Do Detox Foot Pads Work? Evidence, Risks and Misleading Claims

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Here’s How!
Flickr

A dark foot pad can look convincing the morning after you use it. But a change in a product's appearance is not a measurement of what has left your body. The promise that an overnight pad can draw out toxins needs evidence that the pad actually does that.

Mayo Clinic's review of detox foot pads reports no trustworthy scientific evidence that they work. It also warns about allergic reactions and the possibility of worsening irritated, infected or wounded skin.

What the 2016 post claimed, and the recipe it gave

The post, first published in January 2016, said that foot pads are commonly worn in Japan, stuck to the soles of the feet overnight to rid the body of toxins, and that people wake up to dark pads supposedly full of toxins from the body. It claimed that because the pads are all natural there are no side effects, that wearing them helps circulate blood and lymph into the torso (useful, it said, for people whose circulation in the ankles, lower legs and feet is poor because of inactivity or illness), and that they relieve tiredness, joint pain and headaches. Readers could make their own pads or buy ready-made ones.

The homemade version it described used onion, garlic, water, self-stick gauze pads and socks: the onion and garlic were sliced thin and boiled in water for ten minutes, the liquid was left to cool for about 20 minutes and poured onto the gauze pads just enough to wet them (keeping the sticky edges dry), and the pads were stuck to the centre of the soles at bedtime and held in place with socks, then thrown away in the morning. The post said the brown colour on the used pad showed “just how many toxins have been released”.

None of those health claims is supported. A brown stain on a pad soaked in onion-and-garlic liquid and worn against a warm, sweating foot is not a measurement of anything leaving the body, and “natural” does not mean free of side effects: the Mayo Clinic review cited above warns of allergic reactions and of worsening irritated, infected or wounded skin. Commercial pads have drawn regulatory action: in January 2009 the US Federal Trade Commission sued the marketers of Kinoki foot pads, alleging that claims that the pads remove heavy metals, toxins, parasites and chemicals and treat depression, diabetes, high blood pressure and other conditions were false or unsubstantiated.

A photograph is not a detoxification test

Suppose someone shows you a used pad and says it contains toxins. Three questions immediately matter: which substance was measured, how was it identified, and how was the amount compared with an unused pad? Without those details, the photograph cannot establish the claim. Testimonials about feeling better also cannot tell us whether the pad caused the improvement.

This distinction is useful beyond foot pads. An impressive demonstration may show that a product changes color, heats up or absorbs moisture; the health claim requires its own evidence. Ask the seller for research on the exact product and promised outcome, rather than accepting a dramatic before-and-after picture as a substitute.

Your body already has systems for removing waste

The kidneys filter blood and remove waste and excess water through urine, as the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases explains. A pad's appearance does not test how well those organs are working.

The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health also describes limited, low-quality evidence for commercial detox approaches and notes that some can be unsafe. Medical treatment for a specific poisoning is a different matter from a general promise to cleanse unspecified toxins.

Before spending money on a detox product

  • Identify the exact health claim, rather than accepting the word “detox.”
  • Look for research measuring that outcome in people.
  • Check whether safety information includes adverse effects.
  • Take persistent symptoms to a qualified clinician instead of assuming toxins are the explanation.

You do not need to buy an overnight cleansing ritual to justify taking care of yourself. Clear evidence is a better starting point than a discolored pad.

Original author and source:

By Charlotte H.

Source: Life Advancer

Related:

For a related approach to checking product claims, see McDonald’s Fries Ingredients: How to Check the List for Your Country.

COMMENTS