with non-tropical vegetable oils, and major bodies, including the NHS and the AHA, still class it as a saturated fat to limit.

Practical takeaways for your kitchen

  • Use it as a flavour, not a staple. Harvard's nutrition experts suggest coconut oil is best used in small amounts as an occasional alternative to other oils, for example in a Thai curry or some baking.
  • Make olive, rapeseed (canola) or sunflower oil your everyday choice. These are mostly unsaturated fats.
  • Do not cut out fat altogether. Your body needs fat to absorb vitamins A, D, E and K. Good sources of unsaturated fats include avocados, nuts, seeds and oily fish such as salmon and mackerel.
  • Read labels. Coconut oil, palm oil and coconut cream turn up in many processed snacks and dairy-free products.
  • If you have high cholesterol or heart disease, talk to a doctor about the right diet for you.

For more context on earlier claims, see our piece on coconut oil and heart health. Coconut oil still has plenty of non-food uses, from moisturising skin to conditioning wooden boards.

Sources: Sacks et al., Dietary Fats and Cardiovascular Disease: A Presidential Advisory From the American Heart Association, Circulation, 2017; Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, The Nutrition Source: Coconut oil; NHS: Fat, the facts; Wikipedia: Coconut water; BBC News, June 2017.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 3
  1. Read up on newer research on saturated fats. Your lack of research is showing.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Don't consider AHA Journel.Write if you have done your own research and tests on coconut, and tender coconut.

    ReplyDelete
  3. American Heart Asociation?? Same as CDC?, Skin cancer Foundation?? And all the official LIES?? No thanks...

    ReplyDelete