Originally published 2022-04-29.

On 27 April 2022, Italy’s Constitutional Court ruled that children must no longer receive their father’s surname automatically. The default is now that a child takes both parents’ surnames, in an order the parents agree on, unless they agree to give the child just one of the two. The court called the old automatic rule discriminatory and harmful to the child’s identity.
The decision, recorded as judgment no. 131 of 2022, ended a rule that had survived decades of criticism, several earlier court rulings and a European human-rights judgment. Here is what changed, what did not, and why it took so long.
What the court decided
The court struck down the part of Article 262 of the Italian Civil Code that gave a child recognised by both parents the father’s surname, along with related provisions covering children born in marriage and adopted children. It relied on the constitutional principles of personal identity and equality, and on Articles 8 and 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protect private and family life and forbid discrimination.
In practice the new rule works like this:
- By default, the child receives both surnames, in the order the parents choose.
- The parents may agree on just one surname, either the mother’s or the father’s.
- If they cannot agree on the order, the dispute can go to a judge under the existing procedures for parental disagreements.
Take two parents named Rossi and Bianchi. Their child could now be registered as Rossi Bianchi, Bianchi Rossi, or, if both agree, simply Rossi or simply Bianchi. What the registry can no longer do is enter Rossi automatically because that is the father’s name.
The case reached the court through a referral from the Tribunal of Bolzano, in South Tyrol, which had been asked by parents to register their child with the mother’s surname alone. Rather than rule only on that narrow question, the Constitutional Court raised the wider issue of the automatic paternal rule itself.
The decision was announced on 27 April 2022 and formally filed on 31 May 2022. The judge who drafted it was Emanuela Navarretta, under court president Giuliano Amato.
A tradition the courts had questioned for years
Giving children their father’s name was never written as a single clear rule; it was inferred from several laws and long custom. Italian women have long kept their own surname after marriage, so the rule created a familiar situation: a mother whose name appeared on no other document in the household. In 1988 the Constitutional Court declined to change it, saying it was up to Parliament. In 2006 the court said the rule clashed with the constitution but still left it to lawmakers to replace.
Pressure grew in January 2014, when the European Court of Human Rights ruled in Cusan and Fazzo v. Italy that refusing a married couple’s wish to give their daughter the mother’s surname violated the Convention. Two years later, in judgment 286 of 2016, the Constitutional Court allowed parents to add the mother’s surname, but only if both agreed. Without agreement, the father’s surname still applied, which in effect gave him a veto. The 2022 ruling removed that imbalance.
Campaigners had argued for decades that the rule sent a message about whose family a child really belonged to. Several bills to change it passed one chamber of Parliament but stalled before final approval, which is why the issue kept returning to the courts.
How politicians reacted
Reactions across parties were largely positive, with many saying the job was now Parliament’s. Renate Gebhard, president of the South Tyrolean People’s Party, told reporters the issue had dragged on “from one parliamentary term to the next”, and Democratic Party MP Laura Boldrini called on Parliament to make this “leap forward in terms of civilisation”, according to Euronews. Family Minister Elena Bonetti wrote on Facebook that turning the ruling into law was an urgent priority.
What still needs to be settled
The court itself asked lawmakers to act on two practical problems. The first is the risk of surnames multiplying: if every child gets two names, the next generation could end up with four, so a rule is needed on which names are passed on. The second is siblings. The court suggested that the choice made for the first child should apply to later children of the same parents, so brothers and sisters share a surname.
There are also questions for families formed before the ruling. The judgment is generally understood to apply to children registered after it took effect, not retroactively to everyone who already carries a single paternal name, although adults and families can still use existing administrative procedures to request a change of surname.
Until Parliament passes a detailed law, registry offices apply the court’s ruling directly. Parents registering a birth in Italy should check the current guidance with their local comune, since procedures can be refined by later decrees.
How Italy compares
Italy was one of the few large Western European countries where the father’s name was still applied automatically. Spain and Portugal have long used two surnames, and Spain lets parents choose their order. France has allowed parents to choose the father’s name, the mother’s name or both since 2005. Italy’s ruling brings it closer to this broader European pattern of parental choice.
For families, the takeaway is simple: in Italy a child’s surname is now a joint decision, and the law no longer assumes that the father’s name comes first.
Sources: Corte costituzionale, judgment 131/2022; Euronews, 27 April 2022; Leiden Law Blog: Gender equality under Italian family law.

COMMENTS