Originally published 2022-04-10.
On Saturday 9 April 2022, Elon Musk asked his Twitter followers whether the company's San Francisco headquarters should become a homeless shelter, "since no one shows up anyway." By the next morning the poll had drawn more than 1.5 million votes, with 91.3% saying yes. Musk had just revealed a stake of about 9.2% in Twitter, making him its largest shareholder. The building never became a shelter, but the poll turned out to be an early sign of how he would run the company once he bought it outright six months later.

Here is the background to the poll, what it said about Twitter's office policy at the time, why converting the building was never simple, and what happened next.
The poll and the reaction
Musk posted the question on his own account on Saturday evening, Pacific time. Some users assumed it was a joke. When people asked, he replied: "I'm serious about this one btw." The poll had nearly 22,000 retweets by Sunday morning, according to CBS News in San Francisco.
Jeff Bezos joined in on Sunday. He shared an article about the family homeless shelter that operates inside one of Amazon's Seattle office buildings, said it had worked out well, and suggested Twitter convert at least part of its headquarters. Musk replied that it was a great idea.
The shelter poll was one of a string of provocations that weekend. Musk also floated changes to the Twitter Blue subscription, including a lower price, no ads and the option to pay in Dogecoin, and ran another poll asking whether Twitter should delete the "w" from its name. Both answer options offered amounted to yes.
Musk's stake in Twitter
Musk had been quietly buying Twitter shares since 31 January 2022. On 4 April he disclosed a 9.2% stake, worth roughly $2.6 billion at his purchase prices and close to $3 billion once the share price jumped on the news. The stock rose as much as 27% in a day.
Twitter invited him to join its board on 5 April, a role that would have capped his stake at 14.9% and limited what he could say in public. The shelter poll came while that seat was still on offer. On 11 April he announced he would not join the board after all, and on 14 April he made an unsolicited offer to buy the whole company for about $43 billion.
At the time, Musk was widely described as the world's richest person, his fortune driven largely by his holdings in Tesla and SpaceX.
Why "no one shows up anyway"
Musk's jab referred to Twitter's flexible working policy. In May 2020, under then-chief executive Jack Dorsey, Twitter became one of the first big tech firms to tell staff they could work from home permanently if their jobs allowed it.
In early March 2022, his successor Parag Agrawal announced that offices around the world would reopen from 15 March and that business travel was back. He stressed that the choice would stay with employees: working from home full time, coming in every day, or a mix of the two would all be acceptable. Many staff kept working remotely, and the big San Francisco office was far from full.
Older reports placed the headquarters in Silicon Valley. In fact, Twitter's head office was in the Market Square building on Market Street in central San Francisco, in the Mid-Market area. The company moved there in 2012, helped by a city payroll tax break designed to bring businesses into a neighbourhood that was struggling. Homelessness in that part of the city was highly visible.
Could an office become a homeless shelter?
San Francisco has one of the most visible homelessness crises in the United States, and the 2022 point-in-time count recorded roughly 7,750 people experiencing homelessness in the city. Turning empty offices into housing is a real policy idea that many US cities have explored since the pandemic, so the question in the poll was not absurd.
It is, however, much harder than it sounds:
- Ownership. Twitter leased its headquarters rather than owning it outright, so any conversion would have needed the landlord's agreement.
- Building rules. Offices lack the plumbing, kitchens, showers, windows and fire safety layout required for people to sleep there, and zoning and permits apply.
- Running costs. A shelter needs trained staff, health and social services and long-term funding, not just floor space.
Amazon's Seattle example works because the shelter was designed into the building from the start and is run by an established charity. Nothing comparable was ever planned at Twitter.
What happened next
Twitter's board accepted Musk's $44 billion offer on 25 April 2022. After months of legal back-and-forth, the deal closed at the end of October 2022. Musk immediately removed Agrawal, chief financial officer Ned Segal, legal and policy chief Vijaya Gadde and general counsel Sean Edgett, and soon cut roughly half the workforce. He also ended the permanent work-from-home policy and told remaining staff to return to the office.
In an ironic twist, the headquarters did get beds. In December 2022, reports emerged that some offices had been turned into bedrooms for staff working long hours, and San Francisco building inspectors opened an inquiry. The "w" poll also came to look prophetic: in July 2023 Twitter was rebranded as X. In July 2024 Musk said X would move its headquarters out of San Francisco to Texas.
A pattern of controversial posts
The shelter poll fit a long habit of using Twitter to provoke. A few that drew wide criticism:
- In 2018 he called Vernon Unsworth, a British caver who helped in the Thai cave rescue, a paedophile in a tweet after Unsworth dismissed Musk's mini-submarine idea as a PR stunt. Unsworth sued for defamation; Musk apologised and a jury found him not liable.
- In November 2021 he told Senator Bernie Sanders, who had called for the very rich to pay more tax, that he kept forgetting Sanders was still alive.
- In July 2020 he replied "We will coup whoever we want" to a user who linked US interests in lithium to the 2019 ouster of Bolivia's President Evo Morales. Critics took it as endorsing that ouster; he later deleted the post. Musk did not call for overthrowing Bolivia's government at the time, as some reports suggested.
Polls like the one about the headquarters made headlines and engagement, but they rarely led to action. The building stayed an office, and the city's homelessness problem stayed unsolved.
Sources: CBS News San Francisco: Musk Twitter poll about making Twitter HQ a homeless shelter goes viral (10 April 2022); Inquirer: Musk starts poll on converting Twitter HQ to shelter, Bezos backs idea (11 April 2022); Wikipedia: Acquisition of Twitter by Elon Musk; Wikipedia: Elon Musk. Original reporting: Daily Mail.

COMMENTS