Originally published 2016-08-18.

Is it harder to commit to love today than it was for our grandparents? In a widely shared 2016 essay for Thought Catalog, writer Nicole Kylie argued that her generation often hides behind reasonable-sounding excuses, such as career, independence and the ease of breaking up, to avoid giving itself fully to another person. Her piece is a personal opinion rather than a study, but it touches on questions many people in their twenties and thirties ask themselves.
Here we walk through her argument, the four excuses she names, what the data on marriage and divorce actually show, and what is worth keeping from her reflection without idealising the past.
A kitchen scene that started it
Kylie begins with a small moment at her grandparents' home. Her grandmother is cooking at the stove; her grandfather tells her how lovely she looks in the kitchen light and asks her to come and sit with him. Grandma pretends not to hear, then shoots him a look, though her granddaughter suspects she is quietly delighted.
What struck the writer was that, after more than fifty years of marriage, her grandfather was still courting his wife. She contrasts that with what she sees among her peers: fear of commitment, relationships that last a few months, and undefined arrangements where two people "have a thing" but avoid naming it. Her conclusion is that people want to be loved completely while holding back themselves, and that they use excuses to stay safe from hurt.
The four excuses she names
"I need to focus on my career"
Kylie argues that success has been redefined around possessions and status: the car, the designer bag, the restaurant check-ins on social media. She sets this against her grandfather at thirty, who had a modest job, a simple house with fruit trees, a family car, a happy wife and four children, and who helped with homework every evening. In her eyes he was successful because his family was happy. Ambition is good, she says, but when it becomes the reason never to take a relationship seriously, it has turned into an excuse.
"We can't fix this, let's break up"
Her second point is about patience. Search engines, touchscreens and delivery apps mean we rarely have to wait or struggle for anything. Kylie suggests that this convenience makes people quicker to give up when a relationship hits trouble, moving on to someone new instead of working through the problem.
"A family is too much of a burden"
She contends that dating without any intention of a future means always keeping one eye open for someone better, and that this selfishness ruins love. She asks readers to see sharing a life, from the joy of a newborn to the stress of buying a home, as an honour rather than a weight.
"I need my freedom and space"
Kylie agrees that personal space matters in a healthy relationship. Her objection is to space used as cover for flirting or keeping options open. She quotes a Chinese proverb her mother uses, "riding a cow while looking for a horse", which describes making do with what you have while hunting for something better. Better, she suggests, not to settle in the first place.
What the numbers actually say
Essays like this often assume that divorce keeps rising and that commitment is collapsing. The data paint a more mixed picture. In the United States, divorce rates climbed through much of the twentieth century and rose sharply in the 1970s after no-fault divorce laws spread. Since then they have fallen. The most recent figures from the CDC's National Center for Health Statistics show 2.4 divorces per 1,000 people in 2023, compared with roughly double that around 1980.
Part of the change is that people now marry later and some choose not to marry at all, so the couples who do marry are often older and more settled. Younger generations are not necessarily worse at commitment; many are delaying it until they feel ready, or expressing it in forms other than marriage.
It is also worth remembering that earlier generations stayed together for many reasons, not all of them happy. Limited legal rights, financial dependence and social stigma kept some people in marriages they would have left if they could. Easier divorce has allowed many to escape unhappy or unsafe relationships.
Where her argument rings true
Even with those caveats, Kylie names something real. Dating apps make the pool of possible partners feel endless, and that can encourage constant comparison. Ambiguous "situationships" can leave both people anxious. And a culture that celebrates visible achievement can make quiet, ordinary contentment look like failure.
Her central point is about intention. When we stop treating a partner as a placeholder and start treating them as a choice we keep making, the relationship changes. That idea does not depend on any particular era.
Taking the lesson without the nostalgia
The kitchen scene works because it shows attention and playfulness after half a century together. Those are habits anyone can practise, whatever their age or relationship style:
- Notice and say it. A compliment, a thank-you or a small invitation to sit together costs nothing and keeps affection visible.
- Be honest about what you want. If you are not looking for commitment, say so. If you are, do not pretend otherwise to seem relaxed.
- Treat rough patches as part of the deal. Before ending something, ask whether the problem is a dealbreaker or simply hard.
- Define freedom together. Space within a relationship works best when both partners agree on its boundaries.
- Measure success your own way. Career goals and a loving relationship are not rivals; the question is which one you let crowd out the other.
A reflection, not a rulebook
Nicole Kylie's essay is a heartfelt argument from one young woman watching her grandparents and comparing them with her friends. It overstates some trends and romanticises a past that was harder for many couples than it looks from a grandchild's seat at the kitchen table. Still, its closing challenge is a good one: look honestly at your own reasons before you begin something that deserves to be more than casual, and do not make the next person pay for your excuses.
Sources: Nicole Kylie, "Our Generation Has Ruined Love With These Excuses", Thought Catalog, June 2016; CDC FastStats: Marriage and Divorce; Wikipedia: Divorce in the United States.

This is wrong
ReplyDeleteI agree. This is so wrong
ReplyDelete"Everything is given to us?" You mean slave wages? No job security?
ReplyDeleteI think what the author is trying to say is that instant gratification is ruining our lives. I say so be it. Life is for experiences, and each to their own. Your ideal of a successful life might not be someone else's ideal. What you are content with might not be enough for others. So until people are sick of their short relationships, let them enjoy the excitement and thrill of being with someone wonderful just because. Life is too short to stick by the rules.
ReplyDeleteTotally agree with author. Well written.
ReplyDeleteI don't entirely agree with the author. Who is educating these generations? Who have educated the generations before them? If our grandparents were such a perfect role model how did we end up like this? Who are the young ones looking up to? Anyone can be a nostalgic for the "good old days". I'm not saying it's good what's happening today but we need to understand how we got here instead of crying over spilt milk...
ReplyDelete