Indian Couple Sued Their Son for a Grandchild or Rs 5 Crore

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-05-14.

The 2022 Indian Lawsuit Demanding a Grandchild or Compensation

Can parents take their son to court for not giving them a grandchild? In May 2022, a retired couple from Haridwar in the northern Indian state of Uttarakhand tried. Sanjeev Prasad and his wife Sadhana Prasad (both also reported with the surname Sinha) filed a petition against their only son and his wife, asking for either a grandchild within a year or compensation of 50 million rupees, about $650,000 at the time. Their case drew worldwide attention because it put an intensely private decision in front of a judge.

Below is what the couple claimed, how the suit was framed, why it struck such a nerve, and what it tells us about family expectations, money and the right of adults to make their own choices about having children.

Who filed the case and what they asked for

The petitioners were the father, a pensioner whose age was given as 61 in Indian reports and 62 by the Abu Dhabi-based newspaper The National, and the mother, aged 57. The defendants were their son, a pilot aged 35, named as Shrey Sagar in some outlets and Sagar Sinha in others, and his 31-year-old wife, Shubhangi Sinha. The two had married in 2016.

According to The National, the claimed sum was made up of roughly 25 million rupees that the parents said they had spent raising and educating their son since birth, plus a further 25 million rupees in damages. The legal news site Bar and Bench listed the matter as a civil suit before the Haridwar District Court, with the parents alleging "mental torture" by the couple for not having a child. The father also spoke to the news agency ANI:

The money behind the claim

The parents said they had used up their savings on their son. The National reported that they paid around $65,000 for his pilot training and took out a loan of 2 million rupees for his education. They also said they covered a wedding at a five-star hotel, a honeymoon in Thailand and an expensive car, valued in some reports at about $80,000.

The Times of India reported that the son lost his job in 2007 and was supported by his parents for more than two years before finding work as a pilot. In the parents' telling, they agreed to the marriage partly in the hope of having a grandchild to spend their retirement with. Their petition, as quoted by The National, put it bluntly: "We killed our dreams to raise him."

What their lawyer said

The couple's lawyer, Arvind Kumar Srivastava, told reporters that the parents were seeking repayment and damages on grounds of "mental cruelty". He said they had tried to persuade their son and daughter-in-law but felt ignored, and that they were heartbroken at the thought of dying without seeing a grandchild. Becoming a grandparent, he said, is a dream that every parent shares.

The petition was filed in mid-May 2022, and a first hearing was expected within days; reports gave the date as 15 or 17 May. No public response from the son or daughter-in-law appeared in the major international coverage, so only the parents' side of the story is known.

What happened next

Unusual lawsuits often generate one burst of headlines and then disappear from view, and this one followed that pattern. No widely reported ruling ordering a couple to have a child, or awarding the parents compensation for the absence of one, has emerged from the case. Any final outcome would need to come from court records rather than early news coverage.

The legal obstacles are obvious. No law obliges an adult to have children, and that a court cannot order a pregnancy. A claim to recover money spent raising a child is also on weak ground: parents in India, as in most countries, have a legal duty to support their children, so that spending is not normally treated as a loan. Indian law does provide for the reverse situation, allowing elderly parents to seek maintenance from adult children who neglect them, under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act of 2007.

Why the case struck a nerve

In India, as in many societies, parents traditionally have a strong say in their children's marriages and careers, and grandchildren are seen as the continuation of the family line. Bar and Bench reported that the mother was distressed by people mocking her over the prospect of the line ending. Pressure on newly married couples to have children quickly is a familiar experience for many families, and the case turned that unspoken pressure into a court filing.

At the same time, India's fertility rate has fallen sharply over recent decades, and more urban couples are delaying children or deciding not to have them, for reasons ranging from careers and housing costs to health and personal preference. The case caught a generational shift in the act.

Lessons for families

  • Support is not a contract. Paying for education or a wedding is generous, but it does not create a right to decide when, or whether, an adult child becomes a parent.
  • Fertility is private and often complicated. Couples may be dealing with health problems, money worries or different hopes for the future. Questions about children can hurt more than relatives realise, and anyone with fertility concerns should talk to a doctor.
  • Loneliness in retirement is real. The parents' grief at the idea of growing old without grandchildren deserves sympathy, even if a lawsuit is the wrong way to express it. Honest conversations, family counselling or mediation are far more likely to help.

The story was quirky enough to go viral, but underneath it lay a genuine clash between parents who sacrificed a great deal and adult children entitled to shape their own lives.

Sources: The National: Indian couple sue son and his wife to demand a grandchild (Taniya Dutta); Bar and Bench: Sadhna Prasad v Sagar; Times of India report; BBC News report; ANI Uttarakhand on X. Photo of the couple: Arvind Kumar Srivastava.

COMMENTS