In late March 2014, in the days before nationwide local elections, Turkey's government blocked two of the world's biggest websites. Twitter went dark on the night of 20 March, and YouTube followed on 27 March, hours after a recording of a confidential security meeting about Syria was posted on the site. Both bans were eventually overturned by Turkey's Constitutional Court: Twitter returned in early April and YouTube in early June 2014.
This is a look back at what happened, why the government acted, how the courts responded and why the episode still matters for anyone following internet freedom in Turkey.

A YouTube stand at a technology fair. For most of 2014 the platform was one of Turkey's most visited websites, which is why its sudden blocking was felt so widely.
The background: leaks and a corruption scandal
The bans did not come out of nowhere. In December 2013 police and prosecutors launched a major corruption investigation that touched ministers, businessmen and people close to then Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. Over the following months, anonymous accounts began posting audio recordings online that appeared to capture senior officials, and allegedly Erdoğan and members of his family, discussing money and political deals.
Erdoğan said the recordings were fabricated or edited and described the investigation as a plot by followers of the cleric Fethullah Gülen to bring down his government. The leaks spread fastest on Twitter and YouTube, which made both platforms political targets.
The Twitter ban of 20 March 2014
At a campaign rally on 20 March, Erdoğan promised to root out Twitter. That night, access was blocked across Turkey. The telecommunications authority said it was enforcing court orders tied to complaints about privacy, and argued that Twitter had ignored requests to remove content.
The block was porous from the start. Turkish users switched their DNS settings or used VPNs, and graffiti showing the numbers of public DNS servers appeared on walls in Istanbul. Even President Abdullah Gül, from Erdoğan's own party, publicly criticised the ban.
The legal pushback was quick. A criminal court of peace in Istanbul ordered a suspension of the block on 26 March, and on 2 April the Constitutional Court ruled that the ban violated freedom of expression. Access returned the next day, about two weeks after it had been cut.
Why YouTube was blocked on 27 March
On 27 March a new recording appeared on YouTube. It purported to capture a meeting between the foreign minister, the head of the national intelligence agency and a senior general discussing possible military action in Syria, including scenarios that could justify an operation across the border.
The government reacted within hours by blocking YouTube on national security grounds. The foreign ministry called the leak a "wretched attack" on Turkish security and said parts of it had been manipulated, while Erdoğan, speaking at a rally in Diyarbakır, called its publication "villainous". Officials did not deny that the meeting had taken place, which made the content particularly sensitive. A source in the presidential office told Reuters that access could return if the recording were removed.

The notice Turkish users saw when they tried to open a blocked site in 2014: a page from the Telecommunication Communication Presidency (TİB) stating that a protective measure had been applied to the address under Law 5651.
The legal tools behind the bans
The government could act so quickly because of Law 5651, Turkey's internet law. Amendments passed in February 2014 allowed the telecommunications authority to block websites on privacy grounds before a judge had ruled; a court only had to confirm each block within 48 hours. Critics in Turkey and the European Union warned at the time that the rules were vague and easy to use against political content, and journalists covering protests against the law in February faced police obstruction.
Twitter and Turkish lawyers and opposition figures challenged the bans in several courts, calling them disproportionate and illegal. Abroad, the bans were widely condemned; US officials likened the Twitter ban to a twenty-first-century form of book burning, and EU leaders called on Ankara to respect freedom of expression.
How it ended: elections and the Constitutional Court
The local elections went ahead on 30 March 2014 with Twitter and YouTube both blocked, and Erdoğan's AKP won the largest share of the vote. Lower courts began ordering YouTube's return from 9 April, but the authority kept the block in place.
On 29 May 2014 the Constitutional Court ruled that the blanket YouTube ban violated individual rights and freedoms. It stressed that free speech also protects views that some people find negative or disturbing. Access was restored in early June, after roughly two months. EU Commissioner Štefan Füle praised the court for safeguarding the rule of law, while Erdoğan accused judges of meddling in politics.
Why the 2014 bans still matter
The March 2014 episode was not the last of its kind. YouTube, Twitter and Facebook were briefly blocked again on 6 April 2015 after images of a prosecutor taken hostage spread online, and later in 2014 the government tried to widen the authority's powers to cover national security, a change the Constitutional Court struck down that October. Turkey has also blocked other major sites in later years, so it is worth checking current reports before assuming anything about access today.
A few lessons from 2014 hold up. First, national blocks are leaky: determined users found workarounds within hours. Second, Turkey's courts, especially the Constitutional Court, have at times acted as a real check on blocking orders. Third, when a block follows the leak of embarrassing material, the attention it attracts often spreads that material further, a pattern often called the Streisand effect.
Sources: Originally reported in part by RT and Reuters (March 2014); Wikipedia: Censorship of YouTube; Wikipedia: Censorship of Twitter; Wikipedia: Internet censorship in Turkey; Al Jazeera: Turkey's top court rejects YouTube ban; European Parliament Think Tank: Social media freedom in Turkey.

COMMENTS