First published August 31, 2016.

Are lazy people smarter? That is how a 2016 study was shared around the internet, but it is not what the study found. Researchers at Florida Gulf Coast University compared 60 students who either loved or avoided effortful thinking, and found that the keen thinkers moved noticeably less on weekdays. The study did not measure intelligence or IQ, and it did not show that laziness is a sign of brains. It showed an interesting link between a thinking style and daily activity, in a small group, over one week.
Here is what the researchers did, what they found, and what it means for anyone who would rather read than run.
What the study actually measured
The research was led by psychologist Todd McElroy and published in the Journal of Health Psychology under the title “The physical sacrifice of thinking: Investigating the relationship between thinking and physical activity in everyday life.”
The team started with an online questionnaire called the Need for Cognition scale. It asks how much people agree with statements such as “I only think as hard as I have to” or how much they enjoy solving puzzles and tackling complex problems. From a larger pool of students, they picked 30 who scored very high, nicknamed “thinkers,” and 30 who scored very low, the “non-thinkers.”
Each of the 60 students then wore a wrist accelerometer, a motion tracker similar to a fitness band, continuously for seven days. That gave the researchers an objective record of how much each person moved, rather than relying on what people remembered.
What the researchers found
From Monday to Friday, the thinkers were clearly less physically active than the non-thinkers. The researchers described the gap as robust and statistically significant. At the weekend, however, the difference disappeared, and both groups moved about the same amount.
The team could not explain the weekend result from their data. Possible reasons include differences in class schedules, jobs, commuting or sports routines during the week, but the study was not designed to test any of those.
Their practical conclusion was gentle. McElroy suggested that people who enjoy deep thinking could benefit from simple “awareness of their tendency to be less active,” and from building more movement into their whole day rather than relying on one gym visit.
Need for cognition is not the same as IQ
This is where the viral headlines went wrong. Need for cognition, a concept developed by psychologists John Cacioppo and Richard Petty in the early 1980s, describes motivation: how much someone likes to think, analyse and puzzle things out. It does not measure how well they think.
The two are related. People who enjoy thinking tend to score somewhat higher on intelligence tests, and they often do well in school. But plenty of highly intelligent people do not especially enjoy effortful thinking, and many people who love it are of average ability. The 2016 study gave no IQ test, so it could say nothing directly about intelligence.
It also did not measure laziness in any everyday sense. Moving less during the week can reflect a desk-heavy course, a long bus ride or a part-time job, not a lack of drive. The original wave of articles turned “thinkers move less on weekdays” into “lazy people are geniuses,” which is a different and much bigger claim.
Why the sample size matters
Sixty students wearing trackers for one week is a reasonable pilot study, but it is small. All participants came from one university, mostly from a similar age group and background, and the researchers themselves acknowledged that the results might not hold for older adults, non-students or other cultures.
The design also chose only the extremes of the scale, very high and very low scorers. That is a common way to make differences easier to spot, but it can exaggerate them compared with the general population, where most people sit somewhere in the middle. And because it was a correlation, the study cannot show that thinking causes people to move less, or the reverse.
The boredom theory, and its limits
To explain the pattern, the authors and the science writers who covered the work pointed to older research on boredom. Studies from the 1990s suggested that people who enjoy thinking are less prone to boredom and find dull situations easier to tolerate, perhaps because they can keep themselves occupied in their own heads. Following that line, people low in need for cognition might seek out physical activity partly to escape boredom.
It is an appealing idea, but it is a hypothesis, not something this study tested. Activity levels are shaped by many factors, including health, sleep, habits, friends, money, the neighbourhood you live in and whether sport was enjoyable at school. A thinking style is just one piece of that picture.
Common myths about laziness and intelligence
Myth: smart people are naturally lazy. There is no good evidence for this. Intelligence is linked with many outcomes, but not with a general lack of effort.
Myth: being active makes you less clever. The opposite is closer to the truth. A large body of research links regular physical activity with better mood, sleep and, in older adults, slower cognitive decline. Exercise appears to support the brain rather than compete with it.
Myth: one study settles a question. Single small studies are a starting point. The value comes when other teams repeat the work with bigger and more varied groups.
Practical takeaways for thinkers
If you recognise yourself in the “thinkers” group, the useful message is not that your couch time proves your genius, but that deep focus can quietly keep you still for hours. The World Health Organization recommends that adults get at least 150 to 300 minutes of moderate activity each week, plus muscle-strengthening work on two or more days, and limit long periods of sitting.
Small changes fit a thinking-heavy life well: walking meetings or phone calls, a standing desk for part of the day, a short walk between reading sessions, or cycling instead of driving short distances. Many people find that a walk actually helps them think through a problem. If you have health concerns or have been inactive for a long time, talk to a doctor before starting a new routine.
Sources: BPS Research Digest: Are brainy people lazy?; McElroy et al., Journal of Health Psychology (2016); World Health Organization: Physical activity fact sheet; I Heart Intelligence (earlier report).

COMMENTS