Shen Men Ear Point for Stress: The Technique and the Evidence

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
0 0 Edit this post
An Ear Acupressure Point for Stress: The Technique and the Claims

Pressing a spot in the upper part of your ear while breathing slowly is a harmless way to take a calm minute in a stressful day, and the slow breathing is the part with real evidence behind it. The point usually used is called Shen Men in ear acupuncture, and it sits in the small triangular hollow near the top of the ear. Claims that massaging it boosts overall health, curbs inflammation and addiction, or relieves pain throughout the body are not supported by good evidence.

This routine circulated widely in 2015, credited to Mark Sandomirsky, reportedly a Russian psychiatrist and doctor of medical science who described it on a health programme on Russian television. We could not confirm the broadcast, but the technique is simple enough to try and to judge on its merits. Below is how to do it, where the idea of ear points comes from, and what research says.

The routine, step by step

As usually described, the exercise takes a minute or two:

  1. Sit comfortably and find the point: the shallow triangular dip in the upper third of the outer ear, just inside the ridge.
  2. Press it gently with a fingertip or a clean cotton bud and make small circular movements. Use light pressure; it should never hurt, and never push anything into the ear canal.
  3. Breathe slowly and deeply, letting your belly rise as you inhale.
  4. As you breathe in, move your eyes to the left; as you breathe out, move them to the right. Keep this slow rhythm going for several breaths.
  5. Notice how your body feels: your shoulders, jaw and hands.

Fans of the routine suggest using it whenever you feel tense and again at bedtime.

An Ear Acupressure Point for Stress: The Technique and the Claims

This diagram labels two points used in ear acupuncture: Shen Men near the top of the ear and "Point Zero" on the ridge closer to the ear canal. These positions come from ear-mapping systems developed in the twentieth century, not from anatomy textbooks.

What Shen Men is, and where the idea comes from

Shen Men is usually translated as "Spirit Gate" or "Divine Gate". Confusingly, the same name is also used for a classic acupuncture point on the wrist, on the heart meridian. The ear version belongs to auricular acupuncture, or auriculotherapy, which treats the outer ear as a map of the whole body.

Ear treatments are mentioned in old Chinese medical texts, but the detailed ear maps used today are modern. They come largely from the French neurologist Paul Nogier, who in 1957 described the ear as an upside-down fetus, with each body part represented by a spot on the ear. His ideas reached China in 1958 and were absorbed into practice there. So the idea that ancient Chinese healers named this point for bringing heavenly energy into the body is, at best, a simplification.

What the evidence says

Ear maps

There is no scientific basis for the belief that spots on the ear correspond to organs. Wikipedia's article on auriculotherapy summarises the mainstream view bluntly: these mappings are not supported by medical or scientific evidence and conflict with known anatomy. A controlled study of 36 people with chronic pain, published in 1984, found that stimulating the "correct" ear points worked no better than stimulating other points or a placebo.

Ear acupuncture for addiction and stress

Shen Men is one of five ear points in the NADA protocol, developed at Lincoln Hospital in the South Bronx, New York, under Dr Michael Smith and promoted since 1985 by the National Acupuncture Detoxification Association. The other points are called Sympathetic, Kidney, Liver and Lung. The protocol is used in some addiction and mental-health programmes as a calming add-on. Even a 2016 review written by NADA trainers concluded that randomised trials for addiction are not conclusively supportive, and suggested that the protocol is best understood as support alongside other treatment, not a treatment in itself.

Slow breathing

The breathing part is better supported. The US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health notes that reviews of breathing-based techniques have found reductions in self-reported stress and anxiety, though many studies are small. Slow breathing activates the parasympathetic "rest and digest" side of the nervous system and gives the mind something simple to focus on. The ear press works well as a cue to start that breathing.

Why it can still feel good

Several ordinary explanations account for the calm many people feel. Touching your ear gently is pleasant, the outer ear has plenty of nerve endings, and pausing to attend to your body interrupts a stressful train of thought. The eye movements add a simple rhythm to follow. Expectation plays a part too: believing something will help makes relaxation easier. None of this requires a special energy point, and none of it makes the exercise less useful as a quick reset.

Common myths to set aside

  • "It relieves pain anywhere in the body." Controlled studies do not support this.
  • "It suppresses inflammation." There is no good evidence that pressing an ear point changes inflammation.
  • "It cures addiction." Ear acupuncture is sometimes offered as a supportive extra in treatment programmes, but it is not a substitute for medical and psychological care.
  • "Ancient sages mapped this point." The modern ear map dates mainly from the 1950s.

Other quick ways to ease everyday stress

  • Longer out-breaths. Breathe in for about four counts and out for six, for a few minutes.
  • Move. A short brisk walk is one of the most reliable mood lifters.
  • Name it. Writing down what is worrying you can make it feel more manageable.
  • Talk. A conversation with a friend often helps more than any technique.
  • Protect sleep. Stress and poor sleep feed each other.

If stress, anxiety or low mood persists, keeps you from sleeping or affects work and relationships, talk to a doctor. Effective help, including talking therapies, is available.

Sources: Routine as reported by Truth Seeker Daily, attributed to Dr Mark Sandomirsky. Background and evidence: Wikipedia, Auriculotherapy; Stuyt and Voyles (2016), Substance Abuse and Rehabilitation; NCCIH, Relaxation Techniques: What You Need To Know.

Related:

Labels:

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

COMMENTS

BLOGGER