In December 2018, a hospital worker in southern Brazil photographed four dogs standing quietly at the emergency entrance of the Hospital Regional Alto Vale in Rio do Sul, Santa Catarina. They were waiting for their owner, a homeless man named César, who had gone inside in the middle of the night for treatment. He was seen and released within about an hour, and the dogs greeted him at the door. The photo, posted on Facebook, was shared tens of thousands of times and still circulates today.
The story is often retold with extra details that do not hold up, such as surgery or a single small dog. Here is what the reporting at the time actually shows, why the picture moved so many people, and what it says about people who live on the street with animals.
What happened at the hospital
The photo was taken by Ana Cristina “Cris” Mamprim, who worked at the hospital. Reports from December 2018 say César arrived at the emergency department in the early hours, around 3 a.m., and that his four dogs followed him and settled at the door, looking in through the glass while he was inside.
Several outlets that interviewed people involved, including the South African magazine YOU (via News24), reported that César was a recycling collector who had come in with severe stomach pain, that staff treated him and gave him medication, and that he left about an hour later. That outlet named him as Cezar Gonçalves and gave the dogs’ names as Bebe, Nick, Menina and Tico; those details were not repeated everywhere, so they are best treated as reported rather than confirmed. Some later retellings said César had surgery for a chronic illness, but the original accounts describe a short emergency visit, not an operation.
Reports also said he often shared his own food with the dogs, which were strays he had taken under his wing.
Why the photo went viral
Mamprim’s post was not just a cute picture. She wrote about a man who depended on help to get through hunger, cold and illness, and yet had loyal companions at his side. She said she did not want to judge his life, adding, in the translation published by My Modern Met: “I admire the respect and love he has for his pets.”
Chilean broadcaster CNN Chile reported that the post passed 78,000 shares and 22,000 comments within days, and that hundreds of people offered to help César and his dogs. Mamprim reportedly said she was surprised by the reaction, because for her this kind of bond between people and animals was normal.
The image hit a nerve because it reversed a common assumption. People often see a homeless person with dogs and wonder whether the animals are neglected. Here, the dogs looked healthy and calm, and their behaviour suggested a relationship built on daily care. Quoted by News24, César put it simply: “Without my little pets I’m nothing.”
Homelessness in Brazil: the real context
Homelessness in Brazil has grown significantly in recent years. Researchers at Ipea, Brazil’s government-funded Institute for Applied Economic Research, estimated about 281,400 people living on the streets in 2022, up from about 90,400 in 2012, and found a 38% increase between 2019 and 2022, a period that included the COVID-19 pandemic.
Street homelessness sits on top of a much wider housing problem. Brazil’s housing deficit, which counts families without adequate homes, crowded shared dwellings and substandard shelters, is often put at around 7 million units, concentrated among low-income families. Rapid urbanisation, high land costs and informal settlements known as favelas are all part of the picture.
It is worth noting the timing. When César’s dogs were photographed in December 2018, neither the pandemic nor the government of Jair Bolsonaro, who took office on 1 January 2019, had yet begun. Retellings that link this specific scene to those later events mix up the chronology, even though both later shaped poverty debates in Brazil.
Living on the street with animals
César is far from unusual. In many countries, a significant number of people experiencing homelessness keep dogs. For them, an animal can offer companionship, a reason to keep going, warmth at night and a sense of safety.
The bond also brings hard choices. Many shelters and hostels do not accept pets, so owners may stay outside rather than leave their animals. Hospital visits, like César’s, raise the question of who will look after the dogs. Organisations in several countries now run free vet clinics for pets of homeless owners, offer pet-friendly beds, or arrange short-term foster care during hospital stays.
The welfare of the animals matters too. The fairest view is the one Mamprim took: look at the actual dogs and the actual person. Healthy, relaxed animals that stay with their owner by choice usually tell you more than assumptions do.
Similar stories of waiting dogs
Dogs waiting outside hospitals is a recurring theme in news from around the world. In Trabzon, Turkey, a dog named Boncuk waited for days outside the hospital where her owner was being treated in early 2021. Such cases are often described as loyalty, and in a sense they are: dogs are social animals that form strong attachments and tend to stay close to the person who feeds and protects them.
How you can help people and pets on the street
- Support local groups that provide food, vet care or pet-friendly shelter for people experiencing homelessness.
- Ask before helping. Offering water for a dog or a meal for its owner is often welcome; taking photos or posting about someone without permission may not be.
- Treat the owner with respect. As this story shows, a person without a home can be a devoted and responsible carer.
- Back hospitals and shelters that plan for patients’ animals, so nobody has to choose between treatment and their dog.
Sources: My Modern Met; News24 / YOU, December 2018; CNN Chile; previously reported by Positive Outlooks; Revista Pesquisa FAPESP on Ipea homelessness estimates; Wikipedia: Homelessness in Brazil. Photo: Cris Mamprim via Facebook.
COMMENTS