First published September 28, 2022.
Yes. In October 2021, a team led by geneticist Eske Willerslev of the University of Copenhagen confirmed that Ernie LaPointe, then a 73-year-old man from South Dakota, is a great-grandson of the Hunkpapa Lakota leader Sitting Bull. The evidence came from DNA recovered from a small lock of Sitting Bull's hair, analysed with a method the team spent about 14 years developing.
For LaPointe, the result added scientific weight to what his family had always said. For geneticists, it showed that family links several generations deep can now be tested even when only a tiny, damaged sample survives.
What the study found
The research, titled "Identifying a living great-grandson of the Lakota Sioux leader Tatanka Iyotake (Sitting Bull)", compared the hair DNA with DNA from LaPointe. Its conclusion was that LaPointe is Sitting Bull's great-grandson. Willerslev's team also confirmed the same relationship for LaPointe's three sisters.
LaPointe had long described himself as a direct descendant, and his family history, oral tradition and documents pointed the same way. Others had questioned the claim for years, partly because control of Sitting Bull's legacy and burial site is a sensitive matter. Reacting to the findings, he told Reuters that doubters "will probably doubt these findings, also."
The first author of the paper was Ida Moltke, an associate professor in the University of Copenhagen's Department of Biology. Willerslev led the work from the university's GLOBE Institute; he also holds a post at the University of Cambridge, which is why some early reports mentioned Cambridge.
Why the hair was so hard to work with
Willerslev, known for decoding ancient genomes, received a small sample of Sitting Bull's hair in 2007, around the time he began visiting Lakota communities. The hair was more than a century old, and the DNA inside it was scarce and broken into short fragments.
Standard kinship tests compare large amounts of good-quality DNA from living people. Existing methods for old samples, Willerslev explained, either needed far more DNA than the hair contained or could only reach as far back as grandparents. A great-grandparent relationship is one step further, and each generation dilutes the genetic signal that two relatives share.
How the new method works
Instead of relying on a full, clean genome, the team built an approach that estimates how genetically similar two people are from limited data, then uses computer simulations to test which family relationships fit that level of similarity. Reports at the time described it as based on autosomal DNA, the genetic material inherited from both parents, rather than only the Y chromosome or mitochondrial DNA.
That matters because Y-chromosome tests only trace the direct father-to-son line, and mitochondrial tests only the mother-to-child line. Autosomal DNA lets researchers test a relationship that passes through both men and women in the family tree, as many real family lines do.
The researchers suggested the method could help with other historical cases where only traces of DNA remain, from famous figures to people whose remains have been separated from their communities.
Who Sitting Bull was
Sitting Bull, Tȟatȟáŋka Íyotake in Lakota, was born in the 1830s in what later became Dakota Territory. He was a Hunkpapa Lakota holy man and leader who became a symbol of resistance to US efforts to take Lakota land and confine his people to reservations.
He is often wrongly described as the commander who defeated George Armstrong Custer. Before the Battle of the Little Bighorn in June 1876, Sitting Bull had a vision of soldiers falling into the Lakota camp, which his people took as a sign of victory. During the battle he acted as a spiritual leader rather than a field commander; warriors such as Crazy Horse led the fighting.
After the battle he led his band into Canada in 1877 and lived near Wood Mountain for about four years. Hunger finally forced him back, and he surrendered in the United States on 19 July 1881 with 186 followers.
Buffalo Bill, the Ghost Dance and his death
In 1885 Sitting Bull toured for about four months with Buffalo Bill's Wild West show, earning around $50 a week, mostly for riding once around the arena. He then returned to the Standing Rock reservation.
His death came five years later, not soon after the tour. In December 1890, US authorities feared he would join the Ghost Dance movement, which was spreading among the Lakota. On 15 December, Indian agency police were sent to arrest him at his home on Standing Rock. A struggle broke out, and he was shot and killed by police officers, including Lieutenant Bull Head and Red Tomahawk. Several of his supporters and several policemen also died.
Two weeks later, the Wounded Knee Massacre took place on the Pine Ridge reservation, one of the darkest episodes in the history of the Lakota people.
Why the result matters to the family
The DNA work was never only an academic exercise. Sitting Bull was first buried at Fort Yates, North Dakota. In 1953, family members exhumed what were believed to be his remains and reburied them near Mobridge, South Dakota. Both sites are still regarded as burial places, and LaPointe has been unhappy with how they are cared for and with their commercial use.
According to the University of Copenhagen, LaPointe hopes that genetic proof, together with documents such as birth certificates, will support his wish to have a say over where his great-grandfather finally rests.
Genetics did not create the family's identity, and it does not replace Lakota oral history. What it did was add one more independent line of evidence, something that is hard to argue with even for the sceptics LaPointe had faced for most of his life.
Sources: University of Copenhagen, GLOBE Institute: DNA from Sitting Bull's hair confirms kinship with descendants (27 October 2021); Wikipedia: Sitting Bull. Quotes as reported by Reuters, October 2021.

COMMENTS