Elon Musk on Loneliness, Being 'Medium Happy' and Life Extension

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-09-28.

Elon Musk Speaks About Loneliness and Why He Opposes Life Extension

In a long interview published by Insider on 26 March 2022, Elon Musk told Axel Springer chief executive Mathias Döpfner that he does not think people should try to live for a very long time, because societies need old ideas to fade for new ones to take hold. In the same conversation he described himself as only "medium happy", said there are times he feels lonely, especially when working alone on SpaceX's Starship programme, and, asked about his own death, reportedly said it would come as a relief. Taken together, the remarks offered an unusually personal glimpse of the then world's richest person.

Below is a guide to what Musk actually said, the long-standing idea behind his argument about ageing, how it contrasts with other billionaires' bets on longevity, and what research says about loneliness, which affects far more people than one tech founder.

The interview and its setting

Döpfner, who runs Axel Springer, the German publisher that owns Insider (now Business Insider) and the newspaper Die Welt, conducted the interview in early 2022. It ranged widely, from the war in Ukraine and electric cars to space travel, artificial intelligence and Musk's personal life. Most headlines focused on two threads: life extension and loneliness.

At the time Musk was running Tesla and SpaceX, had separated from the musician Grimes, and was weeks away from launching his bid to buy Twitter. Commentators at Futurism and elsewhere noted that business pressures and personal change could easily explain the candid tone.

Why Musk opposes radical life extension

Musk's argument is social rather than medical. In his view, most people rarely change their minds on big questions; instead, ideas change as generations are replaced. If people lived for centuries, he suggested, society would be stuck with the views of its oldest members, and progress would slow to a crawl. He linked this to democracy, saying leaders need to be reasonably in touch with most of the population they represent.

"I don't think we should try to have people live for a really long time."
Elon Musk, interview with Mathias Döpfner, 2022

He has made similar points elsewhere, and it is worth separating two things he is not saying. He did not argue against treating illness or helping people stay healthy in later life. His objection is to dramatically lengthening the human lifespan.

An old idea: progress one funeral at a time

The thought behind Musk's comments has a respectable history. The physicist Max Planck wrote in his autobiography that new scientific truths tend to win not because opponents are persuaded, but because opponents eventually die and a new generation grows up familiar with the idea. Economist Paul Samuelson later condensed this into the phrase science progresses one funeral at a time.

There is some evidence for it. A 2019 study by Pierre Azoulay and colleagues looked at what happened in life-science fields after the sudden death of a prominent researcher. Publications by the star's close collaborators fell, while work by outsiders rose and newcomers entered the field. That suggests established figures can, without meaning to, crowd out fresh approaches.

Whether this justifies opposing longer lives is a different question. Critics point out that institutions can encourage turnover through term limits, retirement rules and open competition, without anyone needing to die sooner. Many older people also change their views readily, and lived experience has value of its own.

A contrast with other tech billionaires

Musk's position stands out because other wealthy investors are spending heavily on the biology of ageing. In January 2022 the biotech start-up Altos Labs launched with about $3 billion in funding, one of the largest sums ever raised by a new biotech company. Its stated aim is to develop therapies that can halt or reverse aspects of ageing in cells, and its president has said the main focus is healthspan, the years lived in good health. Jeff Bezos is among its reported backers, alongside the investor Yuri Milner.

The two approaches are not as far apart as headlines suggest. Much longevity research is really about avoiding years of disease and frailty, a goal few people, Musk included, would object to.

"Medium happy" and lonely: what he said about his life

When the conversation turned personal, Musk said that being fully happy requires being happy both at work and in love, and that by that measure he was "medium happy". He spoke of degrees of love rather than an all-or-nothing state. He also admitted to loneliness, describing evenings near the Starship site in Texas spent alone in a small house, feeling it most when his dog was not with him.

His comment about death, reported as saying it would be a relief, drew the most attention. Read alongside his views on ageing and his description of an intense workload, it sounds more like a statement about burden and responsibility than a cry for help, and it is not something outsiders can diagnose from a single quotation. Speculating about the mental health of public figures from a few lines of an interview is unreliable and unfair.

What research says about loneliness

Musk's point that everyone feels lonely at times is true, and researchers make a useful distinction. Loneliness is the painful gap between the connection we want and the connection we have; solitude is simply being alone, which many people enjoy. A person can feel lonely in a crowded office or a busy marriage, and content in an empty house.

Chronic loneliness matters for health. Studies link it to higher risks of depression, heart disease and high blood pressure, and a 2010 meta-analysis by Julianne Holt-Lunstad and colleagues found that people with strong social ties had about a 50 percent greater likelihood of survival over the study periods than those with weaker ties. In 2023 the US Surgeon General issued an advisory on loneliness and isolation, and the World Health Organization declared loneliness a global public health concern and set up a commission to study it.

Wealth does not seem to switch loneliness off, though research suggests it is more common among people with fewer resources. Practical steps that help many people include regular contact with a few close friends, shared activities such as sport, volunteering or classes, and pets, a source of comfort Musk himself mentioned. If loneliness becomes persistent, or comes with low mood or thoughts about death, it is worth talking to a doctor or a trusted professional.

The bottom line

Musk's 2022 interview combined a provocative social theory, that long lives would freeze societies in place, with a frank admission that success has not brought him complete contentment. The first idea has deep roots and real counter-arguments. The second is a reminder that loneliness is common, human and worth taking seriously, whoever you are.

Sources: Futurism: Elon Musk says he is lonely sometimes (27 March 2022); Wikipedia: Planck's principle; Wikipedia: Altos Labs; Wikipedia: Loneliness. Interview by Mathias Döpfner, published by Insider in March 2022; the story was also covered by LADbible.

COMMENTS