The UK's Rwanda Asylum Plan: What Was Announced and Why It Failed

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published April 14, 2022.

The UK's Rwanda Asylum Proposal Was Announced in April 2022

On 14 April 2022, Prime Minister Boris Johnson unveiled a plan to send some people who reached the UK by irregular routes, mostly in small boats across the English Channel, to Rwanda. Their asylum claims would be handled there, and anyone granted protection would stay in Rwanda rather than return to Britain. The scheme never worked as promised: courts blocked it, only four people ever went, all voluntarily, and the Labour government scrapped it in July 2024.

This page explains what was announced, why the government said it was needed, why critics objected, and how the policy unravelled over the following two years.

What the April 2022 deal said

The agreement, called the Migration and Economic Development Partnership, was signed in Kigali on 13 April 2022 by Home Secretary Priti Patel and Rwanda's foreign minister Vincent Biruta. Johnson presented it in a speech in Kent the following day.

The UK made an up-front payment of £120 million to an "economic transformation and integration fund" for Rwanda. On top of that, Britain agreed to cover the processing and support costs for each person relocated, which reports at the time put at roughly £20,000 to £30,000 per person.

The idea was that people who crossed the Channel without permission could be detained, judged "inadmissible" to the UK asylum system, and flown more than 6,000 kilometres to Rwanda. There their claims would be decided under Rwandan law. Those who succeeded would receive refugee status in Rwanda, not in Britain.

It is worth being precise about what the announcement did and did not do. It created a framework. It did not mean that everyone arriving irregularly would be removed straight away, and in practice nobody was sent under the main scheme at all.

Why the government said it was needed

The political backdrop was a sharp rise in small-boat crossings. Around 28,500 people crossed in 2021, and the figure jumped to about 45,700 in 2022. Several crossings had ended in deaths, including the sinking of November 2021 in which at least 27 people drowned.

Johnson argued that people smugglers were selling places in unsafe dinghies and that removing the prospect of settling in Britain would destroy their business model. He described the plan as a way to "save countless lives". In his speech he also argued that many of those crossing were young men who had passed through safe countries in Europe where they could have claimed asylum, and that the system was unfair to people who applied through legal routes.

Tony Smith, a former head of the UK Border Force, gave a more cautious verdict when reporters asked him about it. He agreed that doing nothing would let numbers keep rising, but added that only time would tell whether the plan worked.

Why critics opposed it

Refugee charities, church leaders and opposition parties attacked the plan from the first day. Their main objections were these:

  • Legal risk. The 1951 Refugee Convention and the principle of non-refoulement forbid sending people to a place where they could be returned to danger. Critics doubted Rwanda's asylum system could guarantee that.
  • Rwanda's record. The UN refugee agency, UNHCR, raised concerns about Rwanda's handling of asylum claims, and human-rights groups pointed to restrictions on political freedom there.
  • Cost. Paying another country to process a few hundred people a year looked expensive compared with simply clearing the UK's own backlog.
  • Deterrence. Researchers noted that people who risk their lives in small boats are rarely deterred by policy details they may never hear about.

Political opponents also pointed to the timing. On 12 April 2022, two days before the speech, the Metropolitan Police had issued Johnson with a fixed-penalty notice for attending a lockdown birthday gathering in Downing Street, part of the "Partygate" affair. That made him the first sitting UK prime minister found to have broken the law. A fixed penalty is not a criminal conviction, and paying it does not create a criminal record, but critics argued the asylum announcement was partly meant to change the subject.

The courts and the grounded flight

The first removal flight was set for 14 June 2022. Legal challenges cut the passenger list down one by one, and late that evening the European Court of Human Rights issued an interim measure for one of the remaining passengers. The plane never took off.

The case then moved through the British courts:

  • December 2022: the High Court ruled that the policy itself was lawful, though it found the government had handled eight individual cases wrongly.
  • June 2023: the Court of Appeal ruled the scheme unlawful, finding there was a real risk that people sent to Rwanda could be wrongly returned to their home countries.
  • 15 November 2023: the UK Supreme Court unanimously agreed. It pointed to serious shortcomings in Rwanda's asylum system and concluded that the risk of refoulement made the policy unlawful.

The judgment did not say that sending asylum seekers to a third country is always illegal. It said that, on the evidence about Rwanda at that time, the protections were not good enough.

The Safety of Rwanda Act and the end of the scheme

Rishi Sunak's government responded with a new treaty, signed in December 2023, and the Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Act, passed in April 2024. The Act told courts to treat Rwanda as a safe country, effectively overriding the Supreme Court's factual findings on that point.

Still, no flight under the scheme left before the July 2024 general election. Separately, four people went to Rwanda voluntarily, including one rejected asylum seeker who was paid £3,000 under a voluntary departure programme.

Days after taking office, Prime Minister Keir Starmer confirmed the scheme was finished, calling it "dead and buried before it started". Money already spent or committed was widely estimated at around £700 million, a figure that included payments to Rwanda, staff, detention preparation and legal costs.

What the episode tells us

The Rwanda plan became a test case for "offshoring" asylum, and other countries watched closely. Denmark had signed its own memorandum with Rwanda in 2022, and Italy later struck a deal to process some migrants in Albania. The British experience shows how hard such schemes are to run in practice: they need a partner country whose asylum system can stand up in court, a large budget, and planes that can actually leave.

For readers trying to make sense of old headlines, the key points are simple. The April 2022 announcement was real; immediate mass removals were not. The courts found the original design unlawful. And by the time Parliament tried to override that judgment, the political will behind the scheme had run out.

Small-boat crossings remain one of Britain's most contested political issues, and the debate over how to deter dangerous journeys while respecting refugee law is far from settled.

Sources: Wikipedia, Rwanda asylum plan; Daily Mail, 14 April 2022; JURIST, 7 July 2024.

COMMENTS