The Shock Doctrine Documentary: What It Argues and Its Critics

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

The Shock Doctrine is a 2009 British documentary directed by Michael Winterbottom and Mat Whitecross, adapted from Naomi Klein's 2007 bestseller The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism. In about 79 minutes of archive footage and interviews, it argues that free-market reforms have repeatedly been pushed through while societies were reeling from coups, wars, economic crashes or natural disasters, when people were too stunned to resist.

Below is a guide to what the film claims, the historical cases it covers, where Klein herself stands on it, and what its critics say, so you can watch it with the full picture.

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)

The film and the book behind it

Klein's book, first published by Knopf Canada in 2007, became one of the most widely read critiques of neoliberal economics of its decade. It won the Warwick Prize for Writing, and in 2019 The Guardian ranked it among the best books published since 2000.

The documentary premiered at the Berlin International Film Festival in 2009 and was later screened at festivals including IDFA in Amsterdam. Klein was originally meant to write and narrate it, but she and the directors disagreed about how to build the argument. In a public clarification she stressed that it is not her film: she chose not to take a credit, a different narrator was used, and the film is presented as the directors' adaptation of her book. She said she had reviewed cuts and offered corrections, and wished it well.

That background matters. If you want Klein's argument in her own words and with her full evidence, the book is the primary source; the film is a compressed, more polemical take on it.

The core idea: disaster capitalism

The "shock doctrine" is Klein's name for a pattern she says repeats across modern history. A crisis strikes: a coup, a war, a currency collapse, a hurricane. While the public is disoriented, governments and their advisers rapidly introduce policies that would normally face fierce opposition, such as mass privatisation, deregulation, cuts to public services and the opening of markets to foreign capital.

Klein traces the intellectual roots of this approach to Milton Friedman and the Chicago school of economics. She quotes Friedman's own view that only a crisis, real or perceived, produces real change, and that the ideas lying around at that moment decide what happens next. In her reading, free-market economists made sure their ideas were the ones lying around.

She also argues that disaster response itself has become a business, with private contractors profiting from reconstruction, security and relief. That is what she means by "disaster capitalism".

The historical cases the film covers

The film moves quickly through a series of examples drawn from the book. Each is presented as a variation on the same pattern:

  • Chile, 1973. After General Augusto Pinochet's coup against Salvador Allende, economists trained in Chicago, the so-called "Chicago Boys", helped design a radical free-market programme under a military dictatorship that tortured and killed opponents.
  • Britain and the Falklands, 1982. Klein argues that the patriotic surge after the war gave Margaret Thatcher the political capital to take on the miners and privatise state industries.
  • Poland and China, 1989. Poland adopted rapid "shock therapy" after Solidarity's election victory, under pressure from international lenders. In China, Klein links the crushing of the Tiananmen Square protests to the push for market reforms.
  • Russia, 1990s. After the Soviet collapse, rapid privatisation under Boris Yeltsin created a small class of oligarchs while millions fell into poverty.
  • Asia, 1997, and Hurricane Mitch, 1998. The film cites the Asian financial crisis and the Central American hurricane as moments when emergency loans and aid came with sweeping conditions.
  • Iraq, 2003. The "shock and awe" invasion was followed by an attempt to privatise much of the Iraqi economy, which Klein argues helped fuel the insurgency.
  • Sri Lanka and New Orleans. After the 2004 tsunami and Hurricane Katrina in 2005, she reports that coastal land went to developers and public schools were replaced by privatised alternatives.

Klein also insists that the pattern did not start after 11 September 2001; she sees the "war on terror" as its latest and largest stage, not its origin.

The link to psychological shock experiments

The most disturbing thread in the film starts not with economics but with psychiatry. In the 1950s, Scottish-born psychiatrist Ewen Cameron ran experiments in Montreal, partly funded by the CIA, that subjected patients to heavy electroshock, drug-induced sleep and sensory deprivation in an attempt to wipe and rebuild their minds. Many patients were left with lasting damage.

Klein uses these experiments as a metaphor: a society in shock, like an individual patient, is easier to reshape. She also argues that this research influenced later CIA interrogation methods, including techniques used in the "war on terror". The metaphor is powerful, but it is also the part that many reviewers found most strained.

The Shock Doctrine 2009 Documentary - Information is shock resistance - Arm Yourself - The rise of disaster capitalism

What critics say

The book and film drew strong praise from some reviewers and sharp attacks from others. Knowing the main objections helps you judge the argument for yourself.

  • Johan Norberg of the libertarian Cato Institute called the analysis deeply flawed and argued, for example, that the Tiananmen crackdown actually stalled liberal reform in China for several years.
  • Tyler Cowen, an economist, dismissed several of the arguments and said some claims, such as the idea that Thatcher manufactured the Falklands crisis, are not supported.
  • Joseph Stiglitz, the Nobel-winning economist and a critic of free-market orthodoxy himself, was broadly sympathetic but said Klein oversimplifies and found the Cameron parallel overdramatic.
  • Shashi Tharoor felt she was too quick to see a coordinated plan where events may have been less connected.

Klein replied that some critics misrepresented her: she was describing a broad ideological trend with many actors, not a single conspiracy run by one economist. Supporters such as the philosopher John Gray called the book timely and devastating.

Why it still resonates, including in Greece

After the 2008 financial crash, many readers felt the book had predicted what came next: bank bailouts followed by austerity and privatisation. In Greece, where bailout agreements after 2010 came with demands for spending cuts and the sale of public assets, the idea struck a nerve. Greek documentaries such as Debtocracy and Catastroika, listed below, make a closely related argument about the Greek crisis.

Whether you agree with Klein or not, the core question the film raises is worth asking whenever a crisis hits: who is making decisions while everyone else is distracted, and would those decisions survive open public debate?

How to watch it well

  • Treat it as an argument, not a neutral history. The film is openly persuasive. Pause on each case and ask what other causes might explain events.
  • Check the cases you know best. Readers from Chile, Poland, Russia or Greece will have their own experiences to compare with the film's account.
  • Read the book for the evidence. The film cannot carry the hundreds of pages of sources Klein provides.
  • Read a critic too. A review by Norberg or Cowen alongside the film will sharpen your own view.

The original embedded video has been removed from YouTube. The documentary has been distributed on DVD and on streaming platforms in some countries, so availability depends on where you live.

Sources: Wikipedia: The Shock Doctrine; IDFA: The Shock Doctrine (2009); Wikipedia: Mat Whitecross; Naomi Klein: Clarification on the Shock Doctrine documentary.

Related:

COMMENTS