Pig-Heart Transplant Patient David Bennett and His 1988 Stabbing

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2022-01-16.

A Pig-Heart Transplant Recipient's Earlier Criminal Case

Photo: David Bennett Sr. with his surgeon, Dr Bartley Griffith, at the University of Maryland Medical Center. University of Maryland School of Medicine/AFP.

In January 2022, David Bennett Sr., a 57-year-old Maryland man with terminal heart failure, became the first person to receive a heart from a genetically modified pig. Within days of the news, the family of a man he had attacked decades earlier came forward: in 1988 Bennett had stabbed Edward Shumaker seven times, leaving him paralysed. Bennett was convicted and served six years in prison.

The revelation set off a sharp public debate. Should a person's criminal past count when doctors decide who receives scarce or experimental treatment? Medical ethicists answered almost unanimously that it should not, while the victim's family spoke of decades of pain. Bennett died two months after the operation. Below are the facts of both stories and the ethical principles behind the hospital's position.

The 1988 attack on Edward Shumaker

According to reporting by The Washington Post, the attack happened in a bar in Maryland in 1988. Shumaker, then 22, had been talking with Bennett's then-wife. Bennett stabbed him repeatedly in the chest, abdomen and back, then fled, leading police on a car chase before he was arrested.

At trial a jury acquitted Bennett of attempted murder but convicted him of assault. He was sentenced to ten years and released after serving six. The criminal court ordered restitution, and a later civil judgment reportedly awarded Shumaker and his family about $3.4 million. His sister says the family never received the money.

Shumaker's injuries left him using a wheelchair for 19 years. He had a stroke in 2005 and died in 2007, a week before his 41st birthday.

How the family learned the news

Shumaker's sister, Leslie Shumaker Downey, found out when her daughter saw Bennett's name in the international coverage of the transplant. She told reporters that her brother had suffered for years and that the trauma had shaped her whole family. She added: Now he gets a second chance with a new heart — but I wish, in my opinion, it had gone to a deserving recipient.

Some early reports described Downey as Shumaker's daughter. She is his sister.

Bennett's son, David Bennett Jr., told the Post that his father had never discussed the case with him and declined to comment on it.

Why Bennett received a pig heart

Bennett had been bedridden for weeks and was kept alive by a heart-lung bypass machine. Several hospitals, including the University of Maryland, had judged him ineligible for a human heart transplant. His son said doctors pointed to his history of not following medical advice, missing medication and skipping follow-up visits; he was also unsuitable for an artificial heart pump because of a dangerous heart rhythm.

With no other options, the US Food and Drug Administration granted emergency authorisation on New Year's Eve 2021 for an experimental xenotransplant, the use of an animal organ in a human. On 7 January 2022, a team led by Dr Bartley Griffith implanted the heart of a pig that had been genetically modified, reportedly with ten gene edits, so that its organ would be less likely to be rejected and would not keep growing after transplantation.

Ethicists stressed an important point here: because the heart came from a pig, Bennett did not take an organ away from anyone on the human waiting list. More than 106,000 people in the US were waiting for an organ at the time, and about 17 die each day while waiting, according to the Health Resources and Services Administration.

What ethicists said about criminal history

The consensus among bioethicists was clear. Arthur Caplan, head of medical ethics at NYU Grossman School of Medicine, told the Post that medicine treats people who are sick regardless of who they are, adding: We are not in the business of sorting sinners from saints.

Scott Halpern, a professor of medical ethics at the University of Pennsylvania, made a similar distinction. In his view, society already has a legal system to decide punishment for crimes, and the health-care system's task is to care for patients without weighing their character.

That approach reflects long-standing guidance in US transplant policy. A federal ethics committee has held that a person's criminal record or status as a prisoner should not by itself be a reason to deny a transplant. What can legitimately count are medical factors, including whether a patient is likely to follow the demanding treatment plan that keeps a new organ working. In Bennett's case, it was that medical history, not his conviction, that had kept him off the human waiting list.

What happened after the transplant

For several weeks the pig heart worked well, without signs of acute rejection, and Bennett was able to spend time with his family and watch the Super Bowl. His condition then worsened, and he died on 8 March 2022, two months after the operation. Doctors later reported that the heart showed complications and evidence of a pig virus, porcine cytomegalovirus, which may have contributed to its failure. The finding prompted calls for more sensitive virus screening of donor animals.

The University of Maryland team performed a second pig-heart transplant in September 2023 on Lawrence Faucette, a 58-year-old Navy veteran with heart failure. His new heart functioned well for about a month before showing signs of rejection, and he died at the end of October 2023.

Why the case still matters

Bennett's story carries two truths that do not cancel each other out. For medicine, his transplant was a landmark that showed a gene-edited pig heart could keep a human alive for weeks, information that is shaping current trials of pig kidneys and hearts. For the Shumaker family, the coverage reopened a wound that never healed.

Most people who work in transplant ethics argue that keeping these two questions separate protects everyone. If doctors began ranking patients by moral worth, the system would depend on who happened to be judging, and public trust in organ donation could suffer. Justice for crimes, in that view, belongs in the courts, while clinicians' duty is to treat the patient in front of them.

Sources: The Washington Post, 13 January 2022 (original reporting); Insider via Yahoo News: recipient of historic pig heart transplant stabbed a man years ago; DailyO: second pig-to-human heart transplant patient dies. Photo: University of Maryland School of Medicine via AFP.

COMMENTS