Are Profits or Wages Driving Inflation? Australia's 2022 Debate

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published July 20, 2022.

Australian Debate in 2022 Linked Profits and Inflation

In July 2022 the Australia Institute, a Canberra-based progressive think tank, argued that the main domestic engine of Australian inflation was not workers' pay but company profits. Its chief economist, Richard Denniss, told reporters the country was seeing a "price-profit spiral" rather than a wage-price spiral. Employer groups, led by the Australian Industry Group, pushed back, warning that big pay rises without productivity gains would make inflation and interest rates worse. Both sides were reading the same national accounts, but they told very different stories about who was pushing prices up.

This piece explains what each side said, the numbers behind the argument, how mainstream economists reacted, and what the debate looks like with hindsight. It also offers a simple way to judge "greedflation" claims when they come up again.

What happened in July 2022

Australia's consumer price index had risen 5.1% in the year to the March quarter of 2022, the fastest pace since 2001. Petrol was expensive after Russia's invasion of Ukraine, shipping and supply chains were still tangled after pandemic lockdowns, and floods in New South Wales and Queensland had damaged crops. In May 2022, in the middle of a federal election campaign dominated by living costs, the Reserve Bank of Australia raised its cash rate for the first time in more than a decade.

Against that background, the Fair Work Commission had just lifted the national minimum wage, and unions were asking for pay rises that kept pace with prices. Business leaders warned against that. Innes Willox, chief executive of the Australian Industry Group, said the country risked a "wages and inflation and interest rates death spiral", arguing that wage increases not matched by higher productivity would feed straight into prices and force the central bank to lift rates faster.

The Australia Institute's research landed in the middle of this argument. Reported by Yahoo Finance Australia and The New Daily on 17 and 18 July 2022, it said that rising profits, not labour costs, explained most of the extra inflation generated inside the Australian economy.

The Australia Institute's argument in plain terms

The think tank looked at the national accounts, which split the value of what the economy produces into what goes to workers (compensation of employees) and what goes to businesses (gross operating surplus, roughly profits). Its analysts then asked how much of the recent rise in prices showed up as higher labour income and how much as higher profit income.

According to The New Daily's coverage, their answer was that around 60% of the recent inflation could be traced to profits and only about 15% to wages. Denniss's central point was about choice: if firms were truly being squeezed by costs, profit margins would be shrinking. Instead, the profit share of national income was at a record high. In his view that showed companies had room to absorb some cost increases but were passing them on in full, and sometimes more, because limited competition allowed it.

He framed the problem as a lack of competition rather than a lack of skilled workers. That matters for policy. If wages are the cause, the textbook response is higher interest rates and wage restraint. If market power is part of the cause, competition policy, merger rules and price monitoring also come into play.

Why employers and many economists disagreed

The business case was straightforward. Wages are the largest single cost for many service firms. If pay rises outpace productivity, firms either raise prices or cut staff, and the central bank responds by tightening further. Willox and others pointed out that unemployment was near a 50-year low, which normally gives workers more bargaining power and pushes wages up later in a cycle.

Several independent economists were also sceptical of the think tank's framing. UNSW economist Richard Holden called the idea of a price-profit spiral "logically incoherent", and veteran economist Saul Eslake said it was a stretch to blame the inflation surge on profits in general. Their main objections were:

  • Mining distorts the totals. Australia's record profit share in 2021 and 2022 was heavily driven by soaring iron ore, coal and gas export prices. Those profits come from world markets, not from prices charged to Australian shoppers, so they say little about the supermarket or rent bill.
  • Accounting is not causation. Splitting price growth into a wage part and a profit part is an identity: every dollar of price has to go somewhere. Showing that profits rose does not by itself prove that firms caused inflation rather than benefiting from a demand surge or supply shock.
  • Timing. Wages usually respond to inflation with a lag, through annual reviews and enterprise agreements. Early in an inflation episode, profits often jump first.

What the evidence showed later

Inflation in Australia kept climbing through 2022 and averaged about 6.6% for the year, before easing to roughly 5.6% across 2023. The Reserve Bank raised rates repeatedly, reaching 4.35% in November 2023, a 12-year high. Real wages fell sharply in 2022 because pay rose far more slowly than prices, so the feared wage-price spiral did not appear in that period.

The profit debate did not go away. In early 2023 the Australia Institute's Centre for Future Work published a longer report by economist Jim Stanford, Profit-Price Spiral: The Truth Behind Australia's Inflation, claiming that excess corporate profits accounted for about 69% of inflation above the Reserve Bank's target band, compared with 18% for unit labour costs. Those are the institute's own estimates and were contested by business groups. Supermarket prices became a political issue in 2023 and 2024, with Coles and Woolworths, which together hold roughly two-thirds of the grocery market, criticised for their pricing and later examined by the competition regulator.

Researchers elsewhere reached mixed conclusions. Work in Europe and the United States found that profit margins did widen in some sectors during 2021 and 2022, particularly energy, shipping and some retail, before settling as supply pressures eased. A balanced reading is that profits played a real part in some industries at some moments, while energy shocks, pandemic demand and supply bottlenecks explained a large share of the overall surge.

Common myths about profits, wages and inflation

  • "Record profits prove price gouging." Not on their own. Profits can rise because sales volumes jump, because export prices climb overseas, or because costs fell. You need to compare margins, not just totals.
  • "Wages always cause inflation when unemployment is low." Low unemployment raises the risk, but in 2022 Australian wages lagged prices badly. The spiral needs both sides to keep chasing each other.
  • "Interest rates fix every kind of inflation." Rate rises cool demand, but they cannot quickly fix a supply shock or weak competition in a concentrated market.
  • "One cause explains everything." Most economists who studied the 2021 to 2023 surge concluded that several forces overlapped, and their weight changed over time.

How to judge a "greedflation" claim yourself

When a new report blames prices on profits, or on wages, a few questions help sort out what it really shows:

  • Does it look at profit margins (profit per dollar of sales), or just total profit dollars?
  • Does it exclude mining and energy exports, which can swamp national totals in a commodity country like Australia?
  • Does it compare the same time period and sector for prices, costs and profits?
  • Who published it, and has it been reviewed or challenged by economists outside that organisation?

Asked this way, the 2022 debate is less a battle between two slogans and more a useful reminder: higher revenue can come from higher prices, more sales or both, and only a careful look at costs and margins can tell which.

Sources: Yahoo Finance Australia (July 2022); The New Daily; The Australia Institute, Profit-Price Spiral; Wikipedia: Reserve Bank of Australia; Wikipedia: 2021–2023 inflation surge.

COMMENTS