Nature Walks and the Brain: What the Stanford Rumination Study Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2016-03-25.

Woodland Visits and Research on Stress or Brain Measures

Does a walk in the woods actually change what is going on in your brain? A well-known Stanford study published in 2015 suggests it can, at least in the short term. Healthy adults who walked for 90 minutes through green, natural surroundings reported less brooding afterwards and showed reduced activity in a brain area linked to that kind of negative, repetitive thinking. People who walked the same length of time beside a busy road showed no such change.

The findings are encouraging, but they are also narrower than many headlines made them sound. Here is what the researchers did, what they found, and what it does and does not mean for everyday life.

The Stanford experiment in brief

The study was led by Gregory Bratman, then a graduate student at Stanford, working with psychologist James Gross, environmental scientist Gretchen Daily and colleagues including J. Paul Hamilton and Kevin Hahn. It appeared in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) in June 2015 under the title "Nature experience reduces rumination and subgenual prefrontal cortex activation".

The team recruited 38 city-dwelling adults with no history of mental illness and split them into two groups:

  • The nature group walked for 90 minutes through grassland dotted with oak trees and shrubs near the Stanford campus.
  • The urban group walked for 90 minutes along El Camino Real in Palo Alto, a loud, heavily used road with several lanes of traffic in each direction.

Before and after the walks, the researchers measured heart rate and breathing, gave everyone a questionnaire on rumination, and scanned their brains.

What is rumination, and why measure it?

Rumination is the habit of going over the same negative thoughts again and again: replaying an embarrassing moment, dwelling on your faults, or circling a worry without getting any closer to solving it. Everyone does it sometimes. When it becomes persistent, psychologists see it as a known risk factor for depression and anxiety.

The questionnaire asked people how strongly they agreed with statements about turning their attention inward on things they would rather stop thinking about. Scores were compared before and after each walk.

The brain scans focused on the subgenual prefrontal cortex (sgPFC), a small region at the front of the brain. Earlier research had found it to be especially active during the sad, self-focused brooding typical of rumination, and it has been studied in people with depression.

What the researchers found

After the nature walk, participants reported less rumination than before, and their scans showed reduced activity in the sgPFC. The urban walkers showed neither change. Heart rate and breathing measures, on the other hand, differed very little between the two groups, which suggests the effect was not just about relaxing physically or getting some exercise, since both groups walked for the same time.

Bratman told Stanford's news service that the result was exciting because it showed nature having an effect on "an aspect of emotion regulation". The scans mattered because they added a measurable brain change to what people said about how they felt.

The study built on Bratman's earlier work. In a previous experiment, his team had found that a walk in nature improved mood and some aspects of thinking, including working memory, and reduced anxiety compared with an urban walk.

What the study does not show

It is easy to read too much into results like these. A few limits are worth keeping in mind:

  • It was small. Thirty-eight people, split into two groups, is a modest sample for any study, and it was a single experiment rather than a long-term trial.
  • Participants were healthy. Nobody in the study had depression, so it cannot tell us whether nature walks treat or prevent it.
  • The effect was short term. The measurements were taken right after one walk. Whether regular walks produce lasting changes is a separate question.
  • It does not prove cause on a larger scale. James Gross said the results were consistent with, but did not yet prove, a causal link between growing urbanisation and rising rates of mental illness.

A common myth is that a single study like this shows "nature cures depression". It does not. What it offers is a plausible mechanism, less brooding and calmer activity in one brain region, that fits with a wider body of research.

Why it matters in a world of cities

The researchers framed their work around urbanisation. More than half of the world's population now lives in towns and cities, and United Nations projections put the figure at around two-thirds by 2050. The Stanford team noted that city dwellers face a higher risk of anxiety and mood disorders than people in rural areas, while also having less contact with nature.

Urban life brings stressors that are easy to recognise: noise, traffic, crowds and constant social contact. Gretchen Daily summed up the team's view by saying that accessible natural areas "may be vital for mental health in our rapidly urbanizing world". That makes parks, street trees and green corridors a public-health question, not just a matter of looks.

Other research points in a similar direction. A large 2019 study of around 20,000 people in England, published in Scientific Reports, found that people who spent at least two hours a week in nature were more likely to report good health and wellbeing, and the benefit did not seem to depend on whether the time came in one visit or several. Research on Japan's practice of shinrin-yoku, or "forest bathing", has explored similar effects on stress.

Practical ways to use the findings

You do not need a forest or a whole afternoon to put this into practice. Some ideas based on the research:

  • Choose the green route. If you walk to work or the shops, a path through a park or along a river may do more for your mood than the shortest route beside traffic.
  • Aim for regular time outdoors. Spreading a couple of hours across the week is a realistic target for many people.
  • Leave the phone in your pocket. Part of the benefit may come from letting your attention drift to your surroundings rather than to your own thoughts or a screen.
  • Notice when you are brooding. If you catch yourself replaying the same worry, a change of scene can be a simple way to break the loop.

Time in nature is a helpful habit, not a replacement for care. If low mood, anxiety or persistent negative thinking are affecting your daily life, talk to a doctor.

Sources: Stanford Report, 30 June 2015: Stanford researchers find mental health prescription: Nature; KurzweilAI, 1 July 2015: Walking in nature lowers risk of depression, scientists find in MRI study; Bratman G.N. et al., "Nature experience reduces rumination and subgenual prefrontal cortex activation", PNAS 112 (28), 2015. Earlier coverage: I Heart Intelligence.

COMMENTS