Putin’s Warning That Sanctions Would Raise World Food Prices

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-03-11.

On 10 March 2022, two weeks after ordering the full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Vladimir Putin warned that global food prices would climb further if Western countries kept tightening sanctions on Russia. He called the sanctions illegal, said Russia was still honouring its energy contracts, and accused Western governments of blaming Moscow for inflation that had begun long before the war.

Some of what he said was true, some was exaggerated, and some left out important context. This article explains the warning, checks the key claims, and looks at what actually happened to food prices in 2022.

Putin's 2022 Warning About Food Prices and Sanctions

What Putin said

The remarks came during a televised government meeting in Moscow. Agriculture minister Dmitry Patrushev told the meeting that Russia would keep meeting its export commitments for food, presenting Russia as a guarantor of world food security.

Putin then turned to the West. He said countries taking hostile steps against Russia were telling their own citizens to tighten their belts, dress warmly and were pointing to sanctions on Russia as the reason life was getting more expensive. He argued that Russia was still supplying oil and gas as before, that prices had risen anyway, and that Western leaders were using Russia as a scapegoat for their own inflation. A clip of these remarks circulated widely on Twitter:

The warning was aimed at two audiences: Western voters already worried about the cost of living, and food-importing countries in Africa, the Middle East and Asia that depended heavily on Russian and Ukrainian grain.

Why Russia matters so much to the world’s food supply

Russia’s leverage over food is real. Together, Russia and Ukraine supplied around 27% of the world’s wheat exports and more than half of its sunflower seed exports before the war. At least 25 African countries imported a third of their wheat from the two countries, and 15 relied on them for more than half.

Russia is also among the world’s largest exporters of fertilisers, including potash, ammonia and urea. (Older reports sometimes described it as the largest producer; it is more accurate to call it one of the leading exporters.) Nitrogen fertiliser is made using natural gas, so when gas prices rise, fertiliser becomes more expensive, and farmers everywhere either pay more or use less, which can mean smaller harvests.

Notably, Russia had already restricted some of its own fertiliser exports before the invasion. It banned exports of ammonium nitrate from 2 February to 1 April 2022 to protect its domestic farmers.

Checking the oil and inflation claims

In the clip, Putin said Russia supplied only 3% of US oil. That figure needs context. According to the US Energy Information Administration, Russia supplied about 3% of US crude oil imports in 2021, but about 8% of all US petroleum imports once refined products were included. So the number was not invented, but it was the smaller of two relevant figures.

He also said US inflation was the highest in history. That was an overstatement. US inflation was running at about 8% in early 2022, its highest level in around four decades, and peaked at 9.1% in June 2022, the highest since 1981. In the late 1970s and early 1980s it had been higher still.

His wider point, that prices were rising before the war, was correct. Inflation had been building through 2021 because of pandemic disruption, tangled supply chains and large stimulus spending. On 8 March 2022, two days before his comments, the United States announced a ban on imports of Russian oil, gas and coal.

Were food prices already rising before the war?

Yes. The UN Food and Agriculture Organization’s Food Price Index reached an all-time high in February 2022, up about 24% on a year earlier, and most of that data was collected before Russian troops crossed the border.

The causes went back years: Covid-19 disruption to supply chains, an energy crisis that pushed up fertiliser and transport costs, floods and heatwaves that damaged crops in 2021, low wheat reserves, and growing demand for animal feed and biofuels.

The war then made a difficult situation much worse. Ukrainian ports on the Black Sea were blockaded, fields became battlegrounds, and fuel costs jumped. The World Bank described the conflict as the largest commodity shock in 50 years. Research has suggested that higher costs of inputs such as fertiliser and fuel did more to push up food prices than the loss of grain exports alone.

Did sanctions cause the food crisis?

This is where Putin’s framing was most misleading. Western sanctions largely exempted food, because governments knew restrictions on grain would hurt poorer countries. Fertiliser was not the main target either, although banks, shipping and insurance restrictions made some Russian exports harder to arrange in practice.

The biggest disruption to grain supplies came from the war itself, especially the blockade of Ukraine’s ports, which trapped millions of tonnes of grain. In July 2022 the UN and Turkey brokered the Black Sea Grain Initiative with Russia and Ukraine to reopen those exports and ease Russian grain and fertiliser shipments. Russia later pulled out of the deal in July 2023.

So the fairest summary is that sanctions added friction, but the invasion, the blockade and soaring energy costs were the main drivers of the 2022 food price spike.

Who paid the price

For households in Europe and North America, the result was higher bills at the supermarket. For many countries in North Africa, the Middle East and East Africa, where bread is a staple and much wheat is imported, the stakes were far higher. Rising prices hit the poorest hardest, since they spend the largest share of their income on food.

Other shocks piled on during 2022: droughts in Spain and Portugal, a heatwave that cut India’s wheat harvest and led to an export ban in May, and a short-lived Indonesian ban on palm oil exports.

Reading leaders’ economic warnings

Putin’s speech mixed accurate points with spin. Russia does have real influence over global food and energy markets, and prices were rising before the war. But the claim that the West alone was to blame left out the invasion that triggered the crisis. When a leader at war talks about prices, it helps to check the numbers against independent sources such as the EIA, the FAO or the World Bank, and to ask what the statement leaves out.

Sources: Remarks as reported by Proto Thema (March 2022) and a video clip posted on Twitter by @_AfricanSoil. Fact-check and background: US Energy Information Administration; Wikipedia: 2022 food crises; Wikipedia: Economic impact of the Russian invasion of Ukraine; Wikipedia: 2021–2023 inflation surge; Wikipedia: Dmitry Patrushev.

COMMENTS