CNN Türk Guest's Greek Islands Scenario and the Aegean Dispute

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-06-12.

CNN Turk Panelist's Remarks About Greece Drew Criticism in 2022

In early June 2022, a guest on the Turkish news channel CNN Türk, political commentator Hakan Bayrakçı, stood before a map of Greece and described how Turkey could land troops on two Greek islands and then claim it was only sending a warning. He argued that such a move would make both Greek and American policy in the region collapse. The segment spread quickly in Greece, where it was reported as a televised plan to invade a NATO ally.

It was not a government order or an official plan. It was commentary on a privately owned channel. But it aired during one of the tensest periods in Greek-Turkish relations in decades, as Turkish ministers were openly questioning Greek sovereignty over islands in the eastern Aegean. That context is why the remarks drew so much attention, and why they are worth understanding properly.

What was said on air

According to the Greek City Times account, which included a translation of the segment, Bayrakçı presented the idea as a limited show of force. Turkey, he suggested, could land on two islands and then tell the world it was not an aggressor. In his words, Turkey could say it did not attack Greece but simply sent a message: "if you continue the aggressive policy I will do these things." The islands were not named.

The programme's host, Hürriyet editor-in-chief Ahmet Hakan, did not push back, according to the same report. The discussion went on to describe Greece as becoming a kind of American state, pointing to the expansion of US military facilities on Greek soil, which the speakers put at close to ten, and echoing complaints President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan had made about those bases.

Greek City Times is an openly critical Greek diaspora outlet, and parts of its description are its own interpretation. The core of the remarks, however, was broadcast and widely circulated on video.

Another analyst's claim about the Dodecanese

Around the same time, Eray Güçlüer, an assistant professor at Istanbul's Altınbaş University who appears as a military analyst, told the channel Haber Global that the Dodecanese had been handed to Italy only on a temporary basis and should have come back to Turkey. He claimed there was therefore already a question of sovereignty. Earlier he had said Greece "has no other way out but to depend on us."

That historical argument does not hold up. Italy seized the Dodecanese from the Ottoman Empire in 1912 during the Italian-Turkish War. The Treaty of Ouchy that ended that war did require Italy to hand the islands back, but Italy held on to them. In the 1923 Treaty of Lausanne, the founding settlement of the modern Turkish Republic, Turkey formally gave up all claims to the Dodecanese under Article 15. After the Second World War, the 1947 Paris Peace Treaty with Italy transferred the islands to Greece. Turkey's rights had already ended in 1923, so there was nothing to return.

The bigger quarrel: demilitarisation and sovereignty

The television remarks echoed a line Turkish officials had been pushing since 2021. Some Greek islands in the eastern Aegean were given a demilitarised status under the treaties that assigned them to Greece. Ankara argues that by stationing forces there, Greece is breaking those treaties.

In December 2021, Foreign Minister Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu went further, linking Greek sovereignty itself to that status and suggesting Greece could lose its rights even over large islands such as Lesbos, Chios and Rhodes if it kept them militarised. Turkey made a similar argument in letters to the United Nations, and Erdoğan repeated it in 2022.

Greece rejects this. It says the islands are Greek under international law and that it has every right to defend them, pointing to Turkey's large landing fleet and the army based on the facing Aegean coast. The US State Department said Greek sovereignty over the islands "is not in question," and the European Union called it indisputable.

A longer history of tension

The quarrel did not start in 2022. Turkey and Greece also disagree over territorial waters, airspace and continental shelf rights. In June 1995 the Turkish parliament declared that any Greek extension of its territorial waters from six to twelve nautical miles would be a cause for war. In January 1996 the two countries came close to fighting over the tiny Imia islets; three Greek officers died when their helicopter crashed during the crisis.

Cyprus looms over all of this. After a coup in Cyprus backed by the military junta then ruling Greece, Turkey invaded the island in July and August 1974 and took control of about 36 to 37 per cent of it. Between 140,000 and 200,000 Greek Cypriots were driven from their homes. Turkey still occupies the north. The Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus declared in 1983 is recognised only by Turkey, and the UN Security Council called that declaration legally invalid.

In recent years Turkey has also launched cross-border military operations in Syria and Iraq against Kurdish armed groups. Human rights organisations, including Amnesty International, have accused Turkish forces and allied militias of serious abuses and civilian deaths, accusations Turkey denies.

What followed in 2022

The months after the broadcast showed the rhetoric was not limited to television guests. In July 2022, a map displayed during a meeting with Turkish nationalist leader Devlet Bahçeli showed Crete and the eastern Aegean islands as Turkish, prompting objections from the US and Germany. In September 2022 Erdoğan threatened action over islands he described as occupied, and in December he said Turkish missiles could strike Athens if Greece armed the islands. Greece informed the UN and NATO, and many governments voiced support for its position.

Tensions eased somewhat in 2023 after deadly earthquakes in Turkey prompted Greek rescue teams to help, and the two governments resumed high-level contacts. The underlying disputes, however, remain unresolved.

How to read stories like this

Television debates in any country can feature provocative guests, and a commentator's scenario is not proof that a government has adopted a plan. At the same time, rhetoric matters when it repeats arguments that officials are making in diplomatic letters and speeches. In this case, the CNN Türk segment mattered less as a military blueprint than as a sign of how normal talk of seizing Greek islands had become on mainstream Turkish airwaves in 2022.

The key facts are not in dispute under international law: the Dodecanese and the eastern Aegean islands are Greek territory, and treaties signed by Turkey itself confirm it.

Sources: Greek City Times, CNN Türk segment report (8 June 2022); Wikipedia, Treaty of Lausanne; Wikipedia, Dodecanese; Wikipedia, Aegean dispute; Wikipedia, Turkish invasion of Cyprus; Britannica, Cyprus.

COMMENTS