Jacob's Adoption After 10 Years and 10 Foster Homes

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-06-06.

Jacob Found an Adoptive Family After Years in Foster Care

Jacob spent roughly ten years in the foster care system. In that time he lived in ten different foster homes, attended ten different schools and, as his court-appointed advocate put it, had ten sets of friends. In December 2021, at the age of 15, he was adopted by Beth and Tim Shelley, a story told by the Kansas City station KCTV5 in April 2022.

His story spread widely online, often mixed up with a second boy's interview from Texas. Below is what each report actually says, why it matters, and what Jacob's experience shows about foster care in the United States.

Jacob's story, as reported

KCTV5's report, filed from Mission, Kansas, focused on the one adult who stayed constant through all of Jacob's moves: his CASA volunteer, Ballard Yeates. CASA stands for Court Appointed Special Advocate, a trained community volunteer assigned by a judge to look out for a child's best interests. Yeates summed up the decade this way:

"Ten different foster homes, 10 different schools. 10 different sets of friends. 10 of everything, but only one CASA."

Because of pandemic rules, the Shelleys first met Jacob over a video call in 2021 and only met him in person a few months later. The adoption was finalised that December. Beth Shelley later told the station that the decision came down to a feeling of fit rather than paperwork:

"What mattered was the connection that we found with Jacob and we just knew that was our kid."

The headline of the KCTV5 piece also mentions two adoptions that fell through before this one, though the article does not go into detail. That is not unusual. Older children and teenagers often go through several attempted matches before a placement becomes permanent.

The Texas interview that often gets attached to his story

Many viral posts about Jacob also quote a boy describing foster care as a prison and saying he wanted a dad who would go outside with him. Those words come from a different child. In May 2022, the Dallas ABC affiliate WFAA featured a 13-year-old named Tim on its long-running Wednesday's Child segment, which introduces children who are waiting for adoptive families. Tim had entered care at three and had also spent about ten years in the system.

His interview is the video below. In it he describes life in residential care as feeling, for many kids, "kind of like being in a prison without walls," and talks about wanting the ordinary freedom of walking out the door without anyone doubting he would come back. At the time it aired, Tim was still waiting for a family. The two boys' stories are both real and both worth hearing, but they are separate, and Tim's interview did not lead to Jacob's adoption.

Why so many moves matter

Every placement change usually means a new school, new rules, new adults and the loss of friends. Research on children in care links frequent moves with gaps in learning, trouble forming trusting relationships and higher rates of emotional and behavioural difficulties. Up to 30% of young people who have been in foster care are diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder at some point, and only about half graduate from high school.

That is why the details both boys asked for sound so modest. Someone who asks how your day went. Someone who goes outside with you. To a child who has packed his belongings in a bag more times than he can count, those small routines are what permanence feels like.

What the numbers actually say

A figure that circulates with this story claims most children are adopted out of foster care within 18 months. That mixes up different outcomes. Adoption is not the most common way children leave care. Federal data summarised for fiscal year 2020 show that of roughly 224,000 children who exited care that year, about 48% were reunited with their parents or primary caretakers, about 25% were adopted, 10% went to a guardian, and 9% left by emancipation or aging out. The median time in care for those leaving was about 16 months.

The KCTV5 report did cite an 18-month figure, but specifically for children with a CASA who go on to be adopted in that local program, not for all children nationally.

On overall numbers, the United States had a little over 400,000 children in foster care in 2020. Preliminary federal figures for 2023 put the total at about 343,000, a decline of nearly 7% in a year. Teenagers like Jacob and Tim are among the hardest to place, which is why programs such as Wednesday's Child exist.

How CASA volunteers fit in

The CASA model began in 1977, when Seattle judge David Soukup grew frustrated at deciding children's futures with only limited information. He asked for trained volunteers who could get to know each child and report back to the court. Today programs operate in 49 states and Washington, D.C., serving roughly 200,000 to 250,000 children a year.

Research on outcomes is mixed. Some studies link CASA involvement to better access to services and more child-focused information for judges, while a large 2019 Texas study found children with a CASA were less likely to reach legal permanency, possibly because volunteers are assigned to the most complex cases. What is clear from Jacob's story is the value of continuity: one adult who knew him across all ten homes.

If you are thinking about fostering or adopting

  • Contact your state child welfare agency or a licensed local agency to learn about training and home studies.
  • Consider older children. Teenagers wait the longest, and many, like Jacob, have spent most of their childhood in care.
  • Volunteer as a CASA if fostering is not right for you. Programs train community members to advocate for a child in court.
  • Support foster families already in your area with meals, respite care or school supplies.

Jacob's adoption is a happy ending to a hard decade, and Tim's interview is a reminder that many children are still waiting. Both stories make the same point: what these kids ask for is not perfection, just someone who stays.

Sources: KCTV5, "10 years in foster care, 2 failed adoptions, 1 child waiting on a forever family" (April 2022); WFAA, Wednesday's Child: 13-year-old Tim (May 2022); Faithit; Wikipedia: Foster care in the United States; Wikipedia: Court Appointed Special Advocates.

COMMENTS