
America Now
On 15 February 2017 Pope Francis told indigenous leaders gathered in Rome that when economic projects touch their lands, their right to give or withhold consent should come first. Speaking at a forum hosted by the UN's International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD), he said that the right to prior and informed consent should always prevail
, citing the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. Because the speech came weeks after the new Trump administration revived the Dakota Access Pipeline, many outlets read it as a message about Standing Rock, although the Pope never named the United States or the pipeline.
What Pope Francis said in Rome
The occasion was the third global meeting of IFAD's Indigenous Peoples' Forum, held during the fund's 40th anniversary year. Francis met the participants in a hall next to the Vatican's Paul VI Audience Hall.
His central point was a balance. Indigenous peoples, he said, have a right to development, but that development must respect their distinct cultures and territories, especially when economic activity could disrupt their ancestral relationship with the land. That is where consent comes in. In his view, only by respecting prior and informed consent can governments and indigenous communities cooperate peacefully instead of sliding into confrontation.
He also addressed governments directly. Indigenous communities, he said, should be valued and consulted as part of the national population, and their full participation should be encouraged in local and national decision-making. He asked that young people and women be included rather than merely considered, and said that marginalisation cannot be allowed.
Finally, he praised indigenous traditions of care for "mother earth" and urged the leaders not to accept technologies that damage the environment or their inherited knowledge, however advanced they may be. He tied this to his 2015 encyclical Laudato Si', which argues that economic growth that leaves the world worse off cannot count as progress.
What "prior and informed consent" means
The phrase comes from international human rights law. The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, adopted by the General Assembly in 2007, says in Article 32 that states should consult indigenous peoples in good faith, through their own institutions, to obtain their free and informed consent before approving projects that affect their lands, territories or resources, particularly mining, water or other resource development.
In practice, the principle is often summarised as FPIC, free, prior and informed consent:
- Free: no coercion, intimidation or manipulation.
- Prior: sought well before a project is authorised or work starts.
- Informed: communities receive full information on scope, risks and benefits, in a form they can understand.
- Consent: a real choice, which includes the possibility of saying no.
The declaration is not a binding treaty, and governments disagree on whether consent amounts to a veto or a duty to consult seriously. The United States, Canada, Australia and New Zealand voted against it in 2007 and later endorsed it with reservations. That is why a pope stating that consent should "always prevail" drew attention.
Why many linked the speech to Standing Rock
The timing explains the headlines. Through 2016, thousands of people led by the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe protested the Dakota Access Pipeline, a roughly 1,170-mile line carrying crude oil from North Dakota through South Dakota and Iowa to Illinois. The tribe objected to its route under Lake Oahe, a Missouri River reservoir just upstream of the reservation and its main water source, and to damage to sacred and burial sites. It also argued it had not been properly consulted.
On 4 December 2016 the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, under the Obama administration, declined the easement for the Lake Oahe crossing and called for a study of alternatives. Days after taking office, on 24 January 2017, President Trump signed a presidential memorandum directing agencies to expedite the project, and in early February the Corps granted the easement.
So when the Pope said consent should prevail less than two weeks later, campaigners and several news sites, among them EcoWatch and True Activist, framed it as a rebuke of Washington. The speech text itself mentions neither, and contemporary reporting said the Vatican did not present it as a comment on the pipeline. It is best read as a statement of principle that applies to projects anywhere, from the Amazon to North America.
Part of a longer pattern
The 2017 speech fits a theme Francis returned to often. Laudato Si' criticised the exploitation of land and resources at the expense of poor and indigenous communities, and closes with a prayer asking God to bring healing to our lives, that we may protect the world and not prey on it
. In 2015 in Bolivia he apologised for crimes committed against native peoples during the colonial conquest of the Americas; in 2019 he convened a Synod of Bishops on the Amazon; and in 2022 he travelled to Canada to apologise for the role of Catholic institutions in the residential schools system.
In 2023 the Vatican also formally repudiated the "Doctrine of Discovery", the colonial-era idea that Christian powers could claim lands already inhabited by non-Christian peoples, saying it was not part of Catholic teaching. Indigenous leaders had long asked for that step.
What happened to the pipeline
The Dakota Access Pipeline was completed in 2017; first oil was delivered in May and commercial operations began on 1 June. In 2020 a federal judge sided with the Standing Rock Sioux, threw out the Lake Oahe easement and ordered a full environmental impact statement. He also ordered the pipeline shut, but an appeals court overturned the shutdown in August 2020, and oil kept flowing during the review. In 2022 the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the operator's appeal.
On 21 May 2026 the Army Corps issued its final decision granting the Lake Oahe crossing permit, adding conditions such as new leak detection, groundwater and surface-water monitoring, and emergency water and food plans for communities that depend on the lake. The Standing Rock Sioux Tribe said the conditions did not address its concerns and that it was weighing its legal and political options.
Nearly a decade on, the case remains one of the clearest examples of the tension Francis described in 2017: a major economic project, a community that says it never consented, and a long argument over who should have the final word.
Sources: Vatican.va: Address of Pope Francis to the Indigenous Peoples' Forum at IFAD, 15 February 2017; Wikipedia: Dakota Access Pipeline; News From The States, May 2026: Army Corps grants final approval to Dakota Access Pipeline; Reuters, 15 February 2017 (original report); EcoWatch, February 2017; True Activist (original article). Header image: America Now.
Related:- Pope Francis: Capitalism Is 'Terrorism Against All Of Humanity'
- Pope Calls on World Youth to Rise Up Against Global Capitalism
- Corruption ‘more addictive than drugs,’ Pope Francis says
- Pope Declares Evolution & Big Bang Theory Are Real & That ‘God Isn’t A Magician’
- Thousands Of Buffalo Appear At Site Of Standing Rock Protest [Watch]
- Standing Rock and the 2016 Dakota Access Pipeline Protests
- The Worst Mass Shooting in U.S. History Was Not in Orlando
- Johnny Depp Intends To Buy Site Of Wounded Knee Massacre And Gift It Back To The Native American People
- Leonardo DiCaprio’s Golden Globe Acceptance Speech For The First Nations & Indigenous People Of The World
- 30 Native American Wisdom Quotes To Upgrade Your Mind
- 10 Pieces Of Wisdom & Quotes From Native American Elders
- Luther Standing Bear Quotes: Reading a Lakota Writer Carefully
- 31 Plants Discussed in Accounts of Native American Traditional Medicine

COMMENTS