Originally published 2022-01-30.
Yes, by early 2022 MacKenzie Scott had given away far more money than her former husband Jeff Bezos. Forbes' January 2022 ranking of America's top givers credited Scott with about $8.6 billion in donations since 2019, compared with roughly $2.1 billion over Bezos's lifetime, even though he was worth more than three times as much. The two have very different ideas about how to give.
The numbers Forbes reported
Forbes ranked Scott fifth on its 2022 list of the most generous American billionaires, with lifetime giving of $8.61 billion. Bezos appeared on the list for the first time, in 16th place, with an estimated $2.1 billion.
Measured against wealth, the gap is wider. Forbes put Scott's net worth at $53.5 billion at the time, so her donations equalled roughly 16% of her fortune. Bezos, estimated at $184.8 billion, had given about 1%. Some reports at the time stated that Scott received $53.5 billion in the divorce. That is not accurate: the figure was her net worth in 2022. In the 2019 divorce settlement she received Amazon shares then worth about $35.6 billion, and their value rose with Amazon's stock price.
Forbes counts only money that has actually reached charities. Pledges, cash parked in private foundations and donor-advised funds without disclosed grants are left out. Because Scott did not publish some of her late-2021 gifts, Forbes said it was "only crediting her with her known, public donations," so her real total was likely higher.
How MacKenzie Scott gives
Scott, a novelist who married Bezos in 1993 and worked at Amazon in its early days, signed the Giving Pledge in 2019, promising to give away most of her wealth. Her approach has been unusual among the very rich:
- No foundation. She gives directly, without building a large private foundation that holds money for decades.
- Unrestricted gifts. Recipients can usually spend the money however they see fit, from salaries to rent.
- Smaller, community-led groups. Many grants go to historically Black colleges, food banks, community lenders and organisations working on racial and gender equity.
- Quiet research, public announcements. A small team vets organisations without asking them to apply, and she announces rounds of giving in essays posted online.
In one of those essays she described herself as giving away "a fortune that was enabled by systems in need of change," and argued that people building power inside their own communities are the real agents of change.
How Jeff Bezos gives
Bezos has tended to make fewer but much larger commitments, often to established institutions or to funds he controls. The biggest is the Bezos Earth Fund, announced in February 2020 with a $10 billion commitment to fight climate change, which he has said would be granted within the decade. Forbes reported that only a portion of that, around $443 million, had been paid out by early 2022.
Other gifts counted by Forbes include $100 million to the Obama Foundation and around $96 million in grants to homelessness groups through his Day 1 Families Fund. Later, in a November 2022 interview with CNN, Bezos said he planned to give away most of his fortune during his lifetime, though without setting a timetable.
Two models of philanthropy
The contrast reflects a wider debate in charity. Large, long-term funds can tackle big problems such as climate change, back research and keep giving long after a donor is gone. Critics say they can also let money sit idle while donors enjoy tax benefits and public credit.
Direct, unrestricted giving, the style Scott favours, puts cash into organisations quickly and trusts local leaders to decide how to use it. Studies by nonprofit groups have found that many small charities struggle most with basic running costs, which restricted grants rarely cover. Tax rules also shape the picture. In the United States, gifts to a private foundation or donor-advised fund can earn a tax deduction in the year they are made, even if the money reaches working charities much later. That is one reason analysts separate money promised from money delivered. The downside of Scott's style is less public detail about where all the money goes, something Scott faced criticism for before she launched her Yield Giving database in 2022.
What happened after 2022
Scott kept going. By the end of 2024, the Associated Press reported, she had given about $19.2 billion to more than 2,450 nonprofits since 2019. Later figures on her Yield Giving site and in press reports put her total higher still. Bezos's Earth Fund has continued to announce climate grants, while his larger pledge to give most of his wealth away remains a long-term promise.
How to read giving rankings
Charity league tables are useful, but they are estimates. When comparing donors, it helps to ask:
- Is this money actually paid out, or only pledged?
- Is it going to charities, or into a foundation the donor controls?
- What share of the donor's wealth does it represent, and on which date was that wealth measured?
- Do recipients get freedom to use the money, or strict conditions?
On every one of those measures, Scott's giving in 2019 to 2022 stood out. That, more than the headline sum, is why her approach drew so much attention.
Sources: Forbes: America's Top Givers 2022; Wikipedia: MacKenzie Scott; Wikipedia: Bezos Earth Fund; AP via ABC News: MacKenzie Scott reveals 2024 donations; earlier coverage by Upworthy.

COMMENTS