First published June 5, 2022.

Photo: chicken embryo, Graeme Campbell/Wikimedia
In 2016 a team at the University of Chile reported that they had grown chicken embryos with a dinosaur-like lower leg. By changing how one bone matured in the developing embryo, they produced a fibula that stayed long and tube-shaped and reached all the way to the ankle, just as it does in the dinosaur ancestors of birds. The study, led by João Francisco Botelho in the lab of Alexander Vargas, appeared in the journal Evolution. No living "dino-chickens" were created: the work looked at a single bone, in embryos that were never hatched.
What makes the experiment interesting is not the headline but the question behind it: how did evolution reshape a dinosaur leg into a bird leg, and can a small change during development explain a big change over millions of years?
Birds are living dinosaurs
Modern birds descend from theropods, the group of two-legged, mostly meat-eating dinosaurs that also includes Tyrannosaurus and Velociraptor. That makes birds dinosaurs in the same way that humans are primates. Older popular accounts sometimes called dinosaurs "giant lizards", but they are a separate branch of reptiles, and birds are their surviving line.
Because the relationship is so close, chicken embryos are a natural model for studying how dinosaur anatomy turned into bird anatomy. Many ancestral features still appear briefly in the embryo before they are remodelled, which gives researchers a window into the past.
The bone that changed: the fibula
Your lower leg has two bones, the tibia (shin bone) and the thinner fibula beside it. In theropod dinosaurs the fibula was a full tube, nearly as long as the tibia, and it connected to the ankle.
In adult birds it looks very different. The fibula is shorter than the tibia, tapers to a thin splinter and no longer reaches the ankle. Bird embryos, interestingly, still start with a tube-shaped, dinosaur-like fibula, which only later becomes short and pointed.
Fossils show that the change happened in steps. Early toothed birds from the Cretaceous already had a splinter-like fibula that did not reach the ankle, though it was still almost as long as the tibia. In other words, the fibula lost its lower end first, and the tibia grew much longer than it only later.
How the experiment worked
Bones grow from their ends. Normally the shaft of a long bone matures and stops growing before the ends do, which leaves growth zones at each end. The team found that in bird embryos the lower end of the fibula matures unusually early, so its cells stop dividing and the bone stops lengthening there.
The key player appears to be a gene called Indian hedgehog (IHH), which drives bone maturation. When the researchers inhibited IHH in chicken embryos, the fibula did not mature early at its lower end. It stayed tubular, grew as long as the tibia and remained connected to the ankle, like a dinosaur's.
Why does the lower end mature early in birds? The researchers point to a small ankle bone, the calcaneum, which in bird embryos presses tightly against the end of the fibula. They suggest this contact makes the fibula's tip behave like part of the shaft. In the treated embryos the calcaneum stayed attached instead of separating, and it strongly expressed another gene, PTHrP, which supports growth at the ends of bones.
What the results suggest about evolution
The experiment also produced a surprise: in the treated chickens the tibia was noticeably shorter. The authors proposed that a full-length fibula attached to the ankle holds the tibia back, preventing it from outgrowing its neighbour. If so, the early loss of the fibula's lower end in bird ancestors may have been what later allowed the tibia to lengthen.
That fits the order seen in fossils. Vargas summed up the approach plainly: "The experiments are focused on single traits, to test specific hypotheses." The value lies in linking a molecular mechanism in living embryos to a pattern visible in the rock record. Palaeontologist Jingmai O'Connor of the Institute of Vertebrate Paleontology and Paleoanthropology in Beijing helped connect the lab results to fossil birds.
Earlier experiments in the same spirit
This was not the first time researchers had coaxed ancestral traits from bird embryos. Botelho's group had earlier produced a chicken embryo with a non-twisted, non-opposable first toe, more like the foot of a dinosaur than the perching foot of a modern bird. A separate team at Yale changed gene activity in chicken embryos to give them a broad, dinosaur-like snout in place of a beak.
Each study tests one idea about how a feature evolved. Together they show that the developmental "instructions" for some ancestral structures still exist in birds and are switched off or altered during growth.
Myths and ethics: no Jurassic Park
Headlines about "dinosaur chickens" invite some common misunderstandings:
- No dinosaur was recreated. One bone took on an ancestral shape. Feathers, wings, beaks and every other feature stayed those of a chicken.
- No chicks were hatched. The embryos were studied before hatching, so nobody knows how such a leg would work in a living bird.
- It was not a breed of modified chickens. The team interfered with a gene's activity in individual embryos to test a hypothesis; it did not create a new line of animals.
Some people still object to this kind of research, arguing that altering embryos only to answer evolutionary questions crosses a line, especially when there is no medical payoff. Others reply that knowing how genes shape limbs feeds into developmental biology in general, including how skeletal birth defects arise. Both views deserve a hearing, and animal research of this kind is reviewed by ethics committees. The researchers themselves were clear that the aim was understanding, not producing dinosaurs for entertainment.
The study's real lesson is quieter than the headlines: large evolutionary changes can begin with small shifts in the timing of growth, and the traces of those shifts are still hidden inside every egg.
Sources: photo of chicken embryo by Graeme Campbell/Wikimedia Commons; HeritageDaily, March 2016: Molecular experiment reverses evolution in birds, obtaining a dinosaur-like lower leg; University of Chile repository: Botelho et al., Evolution (2016); IFLScience.

COMMENTS