Can a network of hundreds of online friends leave someone feeling more alone? That is the question at the heart of The Innovation of Loneliness, a short animated film written, designed and animated by Shimi Cohen as a final project at Shenkar College of Engineering and Design in Israel. In about four minutes of clean, fast-moving graphics, it argues that social networks can give us the feeling of being connected while quietly replacing the slower, messier work of real conversation.
The film does not claim to show a brain scan or a laboratory finding, despite the dramatic headlines it was shared under in 2014. It is an essay in pictures. Its ideas come from two named sources: Sherry Turkle's TED talk Connected, but alone? and a Hebrew article by psychologist Dr. Yair Amichai-Hamburger titled The Invention of Loneliness. You can watch it below and then read what it gets right, where it simplifies, and what later research says.

A frame in the bold graphic style of the animation. The full film runs about four minutes and is hosted on Vimeo.
What the animation actually argues
The film moves through a chain of ideas. Humans are social animals, and for most of history our circle of contacts was limited by geography and time. Modern life loosened those ties: people moved to cities, worked longer hours and lived in smaller households. Social networks then arrived promising to fill the gap.
Cohen's point is that the promise works on the surface. Online, we can choose what to show, edit our words before sending them and present a polished version of ourselves. That control feels safe. But the film suggests it also removes the spontaneity, risk and attention that make real relationships nourishing. We end up, in its framing, managing an audience rather than being known by friends.
The closing message is not "delete your accounts." It is closer to a reminder that being alone is not the same as being lonely, and that people who are comfortable with solitude may be better at genuine connection.
Where the ideas come from: Sherry Turkle and Yair Amichai-Hamburger
Much of the narration draws on Sherry Turkle, a sociologist and professor of the social studies of science and technology at MIT. In her 2012 TED talk she asked: "As we expect more from technology, do we expect less from each other?" Her book Alone Together (2011) argued that the technologies that most increase our connectivity can also deepen a sense of distance, and her later book Reclaiming Conversation (2015) made the case that we often trade conversation for mere connection.
Turkle also argues that solitude matters. Being able to sit with your own thoughts, she says, is part of what makes empathy possible. The film turns that idea into its final scenes.
The second source, Yair Amichai-Hamburger, is an Israeli psychologist who has written widely about the internet and personality. Cohen credits his Hebrew essay The Invention of Loneliness as a basis for the script. Older reposts of the video often garbled both names, calling the film "The Invention of Being Lonely" or leaving out half the psychologist's surname. The animation's own Vimeo page uses the title The Innovation of Loneliness.
What research says about social media and loneliness
The film was made in 2013, when hard evidence was thin. Since then, researchers have studied the question more directly, and the picture is more nuanced than either "social media makes you lonely" or "it is harmless."
One frequently cited experiment came from the University of Pennsylvania in 2018. Psychologist Melissa Hunt and colleagues asked 143 undergraduates to either carry on as usual or limit Facebook, Instagram and Snapchat to about ten minutes per platform per day for three weeks. The group that cut back reported significantly lower loneliness and depression, with the biggest improvement among those who started out most depressed. The researchers pointed to social comparison, especially when scrolling through other people's highlights, as one likely reason.
The same team was careful about limits. The study involved young adults at one university and three platforms, and the authors did not recommend quitting social media altogether. Other studies have found that how people use these apps matters: actively talking with friends tends to look different from passively scrolling.
Correlation is not the whole story
Many studies show that heavy use and loneliness go together, but that does not always tell us which comes first. Lonely people may turn to their phones for company, and heavy use may also crowd out time with others. Both directions are plausible, and they can reinforce each other.
Common myths the old headline encouraged
When the film first circulated, it was often shared under a title claiming to reveal "what Facebook is doing to your brain." That framing overstated things. The film contains no neuroscience, and no single platform does the same thing to every user. A teenager keeping in touch with a grandparent abroad and someone comparing themselves to strangers for hours are having very different experiences on the same app.
A second myth is that loneliness is simply a matter of having too few contacts. Researchers generally describe it as the gap between the relationships you want and the ones you feel you have. You can feel lonely in a crowded room or content on a quiet weekend alone.
Practical takeaways from the film
- Notice how you feel after scrolling. If you regularly come away flat or anxious, that is useful information.
- Use apps to set up real contact. A message that leads to a call or a coffee tends to do more than a like.
- Make room for solitude. Short stretches without a screen, such as a walk or a meal, can make time with others feel richer.
- Put the phone away in conversation. Turkle's work suggests even a phone on the table can change how deeply people talk.
- Ask for help when it is more than a mood. Persistent loneliness or low mood is worth talking to a doctor or counsellor about.
The quotation that often accompanies the video, "If you make friends with yourself you will never be alone," is often attributed to Maxwell Maltz, the American cosmetic surgeon who wrote the self-help classic Psycho-Cybernetics (1960). It sums up the film's ending neatly: connection starts with being able to keep yourself company.
Sources: Shimi Cohen, The Innovation of Loneliness (Vimeo); Sherry Turkle, Connected, but alone? (TED2012); Sherry Turkle (Wikipedia); ScienceDaily, November 2018: social media use increases depression and loneliness (University of Pennsylvania study); Animator's website: Shimi Cohen; Found via Why Don't You Try This.
Related:
So, you post how social media makes us lonely and then ask if I will like y'all on Facebook, or Foolbook as its coming to be?
ReplyDeleteI, personally, am on the FB not to collect likes and to share photos of my lunch, to whom I date with etc. I am there because I want share and spread some opinions and to find new ones. They are not dissipated like on the net there, but you can find them in the more concentrated, thicker state...thematically clustered.
ReplyDelete