Originally published 2022-01-30.
Zazie, a small French bistro in San Francisco's Cole Valley neighbourhood, is one of the best-known American restaurants to have dropped tipping altogether. Instead of asking diners to add 15 to 20 percent at the end of a meal, it raised menu prices by about 20 percent in 2015 and now passes a fixed share of every dish's price to its staff, alongside health cover, paid leave and a retirement plan.
If you are wondering whether a tip-free restaurant can work, Zazie is a useful case: it has run the model for years, through the pandemic and a change of ownership, and its staff say they earn more than they did under tipping. Below we explain how the system works, what it costs diners, what the evidence says about tipping in the US, and where similar experiments have struggled.
How Zazie's tip-free model works
Zazie opened in 1992 under founder Catherine Opoix. Jennifer Piallat bought it in 2005 and, after years of offering staff benefits that were unusual for a neighbourhood restaurant, removed tipping in 2015.
The mechanics are simple. Menu prices went up by around a fifth across the board. In return, the restaurant asks guests not to tip, and a set portion of revenue goes to the people who cook and serve. Zazie's own website says 25 percent of the price of every menu item goes directly to staff. A 2022 KTVU report described the split in more detail: each server receives 12 percent of their own sales, and another 12 percent of sales is shared among kitchen staff according to their roles.
On top of that pay, Zazie lists a benefits package for full-time and part-time employees: fully funded health and dental insurance, paid sick leave, paid vacation, paid family leave and a 401(k) retirement plan with an employer match. The restaurant says its team of 38, with an average age of 27, has built up more than $2 million in combined retirement savings.
What changed for staff and for diners
Before the switch, staff earned roughly $15 to $20 an hour including tips, according to later coverage of the restaurant. Servers saw a modest raise when tipping ended, while kitchen staff, who in most US restaurants do not share in tips, gained the most, with reported increases of around 35 percent. Later reports put staff earnings at about $30 to $65 an hour, and in 2022 a Zazie server told KTVU she earned more than $80,000 a year.
For diners, the visible change is the menu price. When the model launched, a customer told Eater SF she had expected sticker shock but found that the menu "still looks reasonable." Because there is no tip to add, the number on the menu is close to what you actually pay, apart from tax and any local mandated charges.
Some coverage, including the Upworthy story this article first drew on, reported that customer numbers rose by 28 percent after the change. We could not trace that figure to a primary source, so treat it as unconfirmed. What is clear is that the restaurant has stayed busy enough to keep the model for more than a decade.
Staff ownership and the pandemic years
In January 2020, just before Covid-19 shut down dining rooms, Piallat sold the restaurant to three long-serving employees while keeping a 25 percent stake. She had said for years that she wanted to sell to her staff, and the move tied the people running the floor and kitchen directly to the business's results.
Like every restaurant, Zazie had a rough 2020 and 2021. At the end of 2021 it closed for its usual winter break so staff could rest and the building could be repaired, with chipped paint and a worn patio awning on the to-do list. Its Facebook post at the time thanked loyal guests and hoped for a better year after what it called the craziest year the industry had seen.
During the 2021 labour shortage, when many US restaurants struggled to hire, Zazie was reported not to have faced the same problem, something the owners linked to stable pay and benefits. That claim comes from the restaurant itself, but it fits the wider argument that predictable income keeps experienced staff.
Why tipping is such a big deal in US restaurants
Tipping in the United States is not just a custom; it is built into wage law. Under federal rules, employers can pay tipped workers a cash wage as low as $2.13 an hour and count tips toward the rest of the minimum wage, a so-called tip credit. Many states follow that federal floor or set their own low tipped wage.
California is different. It does not allow a tip credit, so tipped workers there must receive the full state minimum wage before tips, and San Francisco has its own, higher minimum. That makes the jump to a tip-free system smaller in San Francisco than it would be in a state where servers earn $2.13 an hour plus tips.
Critics of tipping point to three problems. Income swings from night to night, which makes budgeting hard. Front-of-house staff often earn far more than cooks and dishwashers working the same shift. And research on tipping has repeatedly found that the amount people leave depends heavily on factors unrelated to service quality, including a server's appearance and bias. Supporters reply that tips reward effort and let good servers earn well above a flat wage.
Has the model spread, and where does it struggle?
Zazie is not alone. In May 2021 Zuni Café, another well-known San Francisco restaurant, reopened after lockdown with a 20 percent "fair wage" charge on bills instead of tips. Kitchen staff there earned noticeably more, but KTVU reported in 2022 that some servers were unhappy and wanted tipping back, and the restaurant said it might adjust the structure. In June 2022 Lovina, a restaurant in Calistoga with links to Zazie's ownership, adopted the Zazie model.
Nationally, several high-profile restaurant groups tried tip-free pricing in the mid-2010s and later brought tipping back, often citing staff turnover among experienced servers and diners comparing menu prices with competitors that still expected tips. The lesson from those attempts is that the model works best when the pay split is transparent, servers do not lose income, and guests understand why prices look higher.
What diners should know
- Compare the total, not the menu line. A tip-free dish priced 20 percent higher often costs the same as a cheaper dish plus a standard tip.
- Read the policy. Some places include service in prices, others add a percentage surcharge to the bill. Both are legal if clearly disclosed, but surcharges are not always tips that go to staff.
- Ask where the money goes. Restaurants proud of their model, like Zazie, usually explain the split and benefits on their website.
- No need to tip twice. If a restaurant asks you not to tip, you are not being rude by following that request.
Zazie's experience does not prove that every restaurant can drop tipping, or that one hourly figure is a living wage in every city. It does show that a small, independent bistro can pay staff steadily, fund real benefits and keep loyal customers, as long as the numbers are honest on both sides of the menu.
Sources: Zazie: Our philosophy; My Modern Met on Zazie's tip-free model; KTVU: San Francisco restaurants moving away from tips; KALW: A restaurant owner who thinks differently; US Department of Labor: minimum wages for tipped employees; original report via Upworthy; video and post by Zazie.

COMMENTS