Originally published 2022-07-21.

In July 2022, health officials in South Africa's Eastern Cape announced that methanol, a toxic industrial alcohol, had been found in the bodies of all 21 young people who died at the Enyobeni tavern in East London the previous month. Many people assumed the case was solved: poisoned, bootleg alcohol. The full picture turned out to be more complicated. When the doctors who carried out the post-mortems testified at the inquest, they said the teenagers died of crush asphyxia in an overcrowded room, with methanol, carbon monoxide and alcohol contributing but not lethal on their own.
This article explains what happened on that night, what the methanol finding meant and did not mean, what the inquest heard, and where the search for accountability stood by 2026.
What happened at the Enyobeni tavern
The deaths occurred during a crowded party at the tavern in East London on the night of 25 to 26 June 2022. Many of the young patrons were reportedly celebrating the end of mid-year school exams. In the early hours, people began collapsing; some were found lying on the floor and on tables, with no obvious sign of a fight or injury. Police said at the time that the bodies showed no external wounds.
Officials reported that the dead were aged between 13 and 17. The scale of the loss, and the fact that so many children had been inside a licensed drinking venue, shocked the country. President Cyril Ramaphosa attended a memorial service for the victims, and the provincial liquor authorities reportedly moved against the tavern's licence.
The July 2022 methanol announcement
About three weeks later, Dr Litha Matiwane, the Eastern Cape health department's deputy director for clinical services, told a press conference that toxicology tests had detected methanol in every one of the 21 victims. He was careful to add that analysts were still working on how much methanol was present and whether it could have caused death. In his words, laboratories were still studying "whether it could have been the final cause of death."
That caveat was often lost in headlines. Detecting a substance in the blood shows exposure, not necessarily that the substance killed someone. Quantity matters, and so do the other conditions people were exposed to at the same time.
What methanol is, and why it is dangerous
Methanol is a colourless liquid used in fuel, antifreeze, solvents and windscreen-washer fluid. It looks and smells much like ordinary drinking alcohol (ethanol), which is why it turns up in illicit or counterfeit spirits, either by accident during crude distillation or because criminals use it to stretch a batch cheaply.
Once swallowed, the liver converts methanol into formaldehyde and then formic acid. Formic acid disrupts how cells use oxygen and makes the blood dangerously acidic. Early symptoms such as headache, dizziness and nausea can look like ordinary drunkenness, but more serious effects often appear 10 to 30 hours later, including blurred or "snowstorm" vision, blindness, breathing failure and death. Damage to the optic nerve has been reported after only a few millilitres.
Mass poisonings from tainted alcohol still happen around the world. In Iran in 2020, nearly 300 people died after a false rumour claimed methanol could protect against COVID-19. During US Prohibition, bootleg liquor made from industrial alcohol blinded and killed many drinkers. Hospitals can treat methanol poisoning with antidotes such as fomepizole or ethanol, plus dialysis, but the treatment works best when started early.
If you suspect tainted alcohol
Anyone who feels unusually ill, has vision problems or becomes confused after drinking, especially homemade or unusually cheap spirits, should get emergency medical help straight away and tell the doctor what they drank. Waiting to "sleep it off" can be dangerous.
What the inquest heard
The formal inquest into the deaths was held at the Mdantsane Magistrate's Court. Two doctors involved in the post-mortems, Dr Zizo Phithi and Dr Sithandiwe Kunyuza, testified that the 21 minors died of crush asphyxia, meaning they suffocated under the pressure of the crowd.
They described several factors that made the room deadly:
- Overcrowding and a blocked exit. The main entrance was closed while patrons were packed against it.
- Carbon monoxide. The owner had run a generator during load-shedding in a poorly ventilated space. Carbon monoxide levels in some victims reached about 21%, against a normal 3 to 4%, which Dr Phithi described as a double blow alongside the crush.
- Pepper spray. A former bouncer used pepper spray earlier in the night, and a police officer also admitted using it. Dr Kunyuza suggested the panic may have triggered the stampede, but said this could not be confirmed.
- Methanol. Laboratory tests confirmed methanol in all the victims, but Dr Kunyuza said methanol, carbon monoxide and alcohol were contributory rather than lethal on their own. She also conceded that the tavern's alcohol had not been tested for methanol.
A third doctor, the chief medical officer, had died before the inquest; his report reportedly noted pepper spray as a possible contributing factor.
Accountability four years on
In July 2026, more than four years after the tragedy, the East London Regional Court sitting in Mdantsane delivered its inquest findings. According to Eyewitness News, the court found the tavern's former owners, Siyakhangela Ndevu and Vuyokazi Ndevu, liable in connection with the deaths and said they had failed to enforce liquor regulations. Several outlets reported that the ruling found grounds for prosecution. In South Africa an inquest does not convict anyone; any criminal case depends on a decision by the National Prosecuting Authority.
For the families, the long wait itself became part of the story. Many had spent years attending court dates and press briefings while the cause of their children's deaths was debated in public.
Underage drinking and the lessons of Enyobeni
It is illegal in South Africa to sell alcohol to anyone under 18, yet the tavern was full of young teenagers. The tragedy prompted renewed calls for stricter enforcement of liquor licences, tougher checks on age at the door, and action against unlicensed or overcrowded venues, many of which operate in townships with little oversight.
Several clear lessons emerge from the evidence:
- Early test results are not final findings. The methanol announcement was accurate as far as it went, but the inquest showed a wider chain of causes.
- Venue safety is about more than drink. Exits, ventilation, crowd limits and the use of generators indoors can decide whether a crowded room is survivable.
- Enforcement matters. Age laws only protect children when venues and inspectors apply them.
The 21 young people who died at Enyobeni are remembered in their communities as students, siblings and friends. Their deaths remain one of South Africa's worst nightlife disasters.
Sources: Yahoo News: Methanol found in blood of 21 teenagers; East Coast Radio: Doctors confirm crushed asphyxia killed 21 minors in Enyobeni Tavern tragedy; Eyewitness News: Court finds Enyobeni Tavern owners liable for deaths of 21 teenagers; Wikipedia: Methanol toxicity.

COMMENTS