6 Early Signs of a Toxic Person and How to Respond

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2016-08-31.

Six Relationship Behaviours to Notice Early

The easiest way to spot a toxic person early is to watch how they treat people and rules that do not matter to them, and how they react when something is their fault. Six patterns show up again and again: casual disrespect, shifting blame, constant self-promotion, interrupting, an endless need for attention and a habit of putting others down. One of these on a bad day means little. Several of them, repeated over weeks, are worth taking seriously.

"Toxic" is not a clinical diagnosis. It is everyday shorthand for behaviour that leaves the people around someone drained, belittled or confused. Many such people are charming and fun at first, which is exactly why the warning signs are easy to miss when you are getting to know a new friend, colleague or date. Here is what to look for, why it matters and how to respond without becoming suspicious of everyone you meet.

Signs 1 and 2: Casual disrespect and blame-shifting

1. Small acts of disrespect

Watch the little things. Do they speak down to waiting staff, roll their eyes at people's questions or drop litter without a thought? Do they ignore a clear "no photos" request at an event, or leave their mess for someone else to deal with because that is somebody else's job? None of these is a crime, but together they reveal a belief that ordinary courtesy applies to other people. Someone who treats strangers' time and effort as unimportant is likely, sooner or later, to treat your feelings the same way.

2. Nothing is ever their fault

Listen to how they tell stories about problems. If they got hurt, it was because someone nagged them into the task. If they missed a promotion, the boss is an idiot. If they keep getting pulled over, the police are unfair. A person who never owns a mistake cannot learn from one, and in a close relationship that blame tends to land on you.

Relationship researcher John Gottman lists defensiveness, including shifting blame and playing the victim, among the "Four Horsemen" of communication patterns that predict relationship breakdown. The healthier alternative he describes is simple to name and hard to do: accept some responsibility, even a small part.

Signs 3 and 4: Humble-bragging and interrupting

3. Every conversation becomes a showcase

There is nothing wrong with being proud of what you do. The warning sign is when achievements are used to rank people. You hear, several times, how much better they are than their colleagues, followed by a fake-modest "but I'm sure they're trying". You learn about the yoga, the language classes, the volunteering and the garden within minutes of meeting them. The point of the conversation is not connection. It is making sure you feel smaller.

4. They talk over you

Everyone interrupts sometimes, especially when excited. A habit of cutting people off, finishing their sentences wrongly or steering every topic back to themselves sends a clearer message: my words matter more than yours. It also shows they are not really listening, only waiting for their turn. Notice whether they ever ask a follow-up question about something you said.

Signs 5 and 6: Attention-seeking and putting others down

5. They need the spotlight all the time

Bandleader Paul Shaffer once joked about loving to be the centre of attention because of his oversized ego. In a comedian, that is self-aware humour. In a friend who sulks, escalates or creates drama whenever attention shifts elsewhere, it is exhausting. Constant need for validation often points to insecurity: if a person cannot approve of themselves, no amount of approval from others feels like enough, and the people around them end up working to fill a hole that cannot be filled.

6. They have something cruel to say about everyone

Some people seem to keep a running commentary of other people's weight, intelligence, money or looks, including people they have never met. It can seem odd that someone with a fragile ego spends so much time judging, but the two often go together. A line widely attributed to writer and physician Charles F. Glassman puts it neatly: "Judging others is easy because it distracts us from the responsibility of judging ourselves."

Gottman's research singles out contempt, meaning mockery, sarcasm, name-calling and an air of superiority, as the most damaging of his Four Horsemen in couples. If someone shows constant contempt for strangers, it is reasonable to wonder how long it will be before it is aimed at you.

What psychology says about toxic behaviour

Psychologists do not use "toxic person" as a category, but several well-studied traits overlap with the signs above. In 2002, Delroy Paulhus and Kevin Williams described the "Dark Triad": narcissism (grandiosity and low empathy), Machiavellianism (manipulation and cold self-interest) and psychopathy (callousness and impulsivity). These traits exist on a spectrum in the general population, not only in clinical cases, and research links them to manipulation tactics such as excessive charm.

That last point explains why toxic people are often attractive company at first. Charm is the opening move. The patterns only become clear over time, in how someone handles disappointment, disagreement and other people's needs.

It is also worth remembering that most people who show one or two of these behaviours are not dark personalities at all. Stress, grief, burnout or simply never having been taught better can all produce rude or self-centred behaviour for a while. That is why patterns matter far more than single moments.

How to respond without becoming paranoid

  • Give it time. One sharp comment or interruption tells you little. Look for repetition across different situations.
  • Test with a small boundary. Say no to something minor or change a plan. A healthy person may be disappointed but adapts. A toxic one sulks, pressures or punishes.
  • Raise one behaviour directly. "I noticed you cut me off a few times, and I'd like to finish my point." How they respond is more revealing than the original habit.
  • Keep your other relationships strong. People who isolate you from friends and family are a serious warning sign.
  • Step back if the pattern holds. You do not need a dramatic confrontation. Spending less time together and investing in people who leave you feeling better is a perfectly valid choice.

If a relationship involves threats, control over money or movement, or any physical harm, that goes beyond "toxic" and into abuse. Reach out to a trusted person, a doctor or a local support service.

Common myths about toxic people

"Toxic people are obvious." Often they are the most likeable person in the room at first.

"If I'm kind enough, they'll change." Change is possible, but it depends on the person recognising their behaviour and wanting to work on it. Your kindness cannot do that work for them.

"Calling someone toxic settles the matter." Labels can be overused. Describing specific behaviours, such as "he blames others whenever something goes wrong", is fairer and more useful than a single word.

"Only other people are toxic." Most of us slip into some of these habits under stress. The same list is a useful mirror.

Choosing people who build you up

Novelist William Gay is credited with a blunt piece of advice on this: "There's folks you just don't need. You're better off without em." You do not have to cut people off at the first sign of rudeness, but you are allowed to notice how you feel after time with someone. The friends worth keeping are the ones who listen, own their mistakes, celebrate your wins without competing and leave you more yourself, not less.

Sources: The original list of six signs was published by I Heart Intelligence (2016). Research: The Gottman Institute on the Four Horsemen; Dark triad (Wikipedia). Quotes: William Gay on Goodreads; the Charles F. Glassman and Paul Shaffer lines are as widely attributed online.

COMMENTS