The two "giant structures" deep below Earth's surface are regions of the lowermost mantle known to geologists as large low-shear-velocity provinces, or LLSVPs. One sits beneath Africa and the other beneath the Pacific Ocean, both resting on top of the planet's core, roughly 2,900 kilometres down. Each is thousands of kilometres across and may rise as much as 1,000 kilometres, more than a hundred times the height of Mount Everest. Together they take up about 8% of the mantle's volume. Scientists still debate what they are made of and where they came from, but they are not hollow, not new and not mysterious in the sense of being unexplained by physics. They are among the biggest features of our planet, and they may help explain volcanoes, hotspots and even the origin of the Moon.
What the 2016 research actually said
Headlines in 2016 presented the structures as a fresh discovery, but they had been mapped since the 1980s. What appeared that year was a major review in Nature Geoscience by Arizona State University researchers Edward Garnero, Allen McNamara and Sang-Heon Shim. It pulled together decades of seismic, mineral and computer-modelling studies to describe the two provinces, their sharp edges and the smaller, even stranger patches that cling to their borders.
The review's message was that the provinces are probably different in composition from the surrounding mantle, not just hotter. Garnero said the team suspected they "hold important clues as to how the Earth was formed and how it works today." That is a big claim for a feature no one can visit, so it helps to understand how we know they are there at all.
Where they are and how big they are
Earth's interior is layered like an onion: a thin crust, a rocky mantle nearly 2,900 kilometres thick, a liquid outer core and a solid inner core. The LLSVPs sit at the very bottom of the mantle, in a zone geologists call D″ ("D double prime"), just above the boundary with the molten iron core.
- The African province, nicknamed Tuzo after Canadian geologist J. Tuzo Wilson, lies beneath Africa and the southern Atlantic.
- The Pacific province, nicknamed Jason after American geophysicist W. Jason Morgan, spans about 3,000 kilometres beneath the central Pacific.
- Size: each extends thousands of kilometres sideways and possibly up to around 1,000 kilometres high. Together they make up about 8% of the mantle and roughly 6% of the whole planet.
Popular reports in 2016 often said one structure lies under the Atlantic. It is more accurate to say it lies under Africa, with parts reaching beneath the South Atlantic.
How scientists can see 2,900 kilometres down
No drill has gone more than about 12 kilometres into the crust, so everything we know about the deep mantle comes from indirect evidence, mostly earthquakes. Each large earthquake sends seismic waves through the whole planet, and thousands of seismometers record when they arrive. Waves travel at different speeds through materials that are hotter, colder or chemically different.
By combining millions of these travel times, a technique called seismic tomography builds three-dimensional maps of the interior, much like a medical CT scan. In those maps, the two provinces stand out because shear waves (the side-to-side kind) slow down noticeably inside them. That is where the name comes from: "low shear velocity". Their edges are surprisingly sharp, and they appear to be denser than their surroundings, which is why many researchers think they are made of different material rather than simply being warmer rock.
Clinging to the edges are much smaller ultra-low-velocity zones, patches only tens of kilometres thick where seismic waves slow dramatically. Some may contain partially molten rock or iron-rich material.
Theories about their origin
Leftovers from Earth's infancy
One idea is that the provinces are primordial: dense material that settled at the base of the mantle as the young Earth cooled from a molten state around 4.5 billion years ago, and that has never fully mixed since.
A graveyard of old ocean floor
Another leading hypothesis holds that the provinces are built from subducted oceanic crust. When tectonic plates dive back into the mantle at ocean trenches, the slabs can sink all the way to the core boundary. Over hundreds of millions of years, those slabs may have been swept into piles beneath Africa and the Pacific.
Pieces of another planet
A 2023 study in Nature by Qian Yuan and colleagues proposed a more dramatic origin. Most scientists think the Moon formed when a Mars-sized body, called Theia, collided with the early Earth. The study's simulations suggested that chunks of Theia's iron-rich mantle could have sunk deep into Earth and survived as the two provinces. The idea is still debated, but it would make the structures a buried record of the Moon's birth.
These explanations are not mutually exclusive. The provinces could contain a mixture of ancient material and recycled crust.
Why they matter at the surface
Deep structures shape what happens far above. Mantle plumes, columns of hot rock that rise from deep within the planet, are thought to feed volcanic hotspots, and several of the Pacific's hotspots sit above the edges of the Pacific province. Some researchers have also linked the borders of both provinces to the locations of ancient eruptions that flooded vast areas with lava, though that connection is still argued over.
Because the provinces are stable over long periods, they may act as anchors for mantle circulation, influencing how heat escapes from the core. That in turn affects the churning of the liquid outer core that generates Earth's magnetic field. Understanding them is part of understanding why Earth has been geologically active, and habitable, for so long.
Common myths about Earth's hidden interior
"They are cavities or entrances into the Earth." No. The provinces are solid rock under enormous pressure, simply with different properties from the rock around them. The deep Earth has no open caverns of this size.
"There is a giant ocean underground." A 2014 study suggested that the mantle transition zone, between about 410 and 660 kilometres deep, may hold one to three times as much water as all the oceans. But that water is locked chemically inside minerals such as ringwoodite, not sloshing about as liquid.
"Scientists have no idea what they are." There is real uncertainty about their origin and exact composition, but their location, shape and seismic properties are well mapped, and several testable theories compete to explain them. As seismic networks grow and computer models improve, the answer is likely to come from patient accumulation of data rather than a single breakthrough.
Sources: First reported by The Mind Unleashed; Garnero, McNamara and Shim, Nature Geoscience (2016); ASU School of Earth and Space Exploration; Large low-shear-velocity provinces (Wikipedia); Ringwoodite (Wikipedia).
Related:- Water Deep Inside Earth: The “Underground Ocean” Explained
- Newly-Found ‘Second Earth’ Is Just Four Light Years Away and Could Have Liquid Water and Alien Life
- Scientists Discover Another Earth!
- Kepler’s Three Super-Earths: What the Discovery Really Means
- Earth’s “Second Moon”: What 2016 HO3 Really Is
- NASA just detected oxygen in the Martian atmosphere
- NASA Confirms Evidence That Liquid Water Flows on Today’s Mars
- Enceladus’ Hidden Ocean: What Cassini Found Beneath the Ice
- Earth’s Magnetic “Portals”: Reconnection Explained
- Hubble’s Andromeda Mosaic: From 2015 to 2.5 Billion Pixels
- BioCarbon Engineering’s 2015 Proposal for Drone-Assisted Tree Planting
- The US and Russia are making plans to return to the Moon together
- Russia Doesn’t Believe U.S. Landed On The Moon, Wants International Investigation
- Scientists Mapped 8000 Galaxies (Out Of Billions) & Made An Amazing Discovery
- 18 Photos That Will Make You Reconsider Your Existence!
- Universe Facts: Questions Behind the Astonishing Numbers
- The Size Of Space As Depicted Here Is Truly Mind-Blowing
- A Third Toroidal Ring Around The Earth Discovered!
- Physics breakthrough: Is the universe a giant hologram?
- Stephen Hawking's Universe - The Story of Everything, Time Travel, Aliens
- Are Flat-Earthers Being Serious?

COMMENTS